okay I've been smoking cigars for 23 years now, and I've used every brand of cutter imaginable. I use my xikar ofen, and I love it. They are a fabulous company that stands behind their product. I also have a palio, and I think it's the best cutter ever. I have a v-cutter, and a punch I carry around on my keychain, for emergency purposes. I say buy the cheap punch cutters, and throw them away when they start to get dull. The fact is, I use them all. If we lived in Cuba, we probably wouldn't use any cutter. They all just seem to suck on the cap for a bit, and bite it off.
Greg