RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 6:12:00 AM
WASHINGTON -

President Bush said Monday he believes schools should discuss "intelligent design" alongside evolution when teaching students about the creation of life.

During a round-table interview with reporters from five Texas newspapers, Bush declined to go into detail on his personal views of the origin of life. But he said students should learn about both theories, Knight Ridder Newspapers reported.

"I think that part of education is to expose people to different schools of thought," Bush said. "You're asking me whether or not people ought to be exposed to different ideas, the answer is yes."

The theory of intelligent design says life on earth is too complex to have developed through evolution, implying that a higher power must have had a hand in creation.

Christian conservatives — a substantial part of Bush's voting base — have been pushing for the teaching of intelligent design in public schools. Scientists have rejected the theory as an attempt to force religion into science education.

On other topics during the group interview, the president:

_Refused to discuss the investigation into whether political aide Karl Rove or any other White House official leaked a CIA officer's identity, but he stood behind Rove. "Karl's got my complete confidence. He's a valuable member of my team," Bush said.

_Said he did not ask Supreme Court nominee John Roberts about his views on Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision that legalized abortion.

_Said he hopes to work with Congress to pass an immigration reform bill this fall, including provisions for guest workers and enhanced security along the U.S.-Mexico border.

Bush spoke with reporters from the San Antonio Express-News, the Houston Chronicle, The Dallas Morning News, the Fort Worth Star-Telegram and The Austin American-Statesman.

after he spoke he was wrapped in his favorite warm blanket and given his crayons and his current coloring book, "the adventures of ****** and carl." it was noted that the president is getting much better staying in the lines.

Thom
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 7:50:00 AM
There is no biblical backing and there is no science backing for Intelligent Design. Come to think of it I don't know anyone who believes in Intelligent (or "Intelligent") Design.
billyjackson
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 7:57:00 AM
This thread has two possibilites....

1) Discuss the validity of Intelligent Design/Creationism

2) Discuss the issue of teaching it in public schools.

I'm sure both will be explored...and #1 might have to be discussed to answer #2.

==================

As to Thom...no biblical backing? Then the story of Creation is....?

==================

And no...I'm not necessarily for teaching creationism in schools. I'm for teaching science as far as it will go...then be honest as to its abilities to answer questions regarding existence...then leave the rest to religion/philosophy/etc/parents.

billyjackson
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 8:00:00 AM
And as far as I have an opinion on Intelligent Design...I think it is a political term for Creationism that was thought up to counter the politics of removing spirituality from formal public education. It is mere semantical rhetoric. Though "evolution only" curriculum might be political as well, "Intelligent Design" as a concept is a POLITICAL counter...it's a mask for creationism.
EI
  • EI
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 8:09:00 AM
4. Author: billyjackson Date: 08/02/2005 12:00 PM Reply

And as far as I have an opinion on Intelligent Design...I think it is a political term for Creationism that was thought up.....

You are right... sort of like how "pro choice" is used instead of abortion

Alternate lifestyle instead of homosexuality

Special needs instead of handicap

Undocumented aliens instead of illegal imigrants

It is a PC world after all

MACS
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 9:02:00 AM
Teach science in school and religion in church.
rugrunner
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 9:05:00 AM

"I think that part of education is to expose people to different schools of thought," Bush said. "You're asking me whether or not people ought to be exposed to different ideas, the answer is yes."

Isn't this the same enlightened reasoning behind jamming everything from homosexuality, Islam, global warming, diversity training, etc down the throats of kids in the government schools? Somehow the left thinks it opening intellectual vistas when it's their BS that kids are forced to listen to but evil right wing religious brainwashing if they were offered two explanations on how we got here? Situational standards to go with their situation ethics, morals, facts etc.

Maven, your jealousy of Bush's coloring abilities is sad to see. Practice Rick, and you too can stay inside the lines....If I find any cigar coloring books I'll send them to you! (c;

billyjackson
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 9:27:00 AM
5. Author: EI Date: 08/02/2005 12:09 PM

"sort of like how "pro choice" is used instead of abortion "

===================

On the issue of PC..."pro life" is just as a political term...especially seeing how most conservatives favor the death penalty. And what would the conservative platform do to care for all these babies that were aborted if they were born? They don't do much for the ones born now into dire straits.

But let them think they are "pro life." They are also "pro choice"...they just expect people to choose like they choose. Just don't act like the Right has a monopoly on truth and honesty.

And I'm not defending the left...they suck too.

==========

Back to Creationism in schools...

TBWCW
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 9:29:00 AM
It's kind of a mask for creationism, but it's also just intellectual honesty. It seems more likely that my cats could build a skyscraper than that a blind, uncaring, unintelligent universe, time, and random chance could produce what we see around us. It's not religion. It's simply opening your eyes and looking around you.
Thom
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 9:33:00 AM
billyjackson -- Really, it has no biblical basis nor solid scientific foundings. It's someone's alternative idea of how we all might have gotten here originally.

http://www.intelligentdesignnetwork.org/index.htm 

EI
  • EI
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 9:35:00 AM
8. Author: billyjackson Date: 08/02/2005 01:27 PM Reply

5. Author: EI Date: 08/02/2005 12:09 PM

"sort of like how "pro choice" is used instead of abortion "

===================

On the issue of PC..."pro life" is just as a political term.

so I guess a more correct term would be Pro Death for those in favor of abortion. Just so they are playing on a level jingoism field

Oh and argualbly this is also in line with creationism

or what ever you may wish to call it

billyjackson
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 11:06:00 AM
EI...

