fishbopper
Saturday, May 28, 2005 4:47:00 AM
I have never had a Cuban cigar. Are they really worth the trouble and expense?

Seems like some "legal ones" get higher ratings.

keitha13
Saturday, May 28, 2005 6:01:00 AM
Ratings Shmatings, ratings mean nothing, trial + error. As I expected it was confirmed to me by 2 sources most (not all) of these high ratings are from companies buying the biggest advertisements.
Slimboli
Saturday, May 28, 2005 6:36:00 AM
In a word ... no.

Sorry Cuban cigar lovers of the world ... but I just don't get it. Granted, there are some exceptionally fine Cuban cigars out there ...

... but on the average ...

... they are no better than many of the domestic brands out there, and I've found many Nicaraguan puros, Dominicans, Hondurans, and 'blends' that are far superior to Cuban cigars ...

... and you don't have the confication issues, the worry of counterfeits, the hassels, etc. It's just not worth the trouble to me.

I don't really know what gets into some people ... maybe they have a more refined palate than I do ... but I don't taste anything extra special about the majority of them.

I know several people who smoke Cuban cigars just to be cool, to be in the 'in' crowd ... hey, the 'mystic', I'm smoking an 'ISOM' ... but they couldn't tell the real deal from a fake if their life depended on it.

To each their own ... that's what makes the world go around.

Slimboli
Saturday, May 28, 2005 6:40:00 AM
keitha13 --- you are right about CA, I've heard the same thing ...

... but Smoke Mag doesn't not give high ratings based on ad revenue (never has), nor do several of the 'newer' mags that have recently come out.

Still, I don't pay attention to ratings, because that is just the collective data from a handful of chosen panelists. Taste is highly subjective, you know ... and your opinions may not agree.

DiceMan
Saturday, May 28, 2005 6:54:00 AM
Cuban Shmuban, I smoke CAOs!
trainerchad
Saturday, May 28, 2005 7:21:00 AM
It all depends on your palate. I'd bet over 90% of cigar smokers would say that cubans are overrated. The vast majority of average smokers still buy mild stuff. Granted there are some great non-cubans out there but once you get ahold of the real deal, and assuming you have the palate for them, there is no alternative to cubans. They have that certain taste that you crave and nothing else can quite live up to it.

The money shouldn't be that big of an issue. There are some darn good cubans that you don't have to spend a fortune on and cost the same or less as some of the super premo non cubans. If you're going to do it, find a reputable place and you shouldn't have any issues with confiscation and fakes.

pierce652
Saturday, May 28, 2005 7:29:00 AM
First off forget the ratings and reviews unless they come from one of these cigar forums and even then take them with a grain of salt. Look at CA and Smoke magazines. What stogies do they review? Look at the full page adds...they review those same smokes. Now tell me, if someone is handing you money are you gonna slam them? No way. The reviews are crap. A Topper Cosmo got like a 90 rating!!! Please, I can pick up after my dog, light it and have a bette smoke than that.

I agree that many many domestics are excellent cigars and most of the deal with Cubans is hype and the mystique of the illegality of the whole thing. Also, I think it has to do with the whole history of the cigar industry.

keitha13
Saturday, May 28, 2005 8:25:00 AM
What Slimboli said to a T.
Charlie
Saturday, May 28, 2005 8:27:00 AM
I love the ISOM Montecristo #2 but are they worth the trouble and expense.....no, not when there are so damn many good cigars available today!

Charlie

Steve*R
Sunday, May 29, 2005 11:50:00 AM
trainerchad wrote: "The vast majority of average smokers still buy mild stuff."

Those of us who participate in cigar internet BBSs, read cigar themed magazines, participate in herfs and cigar banquets are a small, but vocal minority of cigar smokers. Most folks who light up are buying machine mades that are mild. They may never step foot in a tobacconist's or cigar shop, as they buy their Antonio Cleopatras, Dutch Masters, Harvesters, Phillies, etc. at their local drugstore, convenience store, or grocery.

"there is no alternative to cubans. They have that certain taste that you crave and nothing else can quite live up to it."

They're unique and it's not a matter of strength. Cuban tobacco has a very distinctive taste.

"There are some darn good cubans that you don't have to spend a fortune on and cost the same or less as some of the super premo non cubans."

Actually, there are some decent Cuban cigars that cost less than modest priced non-Cubans. Cuban Fonseca Delicias can be purchased for as little as $54.75 per 25 ct. box.

