Bubba7624
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 2:43:00 PM
I am pretty new to Cigar smoking, I know what I like and what I don't like. I do prefer a cigar with allot of flavor, med-full bodied.

My question here is:

When describing a cigar does med-full body have to do with the strength or the flavor?

When you describe a cigar as being complex is this refer to how many favors are present?

Last but not least when you refer to cigar as being one-dimensional is this to do with the flavor profile?

Maybe someone can better explain this so I can learn.

Thanks

Brian

lukin
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 2:53:00 PM
I'll try to answer as best I can:

1. The answer to the bodied questions is strength. A milder smoke will draw nice and easy, but generally not kick you in the butt. You will know a full flavored smoke when you get one. When I was a newbie, I enjoyed mild smokes, but the full flavored bad boys were too much for me. They were often too strong in flavor for me to appreiciate them. The more I smoke, the more I crave the fuller bodied stuff

2. As far as complexity, generally this is reffering to the flavors in cigars. A complex smoke will taste different throughout, and will have several different taste profiles. Some people are better at picking them out than others but even if you can't find the "notes of balsa wood" in your cigar, it is easy to detect that there are more than one flavor factor at work

3. A one dimensional cigar is the exact opposite. A one dimensional cigar is going to taste the same every time you draw from it. It will have one flavor profile and stay consistent throughout. Generally this is a bad thing

The best way to experience all of your questions first hand and see what I mean is to take a Macanudo Gold or something (IMHO way to mild and one dimensional) and smoke it back to back against something full bodied (CAO Italia or Brazilia would work nice) you will see a stark difference not just in strength but in the complexity of the cigar.

Homebrew
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 3:02:00 PM
Hey Bubba,

I'll try and help.

You Posted. "I am pretty new to Cigar smoking, I know what I like and what I don't like. I do prefer a cigar with allot of flavor, med-full bodied.

My question here is:

When describing a cigar does med-full body have to do with the strength or the flavor?

When you describe a cigar as being complex is this refer to how many favors are present?

Last but not least when you refer to cigar as being one-dimensional is this to do with the flavor profile?

Maybe someone can better explain this so I can learn."

I'll try my best, but there are others here which probably know better. So Remember this is just my opinion.

#1. When describing a cigar does med-full body have to do with the strength or the flavor?

To me, it has to do with the mouthfeel of the smoke. Is it a rich coating smoke?? That would be full bodied. Though most full bodied smokes are also strong, it is not always the case.

#2.When you describe a cigar as being complex is this refer to how many favors are present?

That, and how those flavors change and blend throughout the duration of the cigar.

#3.Last but not least when you refer to cigar as being one-dimensional is this to do with the flavor profile?

A one demensional smoke will be either bland or a monotonus smoke. Basically one taste, that never changes throughout the duration of a smoke. Or if it does change, changes for the worst.

I am not an expert,

But this is what I think.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

JSD
  • JSD
  • Connoisseur
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 3:41:00 PM
Bubba - one thing to try might be to smoke a Mild cigar and then comapre it to a full bodied smoke to see what you think and what you like. Maybe try a Macanudo and then the next day smoke something like a Joya de Nic Antano as a comparision - you will see the difference!! Just a suggestion...
andytv
Wednesday, March 23, 2005 3:39:00 AM
While I prefer "complex" smokes, there are many "one-dimensional smokes" that are great due to their consistency.

The Padron X000 series comes to mind as a smoke that is tasty the whole way through without really shifting gears(IMHO).

I'm with Dave (AKA Homebrew) on the "body". For me, there is a taste when you bring the smoke into your mouth, and another taste (or set thereof)after it is expelled. IMHO, the first hit indicates body, which fades into flavor. The two trade off somewhat.

With a dog rocket, the inital hit is harsh bitterness that prevents the acknowledgment of any flavors that may be present.

.........just my take on things.