Steve*R
  • Steve*R
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Saturday, August 20, 2005 5:24:00 AM
For many years my preferred size and shape was toro, with an occasional robusto purchase. Then, as the boom ended, and quality and variety increased, I found myself buying more and more torpedoes and belicosos. Then I began to focus in on the classic 5.5 x 46, Cuban corona. It's always seemed like the perfect size for its ratio of wrapper to filler. Now, I find myself looking more intently for coronas and petite coronas, where the wrapper clearly dominates the blend. The size of the Cusano C10, Monte #4 is just about perfect for me.

Incidently, I just read that the robusto is far and away the most popular selling size.

So, what's your size and shape of choice. Boxpress?

Krubs
Saturday, August 20, 2005 6:21:00 AM
I like the look and feel of a box pressed cigar and my favorite size is the toro.
PurpleSageRighter
Saturday, August 20, 2005 6:28:00 AM

Perfectos, eg:

GURKHA Centurian XX - 6.0" x 60 ring

GURKHA Master Select Perfecto #3 - 4.0" x 54 ring

La AURORA Preferidos 1903 #1 - 6.0" x 60 ring

La AURORA Preferidos 1903 #2 (Tubos) - 5.0" x 54 ring

La AURORA Preferidos 1903 #3 - 4.0" x 54 ring

ARTURO FUENTE Short Story - 4.5" x 49 ring

CUABA Divinos - 4.0" x 43 ring

etc., etc.

Purp

rugrunner
Saturday, August 20, 2005 6:30:00 AM
I tend to like larger cigars. Maybe it makes it more of an event to smoke one at the end of the day etc. I have found recently that I prefer the taste of a smaller ring gauge. Now that you mention the wrapper to filler ratio it makes sense. As for shape, I like smoking belicosos but maybe that's the cigarette smoker (quit 6 years ago) in me trying to get out?
iwolf
Saturday, August 20, 2005 8:38:00 AM
I like the larger ring sizes myself, I think they have more flavor. So I also like the torpedo shape, they are much more comfortable in the mouth.
SteveR@CigarBid
Saturday, August 20, 2005 9:21:00 AM
Toro. Not a churchill, but not a robusto either...quite possible the perfect 'tweener' size. Especially when it's a nice 52 or 54 ring.

However, with the quickly growing small-cigar-craze going on, I've grown quite fond of Petite Coronas. Perdomo Reserve 'PC', RP Vintage Petite Corona, Series 'A' Anamoly...short, tasty and satisfying.

deadeyedick
Saturday, August 20, 2005 10:21:00 AM
Belicoso if I have the time.

Corona or short robusto size if I don't.

DED

Wagner
Saturday, August 20, 2005 12:23:00 PM
I used to like the larger sizes, toro's, belicosos', etc. Now I find myself going more for the corona and petit corona, especially ISOM-PC's. I think it's more of a time to smoke thing, because on a really laid back Sunday I may well reach for one of the former.

MACS
Saturday, August 20, 2005 2:07:00 PM
I honestly can't nail one down. I used to like Robusto myself, but then I found the Corona Gigante... or Julieta, if you will... 7 x 47. And the Petit Coronas and Coronas cannot be ignored... but then if you're in the mood for a torpedo? What to do, what to do...

I stock a variety. That way I can smoke what I want, when I want it. Including figurados... Cuaba.

ryantp
Saturday, August 20, 2005 2:10:00 PM
I'm actually a huge fan of the rothschild size. I'm also getting into the smaller sizes (a la petite corona), especially since I've been traveling and will be living in NYC.
tsfljxr
Saturday, August 20, 2005 4:44:00 PM
Size 50 to 54 ring , 5 to 7 inches .

All one thing I learned since I found cbid is to check the size instead of going by name toro,robusto ect. For example Gurkhs Legends Robusto(my Fav.) size 50 X 6" .would be a toro in another line. I like to save my robusto for the fall when I do alot of bird hunting. The shorter size 5" and less doesn't get in the way when I put my gun up to shoot . Works for me.

jimbarr
Saturday, August 20, 2005 5:03:00 PM
Rugs, you make no sense - you like larger cigars but prefer smaller ring guages? Anyway, I like torpedos and belicosos the best for "mouth feel". Like something about 6-6.5x44-50. Becoming a big fan of the box press too.
Sfraun04
Saturday, August 20, 2005 8:16:00 PM
When I first began smoking cigars, I stuck to robustos and coronas. A churchill would make me sick. Too much. Then, I began moving up the ladder. Started becoming fond of toros and torpedos. Soon afterwards, when my drive to work got shorter, petit coronas entered the picture.

Now, it's just whatever I am in the mood for in all honesty. Each size fits perfectly in its own time.

Good thread btw. A real thinker!

Stefan

rugrunner
Saturday, August 20, 2005 8:27:00 PM
jimbar, no that doesn't make sense. Let's see....

I like the La escepcion series V. I prefer the # 48(6 3/4" x 48)

to the # 54 (6" x 54). If you read Steve*R's original post and mine with that in mind i think it will make better sense.

moonman
Saturday, August 20, 2005 9:05:00 PM
Love em all except for the monster ring gauges. Anything 54 & under. Torpedoes, belicosos & perfectos are my favs. By the way, what is the difference between a torpedo & a belicoso? Potato or potato. Somebody is gonna want to say that a torpedo is an underwater missile that goes boom. Yes?
zody
Saturday, August 20, 2005 9:12:00 PM
Size and shape are really relative to what your tastes are. If I find a blend I like, which is usually very strong, I find that smaller vitolas fit the bill even better. Take the Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970 for example, the belicoso is really a nice smoke, but the machito size (petite) is a quicker and more intense flavor. I always thought before that a small cigar was a "small" smoke, but if you have a favorite strong cigar, scaling down to a smaller vitola usually means a pleasant surprise, an intense and pleasurable treat! As for box press or parejo, it's all what's more comfortable to the smoker, I tend to like both.
nine999
Saturday, August 20, 2005 9:54:00 PM
6 or 6.5 x 52 for most cigars.

i like 'em thick. havent had a 60 yet. gonna have to bid on one.

i have a few ancient warriers 7.5 x 54- its a big smoke, and requires some commitment, but its gotta be one of my favorites. good for a b.b.que.

jcwbnimble
Monday, August 22, 2005 10:58:00 AM
The size gar I'm craving at any given time depends on the circumstances. If I'm working in the yard, I go for the smaller sizes, either Corona, Petite corona, or robusto.

If it's later and I'm just sittin' around enjoying a drink, I'll go for a Churchill, Toro, or torpedo.

If I walk into a shop and want to try a new gar, it's either a toro or torpedo that I'll grab.

My personal favorite is a perfecto (Centurian XX) for the fact that they are easy to smoke, fit nicely in my mouth, and have a nice tight opening to concentrate the flavor on my tongue. I just wish more cigars came in that shape.

jcwbnimble.

bassdude
Monday, August 22, 2005 11:28:00 AM
well it was always robs or torps, now I find that I am reaching for PCs much more often.

I still like robs and torps with a church being my least favorite but still having a time and a place.

There are very few domestics I will smoke in church or DC size.

MACS
Monday, August 22, 2005 11:36:00 AM
The PC's have a great wrapper to filler ratio... I think that's why a lot of PC's are really popular.

Boli PC... Party Short... El Principe... PL PC... and the list goes on...