We've written that on numerous occasions. If the only thing going for a cigar is the price, we'll say so. You can't put whipped cream on crap and expect to maintain a loyal customer base. However, taste is very subjective and one man's trash is another man's treasure.
That said, Perdomo Slow-Aged receives mixed-reviews, but remains a top-seller from week to week. It's a nicely made and delivers a mellow, smooth flavor.