I agree that practially ID=Creationism. As far as accurate labels for the abortion debate...I don't know what they should be. But I do think both sides choose their own labels and the labels of their opponents from political motivation. I'm not defending either side. I just think they are playing the same game while accusing the other side of something they are guilty of themselves. Then they justify it by saying the other side does the same thing. Rhetorical circles emerge with no real chance at anything but further polarization.

I don't know how to solve it or if it can be. But with what smarts I think I have, I can smell bull**** no matter where it comes from.

==========================

Thom - not dogging on you - but on ID...yes, as a foundation, ID may withhold "implications" of their "objective" observations, I find it difficult to believe it is not a political issue founded in the very "implications" they say they can avoid. In that regard, I have a hard time believing that the biblical Creation story (or creations stories from other religions) is the basis for ID approach.

And again...ID can fire away! I just don't buy the "neutralness" of their approach. But that's me.

billyjackson
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 11:12:00 AM
For the record...if anyone cares...I believe in Creation. Whether it was 6 days (periods of time) as in Genesis 1 or it was some kind of Big Bang and Evolution. I don't know. But I believe from a religious standpoint that God initiated creation one way or another and had some involvement in its progression. HOW? I don't know.

And ID makes sense to me...from a religious perspective. The "obviousness" of design vs. chance of the patters of the universe appeal to my belief in a Creator. I don't believe the patterns, if accepted, can be left void of an implied "pattern maker." This in essence is a call toward belief in a Creator. Since such belief is not empirically studied, it oversteps the bounds of science. And, IMO, oversteps the jurisdiction of the state to teach with taxpayer funds.

Again...just me.

tey
  • tey
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 11:18:00 AM
I believe in creation but it does take a leap of faith to Bush and "intelligent design" together.
Charlie
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 11:42:00 AM
tey

you left "to" out of your sentence! Poor syntax!

Charlie

jcwbnimble
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 11:42:00 AM
Saying Intelligent design has nothing to due with religion is hogwash. The very basis of the theory says a higher intelligence (God) had a hand in the design of life.

If it wansn't God that was the higher intelligence, who was it? Aliens? So does that mean all these intelligent design proponents are 2001: A space odessey fans?

Let's face it. In every state where this intelligent design debate arrises, there is a large "moral majority". Read that as very vocal christians, whether they be born-again or otherwise.

And we wonder why our children are not becoming scientists, doctors, and engineers. These idiots are so focussed on cramming religion down our kids throats in school, while they should worry about the fundementals: Math, Science, Language, etc.

I don't want my kids hearing this religious revisionist crap. If these right wing super religious zealots want their kids to believe something different, then teach it to them in sunday school.

Keep church and state seperate, otherwise we might as well have a Monarchy. Then we can have the person that God has chosen, rule over us and decide what we are to learn in school.

I'm tired of the moral majority trying to push their views onto me. Keep it where it belongs, in the church and in the home. Don't tell me what I can watch, read, believe, and think.

jcwbnimble.

Thom
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 12:16:00 PM
billyjackson -- I think we agree on this. ID is some quasi-religious, but not founded on religion, not saying no, not saying yes, way to get people to admit that we could-possilby-might-have-been created by a higher power. Yeah, basically, politics. *shrug*
dolspot
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 1:17:00 PM
Right on nimble!!

I am with you 100%, what's next having videos of Tom Cruise advocating scientology? IMHO ALL religions whether it be Muslim, Christianity, Judaism, etc. have no place in public schools, because all religions invariably leave someone out.

How many problems have arisen in our society when religion (most of the time a form of Christianity) gets bent out of sort when scientific fact discredits one of its foundations? Stem cell research, evolution, Newton, heck what about Columbus disproving a flat world? The debate between science and religion has got to end, because I feel it is the one disjoint in our culture that could lead to a serious conflict, possibly a war bigger than any we have ever seen.

TrannyMk
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 1:20:00 PM
jcwbnimble, you said,

"And we wonder why our children are not becoming scientists, doctors, and engineers. These idiots are so focussed on cramming religion down our kids throats in school, while they should worry about the fundementals: Math, Science, Language, etc."

Where did you hear that the math and sciences wouldnt be taught anymore? You didnt. And have you lost control of your children? YOU, yes YOU, are supposed to be guiding them also. Not just the schools they go to.

When I was a kid, evolution was taught. I'm still a Christian. I didnt all of a sudden quit being a Christian because I was taught about evolution. It works the other way around too. And I'm not saying that Christianity should be taught in schools. Just that the theory of evolution is just that, a theory. And that other possibilities of all kinds should topics of conversation.

Step up and take control of your kids lives. Dont leave it all up to schools. It's a balance of both that work the best.

Charlie
Tuesday, August 2, 2005 1:59:00 PM
Mag

Great posting, wish more people would do just that!

Charlie