smokergirl
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 10:40:00 AM
...when it comes to taste? Let's say you have the same cigar in two different sizes. Are they typically the same tobacco blend?
Country
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 10:43:00 AM
not nice....
MACS
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 10:45:00 AM
Nope. Smaller ones have a greater 'wrapper to filler' ratio. A lot of a cigars flavor comes from the wrapper, some say.

But in general, a certain brand of cigar has different tobacco in the different sizes. I.E. - A bolivar Petit corona and a Bolivar Royal corona are not the same.

smokergirl
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 10:51:00 AM
Other than the smoke time being longer or shorter I had no idea. So far I'm leading toward the corona size so it doesn't take forever for me to smoke it. I guess I should start doing a size/taste comparison on the ones I like and go from there.

Sorry, country - didn't mean to offend but thought I would get more people to view/respond to the question.

lofty1
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 10:52:00 AM
"So far I'm leading toward the corona size"

my kinda woman. yeah, i know, it's pathetic.

tarheel4lyf
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 10:57:00 AM
now you got me wanting to fire up my Dec 01 Boli RC's
RDC
  • RDC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 10:59:00 AM
Oh to be a corona!

Longer cigars can give you a variety of tastes too. The roller will put one type toward the front, one towards the middle and yet another at the end. This way the cigar is different from start to finish.

Now, about that corona...

PurpleSageRighter
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 11:05:00 AM
MACS ...

YOU SAID: "[I]n general, a certain brand of cigar has different tobacco in the different sizes. I.E. - A bolivar Petit corona and a Bolivar Royal corona are not the same."

Aren't you comparing apples to oranges? Your comparison here is talking about the same sized (eg. corona) of different models (eg. Petit vs. Royal) of a Bolivar brand of cigar.

Methings the question goes more to comparing different sizes of the same model (ie. CAO L'Anniversaire eXtreme Churchill size to a Rothschild size). JMHO

Purp

Just an observation.

MACS
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 12:31:00 PM
Ahhhh. My apologies. I was thinking in terms of Cuban cigars. They all have different names based on the size.

My answer is still going to be kind of the same though... same tobacco, but in varying amounts of each, based on size. And if you take the 'wrapper to filler ratio' into account, the CAO eXtreme Churchill and the Corona are going to taste a little different.

MACS
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 12:39:00 PM
Unless of course the makers of said cigars also take this into account and adjust the amounts of each tobacco accordingly in order to make the different sizes uniform in taste?

Maybe Jon Huber could answer this question.

jcwbnimble
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 12:50:00 PM
Have to agree with Macs on this one.

Different sizes do have different tastes in my experience. Most recently I smokes a non-ISOM Romeo y Julieta Cedro #2 and a belicoso. The tastes to me were definitely different.

The other brand I have smoked alot of different sizes is the graycliff red lables. I have the tacos, PGX, and Pirates. My personal favorite was the Taco, it just fit my tastes better.

Again, it's just my opinion based on my experiences.

SteveR@CigarBid
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 1:23:00 PM
There's no doubt you will notice differences among different sizes within a line of cigars, depending on the line, of course. One example I always use is CAO Brazilia. I notice that the smaller sizes within the line seem fuller in body, and much more flavorful, than the larger, longer sizes. However, a cigar like CAO Gold (to me) is consistent in both flavor and strength between the different sizes.

Although it is not set in stone that certain sizes within a line will be fuller or more flavorful than others based on their dimensions, it is generally true that thicker, longer cigars tend to burn cooler.

Basically, it's trial and error and will vary from person to person. Graycliff Espresso is regarded as being one of the fullest bodied cigars on the market right now. While the Robusto makes me weak in the knees, I find the Pirate to be quite mellow, never going beyond medium-bodied. Others find the Pirate to be the strongest size within the line.

