bughunter
Saturday, February 26, 2005 6:59:00 AM
Hey Guys/ Gals,

Newbee here. I need a little insight from some of you seasoned professionals. Just starting out and I was wondering if I'm better off picking up a few of the lower priced "No-named" smokes and trying to find one I like, or if I should put up the extra cash for the more popular brands. Is it a get-what-you-pay-for product. No idea where it start. Any insight to brands and direction would be helpful. Thanks a bunch,

Bug

SteveR@CigarBid
Saturday, February 26, 2005 7:51:00 AM
bughunter - Sampler packs are a great way to explore your palate while giving you a chance to try some of the better known brands for far less than you'll ever see on a retail shelf. I'd recommend some of the non-brand specific samplers that feature a large variety of different names. You'll find a nice array of cigars that vary in strength, maker and country of origin. Over time, you'll begin to key in on what agrees with your palate and what doesn't. Also, never judge a cigar by its price, the hype it receives in magazines or ratings. Nobody can tell you what you will enjoy. A cigar with a high dollar value or well known name on the band doesn't make it any better than an un-banded $1 smoke. The fact that you enjoy smoking it makes it a good cigar. There are a lot of fantastic smokes out there that are often overlooked. My advice: keep an open mind, have fun and enjoy the wonderful world of cigars for its wealth in variety!
Ridgerunner65
Saturday, February 26, 2005 7:56:00 AM
Bug, why not do both? You can sample more when you try the less expensive, but if you invest too heavily in the better brands, you'll sample less. In either case, search boards for recommendations regarding the best bang for the buck. Obviously, your experience may vary, but there's lots of information. If you already have preferences [eg go for a mild-2-medium, like criollo, etc], build from there.

If you plan on "easing in" I recommend the strategy of using the Cbid 'watchlist' feature, to track several weeks of winning prices here for items you'd like to try [as well as determing what you'd be willing to pay]. You might find that brand x usually sells for close to your locals' prices [factoring in shipping]. Then you can try a single & if you like it, go for a discount win on CBid.

HOWEVER, BEWARE THE LURE OF THE DARKSIDE. You may [succumb as many of us have] to buying cigars much faster than you'll ever smoke them. When that happens, you'll readily understand how some FOGs have so many well-aged cigars!

Welcome - & enjoy

countryboy83
Saturday, February 26, 2005 8:53:00 AM
a line of cigars you shoul get aquinted with is CAO... and great advice from Steve about starting with the samplers.

Country

docrks
Saturday, February 26, 2005 9:03:00 AM
One of the real pleasures for me with this thing of ours is that it:

truly is the journey ----- and not the destination.....

When I started - I tried as many different brands as I coulkd get my hands on ---- one of the 1st that I tried I still value as one of my personal favorites - the PADRON line from Nic. Although I have now settled in with the PAM Serie 64 Torps and Imperials - their "Regular" line of "x000", especially for my tastes the 3000, 4000,5000 and 6000 ---what a great cigar and an EXCELLENT value for the money !!!!

There are so many wonderful taste adventures awaiting you ---some cigars I tried were soon discarded and I never spent another penny on that brand - but some brands I discovered when I first started I have held onto and still occasionally visit when the occasion presents itself...

Also keep a look out for the Newbie Sampler which every so often appears on the Boards - a great way to experience a spectrum of various product and meet some new BOTLs......

Keep in mind - it's the journey that is its own reward...not just the destination.

lukin
Saturday, February 26, 2005 9:32:00 AM
I can tell you what I bought when I was just starting out, what was good, and what was bad...

Ten Pack La Finca Robustos (not great)

Two Torano Samplers from CI (at the time they had them on special for like 2 for 39 dollars...awesome deal)

Ten Pack Ghurka Class Regent Toros (another awesome smoke)

RyJ Bully's (decent)

Box of Padron Londres (for my money the best value in cigars. I think its like 55.00 at CI for a box)

If I were you, I would head over to CI, look at the samplers they have over there, decide what looks good to you, buy a couple over here and decide for yourself. One word of caution though....if you get a sampler, make sure that there are two of each smoke in each one. I don't think that it is possible to judge a cigar on first smoke.

Burky4467
Saturday, February 26, 2005 9:52:00 AM
Bug-

Welcome! If you can afford it, buy a little of everything. Fivers and sample packs are the way to go. After a few purchases you should find a "go to" brand. Don't stop there, the fun is always trying new ones. Join a b-day club, trade or something like that. You will get a bunch of different ones to try. Enjoy your time here.

Burky

0patience
Saturday, February 26, 2005 12:13:00 PM
I agree with the sampler packs. A great way to determine what you like and don't like.

As was said,

CAO, Torano are great lines and you can't go wrong with any of their products.

Also, check out Drew Estate's LaVieja Habana line, very inexpensive and a nice everyday smoke.

Flor de Oliva is another reasonably priced line.

