Just a couple of points of clarification here:
1) Rentboy's story sorta smells. I find it very hard to believe that if someone is going to hire a male prostitute for sex, he's going to do more than nude massages without the "happy ending."
2) If you're a preacher, and you claim to follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, you have to follow his example. Christ actively sought-out sinners in order to convert them. You don't convert sinners from afar.
3) I find it difficult, at this point, to take the word of a male prostitute who was willing to take $75.00 a day to carry someones's sack...er...baggage. I think someone decided they could make more money by making up a scadelous story and selling it to the press.
4) If this guy is so stupid to think that he wouldn't get caught after what they did to Haggard, he deserves to go down in flames.