It has been updated within the last year, because I remember very well that whole thing with Gamelover going down as well as the Archmage1 (who by the way has no relation to Archimark) stealing the box pass. However, no mention of Pepsiman (who I believe is gamelover) or pimpstickdaddy. The best way to be sure is to make sure that the BOTL/SOTL you are trading with post their trade here and not through e-mail (this allows others to see the username and warn people if needed) search for the name here, and if you are still not certain, ask for vets advice or references. Also, when unfamiliar, ask the trader to send his end first.
I personally think that a rule ought to be established that until a trader participates in the newbie trade thread or at the very least the PIB then he/she ought to be held suspect. I realize this attitude hurts the newbies, but there are far to many generous people here to risk losing their experience and trades.