PurpleSageRighter
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 1:53:00 PM
I agree with you there MACS, jcw, & SteveR. Different sizes within the same lines, makes, & models have different strength and flavor profiles. There may be similarities but there also seems to always be differences. I am finding myself drawn more to the shorter versions (not necessarily smaller ring size, though) with most makes & models of cigars these days, not only because I like a quicker smoke most of the time but also because I seem to like the flavor profile better. The CAO eXtreme seems to be an exception to that rule for me though. I really go for the churchill size over, say the robustos.

Smokey, it still (and always seems to) comes down to your own individual preferences. You will never know what you will prefer by taking someone elses word for what you will like. You've got to do your own experimenting.

Good subject to discuss.

Purp

SteveR@CigarBid
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 2:05:00 PM
Another note...when a smaller ring cigar uses a robust wrapper, like a sungrown leaf or broadleaf maduro, the wrapper has a tendency to dominate the blend flavor-wise. A perfect example is the 5 Vegas Series 'A' - the spiciness of this wrapper is much more apparent with the Anomaly (petite corona) than the Archetype (toro) or Apostle (churchill).
echo4alpha
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 2:12:00 PM
MACS(SW) is right on his first post. The Boli PC is a mareva. The Boli RC is a robusto. Completely different vitolas with different blends. And... despite the wrapper to filler ratio difference, the Boli RC wins in this comparison.

My .02

Thom
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 2:33:00 PM
one word; Emmenso
PurpleSageRighter
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 9:18:00 PM
It is agreed that what MACS said in his first post was likely accurate, but MACS first post was NOT to the point of smokergirl's question, which positioned MACS first post as misleading. MACS later conceded this point and the follow-up posts better clarified the answers that smokey was seeking. JMNSHO

Purp

jackconrad
Wednesday, October 5, 2005 9:23:00 PM
generally i find Robusto sizes give me the flavour i like the best.
MACS
Thursday, October 6, 2005 7:05:00 AM
I am a wealth of information, ain't I?

Mr. echo4alpha was merely expressing the fact that he likes the RC's better than the PC's.

Hey Mike... ya think a 1999 Boli PC would change yer mind?

Buckwheat
Thursday, October 6, 2005 8:03:00 AM
OK...I'll firmly put my foot in my mouth and chime in on this one.

First, I can really only comment on my experiences with Cubans because that is all that I pretty much smoke anymore (and I really didn't pay that much attention when I smoked NC's).

Second, my experience is (and logic would tell you) that the wrapper has very little to do with the taste of the smoke from a cigar. Yes, the wrapper will influence the taste in your mouth disproportionately to its overall mix in the blend (because it is making contact with your lips, tongue, teeth, etc…) but not the smoke generated.

Cuban brands tend to be consistent from top to bottom in their general flavor profile (as always there are glaring exceptions to this). You can be assured that 90% of the Bolivars and Partagas' that you get are going to be strong regardless of the size (length or girth). Once you are within a certain brand I believe that you can evaluate the individual tastes of the different sizes. Partagas is a good brand for evaluating the different blends in the same vitola because they produce more vitolas than any other Cuban brand.

A good comparison would be to taste a box each of the following (all pretty much Dalias): 8-9-8 Varnished, Partagas de Partagas No. 1, Lonsdales and a Seleccion Privada No 1. You could compare these against boxes of the following (pretty much all Mareva): Mille Fleurs, PC’s, Shorts & Tres Petit Coronas. You will not only find differences in the different sizes but also within the same size. Aging will obviously throw a monkey wrench into this evaluation because the flavors can change pretty dramatically over time (i.e. +5 years).

Sometimes the packaging can also influence the taste of an aged cigar. An aged tubed cigar (e.g. 15 yr. old RyJ Churchill is one that comes to mind) will have a different taste than the same cigar that has been aged in a dress box which will also taste different than the same aged cigar in a SLB.

The bottom line is to try and smoke as many different sizes and brands as you can and determine what is best for you. You will also find that as you smoke more your tastes will change (sometimes dramatically).

“Smoke ‘em if you got ‘em.“