lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, March 15, 2005 12:55:00 PM
I'm starting this thread over here that way we can keep the trade thread from gettting too long and also so others can see the reviewed cigars. IF anyone wants to refer to the box pass itself please use this address

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/forum/forum.cfm?action=list&forumID=6&messageDisplay=0000000033659 

Here is what has been reviewed so far....

From Dice7711

Smoked #21 tonight, haven't done a review before so here it goes -- 6.5inch, 54(?) ring , toothy pyriamid with what looks like a cameroon wrapper. Fairly well constructed. Started out a little bitter, but smoothed out some as it got going. Not terribly complex. Spicey-sweet flavors with a hint of nuts. Produced a dark grey ash that flaked a bit. Lots of smoke with a short finish. Draw was a bit tight and burn was a little uneven. Just okay IMHO . dice7711

Cigar: 6 year aged Corojo (no brand name) put in by Lukin

Just finished #18, a 4.5 in., 50 ring robusto -- wow, now we're talking. Fine contruction with a dark maduro wrapper. Great pre-light aroma. This stick started out very good and got even better. Good draw and lots of smoke. Flavors of chocolate and coffee. Complex but not overwelming. Held a long strong light grey ash, that when it finally fell off, left a perfect glowing orange point. Had to get out the roach clip for this one. Need I say more?

Cigar:La Finca Robusto Black put in by Lukin

From Homebrew so far

Alright,

Here is my review of smoke #31

This cigar is a Long torpedo. With about a 50 ring foot, tapering down to about a 43 ring at the cap. It is a box pressed cigar, with a caramel colored natural wrapper.

This cigar is a beauty, with a seamless wrapper, that glistens in the sun, with an abundance of oils. It is a very firm roll, with no soft spots. After snipping, which was straight and true, the prelight draw, is firm, with almost no flavor. Upon lighting, the flavor starts very mild. My initial thought upon lighting, was CREAMY. When you here guys talk about a nice creamy cigar, this is what they are talking about. Very smooth with a nice medium body, creamy with notes of nuts and vanilla. I am hooked. The construction of this smoke, is amazing. The draw, while slightly firm, yields a huge volume of very tasty smoke. About an inch into this smoke, I am starting to get a touch of spice, with the flavors herbal tea. I can’t put my finger on the blend, but I have had an herbal tea, that has a very similar flavor. This thing is complex. Every puff yields a different flavor. One Puff gives me a sweet creamy vanilla flavor, the next puff the herbal tea, the next puff leather and nuts. I am loving this cigar, and know that this has to be a high dollar cigar. The construction is top notch, this ash is holding very firm past the 2 inch mark, and the burn has been razor straight. The strength and body, build as the smoke gets into the last third. Moving up into a nice full bodied finish. Though it didn’t make me weak in the knees, there is a strength there, which left me with a very pleasant buzz. The flavor profile reminds me of a well aged pardon.

The amazing changes that took place, over the smoking of this cigar, has sold me. Though I normally smoke maddies, this smoke is up there with my favorites.

On a 5 point scale, I would have to give this smoke a 4.7 excellent. Due to the superior construction, and superior blending of this, gotta be, world class cigar. If I were to Guess, I would say a PAN64. I Love it.

Great smoke.

Did I tell you that I loved this smoke?

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

Cigar: PAN 64 Pyramid put in by Dice7711

From Bassdude:

Smoked 33 today after a lunch of LJS fish and shrimp with cheese curds.

natural wrapped beli size. smells like cedar and sparkles in the sunlight - wrapper has many small veins.

prelight draw is good and has hints of black licorice and pepper. toasted the foot and met up with a bitter taste. the bitterness mellowed and is not unpleasant(similar to a bitter ale) very reminiscent of a blind habano I had last week. third way through still bitter with a bittersweet aftertaste. cigar is becoming earthy. half way even more earthy(aftertaste of, well dirt) still slightly bitter nothing like the blind habano. 2 inch mark hints of pepper, slightly earthy and still bitter. hmmm noticing a habano type twang not too bad of a finish. ash was very dark with a gray center.

not bad, I enjoyed the bitter tatse but not the dirt. i almost tossed it but it started to let up.

Cigar: 04 BBF put in by Homebrew

lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, March 21, 2005 9:52:00 AM
I thought I would bump this up so we could use this thread for posting reviews....I'll copy and paste Homie's review into here
lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, March 21, 2005 9:54:00 AM
Here is Homie's reviews of cigar number 12....

