grishulia
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:36:00 PM
Here is the situation...

---------------------

Let's say I've set autobid to $40 on 5 of 5, and right now the bid is at $31.

Someone comes in and bids $34 with an autobid set to $37 on 1 of 1.

---------------------

What I was expecting - my 1 of 5 goes to $37 and 4 of 5 sits at $31.

---------------------

What happened was - all 5 of 5 went to $37.

Now you tell me if this should be fixed... because I really don't think this is the way it should happen...

ASC
  • ASC
  • Aficionado
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:41:00 PM
Good point.

If it shouldn't be fixed...it seems like it would be best to bid 5 times for the quantity of 1. I dunno though. I'll be watching the replies here.

grishulia
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:42:00 PM
I don't think you can bid 5 times on 1 of 1...
tank71663
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:47:00 PM
unfortunately thats not the way it works...

you need to think of all 5 as individual bids

1 @ 31

1 @ 31

1 @ 31

1 @ 31 &

1 @ 31 with your auto bid set at 40

now if someone comes along and bids 34 on 1 lot with auto bid to 37 heres what will happen

his bid causes your 1st lot to go to 37 since you bid 1st, his bid then drops to the next lot which again causes that lot to go to 37 for the same reason..and so on and so on until he has been outbid on all lots avail and your left with

1 @ 37

1 @ 37

1 @ 37

1 @ 37

1 @ 37

I hope I explained it clearly, my wife says I have a nack for Konfuzing the issue...lol

ASC
  • ASC
  • Aficionado
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:48:00 PM
Sure you can. You just have to do it 5 seperate times.

IE: Quantity 1: 31, max 40 bid now

Repeat x4.

If there are 5 available...then the price on the first 4 shouldn't go up. I think this method would be rather moronic and defeating of the "multiple quantity" bid feature that is now available...but it would provide a quick fix to the problem.

Homebrew
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:49:00 PM
This is your post.

"Here is the situation...

---------------------

Let's say I've set autobid to $40 on 5 of 5, and right now the bid is at $31.

Someone comes in and bids $34 with an autobid set to $37 on 1 of 1.

---------------------

What I was expecting - my 1 of 5 goes to $37 and 4 of 5 sits at $31.

---------------------

What happened was - all 5 of 5 went to $37.

Now you tell me if this should be fixed... because I really don't think this is the way it should happen..."

Here is how I see it.

He was willing to spend $37 on any of those lots, not just one. That will make all lots jump to his max price, but since you were first, you retain the bids on all five. I believe that that is how it goes.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

pims14
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:49:00 PM
That isn't the way it works. Think of it this way...

You placed a bid on 5 lots. What would happen if the 5 lots had a maximum bid of $40 by 5 different people? All

5 lots have a current bid of 31. Someone bids a maximum of 37. What happens is that the person is still outbid and all 5 lots now are at the 37 mark.

Make any sense?

ASC
  • ASC
  • Aficionado
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:53:00 PM
Yowsers.

4 posts in 2 minutes time.

Please disregard my last one. 🙂 Thanks

tank71663
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 4:53:00 PM
also you can only have 1 winning bid at a time, so you could not make 5 seperate bids on the same lot number
grishulia
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 6:11:00 PM
Call it what you want, justify it all you like and make all kinds of work arounds this is still bad coding and bad quality control...
jetblasted
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 6:14:00 PM
Sour Grapes ?

ASC
  • ASC
  • Aficionado
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 7:03:00 PM
Well...

Look at the other auction site...

The big unmentionable one that doesn't sell cigars...

Only their boxes.

When someone is selling something dutch...does it raise all of the prices? I don't know...I was just curious if anyone knew...who could throw that in for comparison.

VotTak
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 7:11:00 PM
The only way you can place 4 bids on the same lot is in case you place them under DIFFERENT user name. Sometimes it is helpfull although you gonna collect all shipping sharges
todd38sd
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 8:59:00 PM
i don't think the bidding is bugged....it is just the way an auction with multiple lots works.

if your top bid on 5 lots is $40 for each lot....that means you are willing to pay that amount for EACH lot.

and EACH lot is actually a SEPERATE auction.

so when someone bids $34 the computer will go to each seperate lot and see if that is enough to win it. if not, the lots go up.....one at a time, until all of your bids have beaten the $34 offer.

to put it another way...the only way they can raise only one of your lots would be to accept the lesser offer and take one of the lots away from you...which makes no sense cause your bid is higher than the other guys.

it really isn't a problem with their coding...it is just the way an auction on multiple lots works.

not many ways to avoid it. if you want to try to limit the amount you have to spend to win a few lots you may want to wait till the last minute....put in your high bid on all lots and see how many you win.

hope this helps.

todd38sd
Tuesday, March 22, 2005 9:00:00 PM
actually tank did a damn good job of working this one out....so never mind! LOL
Slimboli
Wednesday, March 23, 2005 2:49:00 AM
Obviously grishulia ... you know very little how auctions work.
John hay Cigars
Wednesday, March 23, 2005 4:27:00 AM
Homebrew and pims made it very clear to me. Sounds legit.
medemax
Wednesday, March 23, 2005 5:30:00 AM

How to solve your problem? Buy one (1) box instead of five fivers. That way when someone bumps your bid up, you'll know why it happened.

teedubbya
Wednesday, March 23, 2005 5:38:00 AM
I think it is perfectly ok the way it is set up. I'd be upsed if I was willing to go up to $40 on each of 5 boxes/fivers, but won 4 @ $34 and someone else won 1 at $37.

That is assuming I really wanted all 5. Now if I didn't want all 5 was gaming the thing then I'd want it "fixed" as you suggest.

I would however like the ability to bid on each separately.

teedubbya
Wednesday, March 23, 2005 5:40:00 AM
ubsed = upset when I don't have my coffee yet