Okay okay okay....I am going to help you out the easiest way.
http://www.cigarsinternational.com/html/cig101_main.asp
Cigars 101. This should help you out greatly. Read as many posts as you can, and absorb the knowledge. There's a newbies thread on here that'll get you going as well.
You do not just "puff and taste the smoke." Take a draw, let the smoke drift over your entire palate, then exhale. Do not inhale! Be relaxed, and try to see what tastes come to mind. Many of the members (myself included) post reviews on cigars, and they describe flavors.
Based on what you described for size, I would suggest going for anything around the size of a 5x50. Basic robusto size with good flavor and such.
Go to that link above, and read ALL the topics. it will have all the info you need. Welcome to the forums.
Stefan