Steve-
Sometime in life, a roller and tobacco make a very important decision. A cigar is rolled, and it is a beauty. The flavors are nice and eveerything is settled. Then, it hits puberty, and everything goes downhill for a while. This is known as the "sick period" where it's at its worse. Flavors and such are off, and it's just not cool. However, once it grows up and gets out of this sick period, it tastes great (sometimes better than before now that the tobacco has set in and the flavors show up as they should).
For more info, do a forum search on "sick period." Maybe some more extensive info there, though I tried to relate it to the human life cycle. Oh, and yes; cigars do get old and eventually past their prime. However, if you do get the chance to enjoy an aged cigar savor it. Mmmm, now I'm craving one of my 1999 Cupidos. Hehe.
Stefan