Mystery BoxPass Smoke #12

A boxpressed Corona Very smooth chocolate collored wrapper, with almost seamless appearance. Looks like a great smoke. Starts out slightly peppery, with notes of leather. A little uneven burn, at first, but that might be due to improper lighting. About a half inch in, I am starting to get a strong coffee taste, more like a mocha back with strong coffee overtones. At ¾ “ the burn is still uneven, though not as pronounced. I am getting a slight metallic taste, not to the point of unpalatable, just a slightly unpleasent distraction from the other flavors. Might be something additional ageing can fix. This appears to be quite the complex little smoke. The metallic taste is gone, and has been replaced with fruity undertones, almost like raspberries. The main flavor is still coffee, but, with notes of leather, nuts berries, and an occasional metallic taste. At one inch, the burn has completely corrected itself, showing quality construction. The spice continues to grow, and builds in strength, for the duration of this cigar. It really builds to a firecracker, but I enjoyed every puff, with exception of that metallic taste. The metallic taste, is what has dropped my rating. Otherwise this is a great smoke.

Due to excellent construction, and for the most part great flavor and complexity, I have to give this smoke, a 4.2, on a five point scale. Assuming, that a little more aging would get rid of the metallic taste, and the price is not prohibitive, I would probably pick up some of these.

Later

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

Homebrew
Monday, March 21, 2005 10:06:00 AM
Just a guess, but I think #12, was a rocky patel product. Maybe an IT SuperFuerte???

Later

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, March 21, 2005 10:09:00 AM
Actually, I live a half hour from the university, my bank, and my B&M (all of which happen to be within a block of one another). I started buying these there at 5 bucs a stick, before I broke down and bought a box. They are my favorite drive home smoke....A Padron Maduro Londres. An excellent half hour smoke for around two bucks a stick.
ryantp
Monday, March 21, 2005 10:18:00 AM
post more!
Homebrew
Monday, March 21, 2005 11:42:00 AM
OK

Mystery Box Pass Smoke #28

Dark Maduro Petit Belicoso, with a slight boxpress. Some veins, but not enough to be a major detraction.

Prelight aroma of leather and manure. Hmm Weird mix.

Construction seems OK with no underfilled portions. The cut was smooth and straight.

The first puff seemed kind of bland, but it does change, about the third or fourth puff, when a little spice comes into play, and the cigar gets much richer. I am getting a slight musty taste from this smoke, though not really unpleasant, it doesn’t really add anything either. This smoke is leathery and earthy, with slight notes of pumpkin pie spice.

The burn is straight, and it is obviously well rolled. At 3/4”, the flavors are still the same, except the musty flavor has all but disappeared.

Ahhh, At about the one inch mark, I start to get the flavor of anise. This is one of my favorite flavors to get from a cigar, and I like the way the anise flavor builds in this cigar. Very nice. At about the half way mark, the ash is still holding firmly, and my lips are beginning to tingle. The burn got a little crooked when It hit one vein, about 1 1/2” to go, but the flavors remained strong. At about one inch to go I let it go out. This was a good solid daily smoke, if the price is right. The musty start, and the vein throwing the burn off near the end, were the main detractors. I would have to give this cigar a 3.9. And if I were to make a guess, I would say that this is an Onyx Reserve, petit Belicoso.

Have a great day.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

dice7711
Monday, March 21, 2005 12:09:00 PM
Damn Homie you are good. You should do this for a living!! Right on the button sir. At around $2 the Onyx Mini is not a bad every day smoke. dice7711
*ferg*
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:35:00 PM
Mystery Cigar #37

When going through the cigars I was very drawn to this stick, more than any other

except for the two I chose that had triple caps. It looks to have some nice age on it, very

sparkly when rotated in the light as well as having some nice oils oozing all over. It is

Churchill/Double Corona in size, a dark chocolate maduro wrapper that I cannot wait to

toast. It is the first I pick from the bag of 5 as well; I know that I am looking forward to

smoking this cigar. It is very firm and obviously filled to the brim, it has a couple of

noticeable veins but all in all looks very yummy. The prelight draw is a bit firm, but

nothing that will impede the smoke. This stick has very distinguished notes of cocoa and

or chocolate, a very sweet medium/full bodied stick that is pleasant throughout. The

burn was a bit erratic; it followed that vein to a T..... only bad quality of the stick though. I enjoyed it thoroughly; I would not have a problem adding this stick to my humi for

regular consumption. I have not clue as to what it is, and look forward to finding out.

I believe this was added by Homie, would give it a 4.4 out of 5, it definitely fits my taste

profile, and look forward to getting some more.