One thing I will say, there are some that you will see consistantly low prices on the bids, it should tell you something. But then again, they may be to your liking. I have bought some cigars that were dirt cheap on the auction, only to find out first hand why they were so cheap.

Unfortunately, it is a personal preferance thing and the only way is to learn for yourself what is good for you and what is not.

I could list cigars that I like and there will be others that will say they hate the same cigar.

I happen to love the cameroon cigars, but there are folks who don't care for them.

Balancing cost with quality and flavor is tough, but if you have patience and keep an eye out, there are great deals to be had.

Long winded as usual, I wish I could be of more help. 😉

myash07
Saturday, February 26, 2005 12:16:00 PM
Bug

Do ya like smokes that are:

Full body

Medium

mild...?

Small or large ring guage?

bughunter
Saturday, February 26, 2005 1:14:00 PM
You guys are the best. I sure appreciate all of the helpful advice. The recommendations are really helpful.

In repsonse to myash: In my experiences thus far I've been leaning toward a small to medium ring gage, full body smoke. I definately prefer a maduro flavor. But I'm not locked into anything in particular.

Thanks again.

Bug

18delta
Saturday, February 26, 2005 1:59:00 PM
bughunter,

e-mail me at [email protected]

Wyteyes
Saturday, February 26, 2005 3:44:00 PM
Hey Bug, Buy up a bunch of samplers, figure out what you like and then bundle up the rest and send them to the OpFTH project. Ping Schmitty22 for that. Not everybody likes the same smoke or there would only be one brand.

John

bughunter
Monday, February 28, 2005 7:11:00 AM
18delta

..........email sent

bug

muaythaiguy
Monday, February 28, 2005 7:40:00 AM
Bug, Steve is pretty much on the money with his suggestions. A sampler is a good way to start but at the same token, the sampler you purchase should consist of two of the same. Don't get a sampler that consists of one of each but try a sampler that has two or three of each. Sometimes the first one is not as you anticipated and need a second to make sure that what you recently ate or drank didn't affect your tastebuds. Cigars are like wine and women, we all love em but we all have different tastes. Don't be afraid to explore different sticks. Welcome and good luck!
John hay Cigars
Monday, February 28, 2005 7:45:00 AM
Bug, welcome, I just started out not too long ago myself. I bought samples of everything. Mostly on the lower end but have worked my way up. Send me an email with your address and I will send some that are taking up space. johnhaycigars at aol dot com
CWFoster
Monday, February 28, 2005 5:36:00 PM
Bughunter, first welcome to the zoo! Second, I'd like to pass along some insights.

1)buy five packs for awhile!

-I have a few boxes of cigars I thought were delicious, until my tastes changed. Now they are WAY too mild!

2)Don't plunk down money on a fancy humidor right away!

-Most of the guys on here can tell you you will NOT be able to keep up buying humis fast enough to store all the smokes you will score on here (in auctions, gifts, b-day clubs, ect.) Go for an economical mass storage solution now! I like the huge plastic storage containers myself, and since I have ten or so boxes of cigars in each, and just keep plastic trays full of loose skes setting on top of the boxes, I dont fret over Spanish Cedar lining.

3)What was said above about trying at least two of a cigar before rendering a judgement goes in SPADES, also a change in vitolas (sizes) can make a drastic difference. Some cigars I absolutely LOVE smoke like crap in a small ring gauge, and vice versa. If you buy a five-pack of somethiing and you don't care for them, lay them up, and try them again in five or six months. Sometimes a bit of age does wonders, but at your stage of the game, your tastes are bound to evolve somewhat, and you may find they taste the same, but you like them later.

Have fun, and don't hurt yourself! :^)

dave97402
Monday, February 28, 2005 5:54:00 PM
Bug...welcome....first stay away from delta!!

Yeah the 5 pack is the way to go. I actually still buy more 5 packs than boxes. Usually if your patient you can get them cheaper than by the box anyway. Try ones you are sure of more than once before deciding you do or don't like it. Get on over to the newbie trade threads and see if you can get in on a little trade with some of the vets over there. We have a habit of providing pretty good variety for you to try....and have fun

Dave

CWFoster
Monday, February 28, 2005 5:57:00 PM
Daves one of the good 'uns!
sli38
Monday, February 28, 2005 6:09:00 PM
From another point of view......start at the top and work your way down. you can always trade away premi's. If you like full bodied smokes you probably wont be disapointed. this can save you from having an abundance of mediocre smokes taking up space in your humi down the road.

Life is to short to smoke cheap cigars.

bughunter
Wednesday, March 2, 2005 4:03:00 AM
Thanks again guys for all the help. As most of you have said, not every guy likes every cigar. I think I'll start with a few of the brands you guys suggested, with a preconcieved notion towards a maduro. Thanks again for all of the insight.

One more thing. Waht makes a good cigar a good cigar, and what makes a cheap cigar a bad cigar?

Bug