I'm starting this thread over here that way we can keep the trade thread from gettting too long and also so others can see the reviewed cigars. IF anyone wants to refer to the box pass itself please use this address
http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/forum/forum.cfm?action=list&forumID=6&messageDisplay=0000000033659
Here is what has been reviewed so far....
From Dice7711
Smoked #21 tonight, haven't done a review before so here it goes -- 6.5inch, 54(?) ring , toothy pyriamid with what looks like a cameroon wrapper. Fairly well constructed. Started out a little bitter, but smoothed out some as it got going. Not terribly complex. Spicey-sweet flavors with a hint of nuts. Produced a dark grey ash that flaked a bit. Lots of smoke with a short finish. Draw was a bit tight and burn was a little uneven. Just okay IMHO . dice7711
Cigar: 6 year aged Corojo (no brand name) put in by Lukin
Just finished #18, a 4.5 in., 50 ring robusto -- wow, now we're talking. Fine contruction with a dark maduro wrapper. Great pre-light aroma. This stick started out very good and got even better. Good draw and lots of smoke. Flavors of chocolate and coffee. Complex but not overwelming. Held a long strong light grey ash, that when it finally fell off, left a perfect glowing orange point. Had to get out the roach clip for this one. Need I say more?
Cigar:La Finca Robusto Black put in by Lukin
From Homebrew so far
Alright,
Here is my review of smoke #31
This cigar is a Long torpedo. With about a 50 ring foot, tapering down to about a 43 ring at the cap. It is a box pressed cigar, with a caramel colored natural wrapper.
This cigar is a beauty, with a seamless wrapper, that glistens in the sun, with an abundance of oils. It is a very firm roll, with no soft spots. After snipping, which was straight and true, the prelight draw, is firm, with almost no flavor. Upon lighting, the flavor starts very mild. My initial thought upon lighting, was CREAMY. When you here guys talk about a nice creamy cigar, this is what they are talking about. Very smooth with a nice medium body, creamy with notes of nuts and vanilla. I am hooked. The construction of this smoke, is amazing. The draw, while slightly firm, yields a huge volume of very tasty smoke. About an inch into this smoke, I am starting to get a touch of spice, with the flavors herbal tea. I can’t put my finger on the blend, but I have had an herbal tea, that has a very similar flavor. This thing is complex. Every puff yields a different flavor. One Puff gives me a sweet creamy vanilla flavor, the next puff the herbal tea, the next puff leather and nuts. I am loving this cigar, and know that this has to be a high dollar cigar. The construction is top notch, this ash is holding very firm past the 2 inch mark, and the burn has been razor straight. The strength and body, build as the smoke gets into the last third. Moving up into a nice full bodied finish. Though it didn’t make me weak in the knees, there is a strength there, which left me with a very pleasant buzz. The flavor profile reminds me of a well aged pardon.
The amazing changes that took place, over the smoking of this cigar, has sold me. Though I normally smoke maddies, this smoke is up there with my favorites.
On a 5 point scale, I would have to give this smoke a 4.7 excellent. Due to the superior construction, and superior blending of this, gotta be, world class cigar. If I were to Guess, I would say a PAN64. I Love it.
Great smoke.
Did I tell you that I loved this smoke?
Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)
Cigar: PAN 64 Pyramid put in by Dice7711
From Bassdude:
Smoked 33 today after a lunch of LJS fish and shrimp with cheese curds.
natural wrapped beli size. smells like cedar and sparkles in the sunlight - wrapper has many small veins.
prelight draw is good and has hints of black licorice and pepper. toasted the foot and met up with a bitter taste. the bitterness mellowed and is not unpleasant(similar to a bitter ale) very reminiscent of a blind habano I had last week. third way through still bitter with a bittersweet aftertaste. cigar is becoming earthy. half way even more earthy(aftertaste of, well dirt) still slightly bitter nothing like the blind habano. 2 inch mark hints of pepper, slightly earthy and still bitter. hmmm noticing a habano type twang not too bad of a finish. ash was very dark with a gray center.
not bad, I enjoyed the bitter tatse but not the dirt. i almost tossed it but it started to let up.
Cigar: 04 BBF put in by Homebrew