*ferg*
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:35:00 PM
Mystery Cigar #9

The second I smoked from the bag of 5. I was drawn to this stick because of the triple

cap and the size. In fact it looks exactly like one of my favorite cigars. It was however

packed in cello, which is why I am sure that it threw the others before me for a loop. I

thought to myself, I can’t believe this gar made it past the others, but oh well it is mine

now. The smell is of definite barnyard, it’s a 6" x 52, a very rich caramel wrapper, with flawless construction. Light, draw, burn, etc are top notch. It has taste of cream, cocoa,

and a very noticeable twang. If this cigar is not a Cohiba Siglo VI, I have definitely been

fooled. I would give this cigar a 4.6 out of 5……

*ferg*
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:35:00 PM
Mystery Cigar #43

I was drawn to this cigar because of the appearance and size. It is a beautiful stick, very

dark, a nearly seamless wrapper, well filled, with very small veins. It seems to have some nice age on it, and it has obviously been well kept. The prelight draw is a little to easy, but I know that this is a good cigar.. It has notes of creamy chocolate and a nice little spice that built as the burn progressed. It had some minor burn problems, but I think that was due to the idiot that torched it. All in all, a very enjoyable smoke. It definitely reminds me of a CAO Brazilia/Italia, its hard for me to tell much difference. But with the noticeable spiciness, I would say it was a Brazilia. I enjoy these on a regular basis, If I am incorrect, I will definitely add these to my rotation if the price is right. I would give this cigar a 4.4 out of 5.

*ferg*
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:36:00 PM
Mystery Cigar #13

I was drawn to this cigar because it was a perfecto, looking like a Gurkha Anniv. or XX.

Prelight draw was tight, which I find to be a problem with the Gurkha perfecto's, but I knew from experience that it would open up. In fact I am not so sure that I might not have accidentally smoked this puppy backwards. A friend came over, and we talked a bit and caught up on old time, I apologize, we have not seen each other in quite some time, so I do not have a lot to say about this stick. It was definitely an enjoyable experience, just wish I would have had the time to give the stick it’s proper due.

One cigar to go, I believe it to be ISOM as well, but I will see how it fares with the others. So far I am very happy with the sticks that I chose, I believe them all to be in the upper echelon.

lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:39:00 PM
In the words of Roger Daltrey...."Meet the New Boss same as the old Boss.....We won't get fooled again!!!!" If I ever had a Cohiba in my humi, I would have been to afraid it was a fake to send it out. That my friend was a La Aroma de Cuba Marquis. An excellent smoke that Mydsooner turned me on to (although I think he sent me the cuban Corona or something like that) Wonderful smoke and one of my favorites.
lukin
  • lukin
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:40:00 PM
number 13 was indeed the Ghurka Anniversary Perfecto. It was the only dead giveaway in the bunch (considering very few rollers make the Perfecto like this).
*ferg*
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:45:00 PM
Sweet, guess I will have to get some more and see if it was a fluke or all in my mind.

That one was definately an enjoyable experience. I am definately not an experienced ISOM smoker by any means.

I can say that I was delightfully fooled on this one.

Off to find a few to purchase......

Homebrew
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:48:00 PM
#37 was an A.Fuentes Double Chateau Maduro.

It had about 4 years in my humi. I love that chocolate flavor I get from these.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

*ferg*
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:50:00 PM
Homie,I will definately be grabbing some of these. A sincerley enjoyable smoke.

Thank you for the experience of a fine aged cigar.

Homebrew
Monday, March 21, 2005 4:55:00 PM
Mystery Box pass smoke #24.

A maduro Perfecto, with an extreme box press.

I tend to like box pressed cigars, so I was looking forward to this perfecto.

The prelight aroma was of spice, with a touch of manure. Just like I like it. LOL

Very densly packed, with no lumps or soft spots. I worry that the draw may be too tight, but I will not really know, until I light it. Had a slightly uneven cut, due to user error, but I believe it will smoke fine. Any thoughts of a tight draw, is dispelled by an explosion of fragrant smoke. Initially I an greeted by a slightly sweet leathery flavor, followed by a fruity finish. Flavors of cinnamon and nutmeg, lightly caress my palate, while the leather and light sweetness are still the most predominate flavors. The burn, is slightly uneven, but the flavors are more than making up for it. The cigar is becoming much richer, and creamy, though the leather flavor lingers, a mocha cream flavor has moved to the forefront, and becomes much more dominate after you get to the one inch mark. This cigar, will be joining my regular rotation, if the price is right. It is reminding me of one of my favorite daly smokes, but due to the different vitola is a much more complex smoke. Alternating between a café Mocha, and honey with cream, the flavors vary with each puff. The body goes from medium to full, as I nub this beauty. . I am not sure if I had this one in the humi long enough, or if it was just poor construction, the burn was just uneven, and never fixed itself.

I really enjoyed the flavors on this smoke, though I did have some burn problems, the flavors made me rate this smoke a 4.2 on the five point scale.

I hate to guess what this smoke is, for fear it will drive up the bids, on this stick. I believe that this is the sleeper, Perdomo2 Torfecto Maduro.

I have seen boxes of these go for less than $50, but no more, if I am right.

Later

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

bassdude
Monday, March 21, 2005 5:34:00 PM
#43 - should have gone with your second guess.
dice7711
Monday, March 21, 2005 5:54:00 PM
Right again Homie, 24 was the Perdomo2 Torfecto Maduro. You can still find them for about $2 a stick. You are on a roll!