It does depend on the humidor. Some humidors have flaws in them that do not allow them to maintain a tight seal. They could be cheaply made, old or have been seasoned wrong. Any humidor that you buy can end up warping and then they are no good. IMO most humidors are designed to look good, and I think that just about any humidor that is made by someone who knows what they are doing will at least start off functioning properly. I think that time will be the real test. jmho
Are you looking to buy one, just wondering, or are you having problems?
Que