They are illegal for U.S. citizens and a hassle.

xibbumbero
Sunday, May 29, 2005 12:10:00 PM
A good Cuban cigar cannot be matched in taste by any cigar from any country. That being said,are they worth it? Yes and no. Some are but most are not. X
WaldoAR15
Sunday, May 29, 2005 12:29:00 PM

Slim. I smoked a Partagas Limited Reserve rolled in 1998. Probably one of the best Dominican Partagas I've ever had. I made the mistake of lighting up a PSD4 about an hour later. Can you guess which cigar I'll never buy again?

Buckwheat
Sunday, May 29, 2005 1:00:00 PM
Yes. There are great NC's out there that are every bit as good or better than cubans. However, all of the good NC's are waaaaayyyyy over priced compared to some outstanding run of the mill cubans (e.g. Party Short, Boli CJ, etc...). Rating are complete BS. Oh...and all Fuente products are overpriced crap...
fpaternostro
Sunday, May 29, 2005 4:05:00 PM
Thats what makes this hobby so much fun and enjoyable! Trying all these wonderful cigars from different countries to know for yourself which one you like best. You know the old saying, " The best cigar is the one you haven't smoked yet". In the last 10 years I've smoked cigars, I must have considered one my favorite 100 different times. LOL. My personal go to cigar is the MC #2. I've really tried to find a domestic that does it for me the way a good #2 does, but have not been successful yet. The thing is, the Domestics I do like and feel come real close are twice the cost. I have a box of MC's that have been aging now for 2 years and everytime I open that box, there is that deep, rich aroma that to me nothing else can touch and smoking them gives me an experience I just have never been able to duplicate with even the best domestics. Cubans definately have a distinct taste that is unlike any other cigars in the world and I think you'd be doing yourself a disservice to not at least try a few and see for yourself how they compare to domestics.
BeatDragon
Sunday, May 29, 2005 4:37:00 PM
Most in the cigar biz aknowledge that the tobacco grown on that Island is the benchmark leaf. Whether the current peoples in charge of that leaf are doing it justice is another story.

While I agree that there are some fine non-Cuban cigars that do indeed compare to their Island conterparts, VSG, La Aurora, Davidoff, Padron Anni's, certain Fuentes, but to say that they are superior to their Island counterparts is a matter of opinion, not fact. The best cigars I have ever smoked have been Cubans. Partagas EL Piramide, Cohiba SigioIV, PSD4, Boli CG Monte #2's HDM DC, to name a few. To bad they are a pain in the arse to obtain, and I believe there are more fakes out there than most would like to admit. If yer getting them for less than the Altadis price list, chances are they may be Cuban tobacco, but not legit Cuban brand cigars. If you can get authentic Cubans, they are at least worth trying once. But the fake to authentic ratio may be 100-1. The guys sellin fakes are thriving on the Americans obsession with this forbidden fruit.

I think Slims anti Cuban statements are in parallel to my opinon of BOOOOKaneros. He just dont get the Cuban thing as I dont get the BOOKanero thing. Oh well, it is what it is and its all good!

fpaternostro
Sunday, May 29, 2005 4:44:00 PM
I think the price thing used to be an issue back in the day, but I honestly don't see REALLY good domestics that are cheaper than cubans. Case and point, Waldo's Partagas choices. The Limited Reserve are almost twice the cost of PSD 4's. The hassle issue is another story, but the net has almost evened things out there as well. My advice, Smoke Em All! LOL.
fpaternostro
Sunday, May 29, 2005 4:52:00 PM
Ooops, one more suggestion. If you do decide to dabble with a few Habano's, try your best to find 04 boxes. It was a banner year for cuban cigars and is said by many will be considered the best ever. Every one I've tried so far has been outstanding. Just my 2 cents. Enjoy!
cmuzz
Sunday, May 29, 2005 4:53:00 PM
They are worth it and more. Its been over a year now since I have had anything that wasnt Cuban. Smokeing 4-7 gars a day and nothing is as satisfying as Cuban cigars.
donutboy2000
Sunday, May 29, 2005 5:33:00 PM
If you like the flavor profile, they may be worth it to you. Give them a try.

If CA rates a Cuban cigar highly, did Habanos pay them off? Obviously they did not buy any ads.

kdotline
Sunday, May 29, 2005 6:32:00 PM
I agree with fpaternostro - although I enjoy a wide range of domestics, from sherpas and occidental reserve to graycliff and PAMs, the only domestics that come close to the experience of good cubans cost two to three times as much. PSD4s, RASS, ELDM Chioix Supreme, and SLR Regios are all favorites now, and at $6-7 per stick, IMHO, are better than any domestic in that price range. but everyone has differant tastes, and different spending habits (it's not easy cutting down on the great cbid deals to save up for a box of cubans 🙂 )