I don't watch it; however...I HAVE watched it.
My mother, who is a teacher, tutored a young man who was home-bound for reasons that really aren't appropriate to discuss here. She did it for about a year. She came to be good friends with the entire family; a very interesting, hard worker, and artistic family.
The young man she tutored was a contestant who apparently advanced into the higher levels of AI.
For this reason, I tuned in a few times in hopes of seeing him perform.
In the end, he withdrew because of some moral issues he had with the American Idol organization (who seem to be real cocksuckers).
I never did see him in the few times I tuned in, but I was lucky enough to catch the "Pants on the Ground" performance and that really made my year.