burgess_b
Saturday, October 15, 2005 8:29:00 PM
i have only been a member for a week, so i do not want to get cut off, but do you think there are minimal acceptable bids? i mean, i put in a couple of LOW bids and just before the cut off, it is still low but better.

for example, i have watched every Gurkha Reserve Robusto for the week, and a 5-pack went for $17 minimum EVERY time, and an hour or 2 before, i was the first bidder with $15. i won it, but the whole crew paid $17. strange?

Sfraun04
Saturday, October 15, 2005 8:56:00 PM
All depends on how many people are bidding, and how far they will go. Changes from day to day.

Stefan

Country
Saturday, October 15, 2005 8:57:00 PM
If there is a quantity of 5 boxes in one lot, and you bid on all 5 for 15 bucks a piece, than the next person will have to bid more than 15 bucks to win one of the boxes. If four people bid on four out of the five boxes than all of the people will bid more than your original 15 dollars, but you will still get 1 out of the 5 boxes for what you originally bid. If one more person bids on them you will be out bid and will then have to bid again.

This is a hard subject to explain but easy when you understand it. Sorry if this doesn't help.

Country

Mr. Jones
Saturday, October 15, 2005 9:04:00 PM
That's the way it works here on this site. Depending on "when" you bid and if others are using the auto-bid feature or not, will decide who wins it for a lower price than the other bidders who win also. P.S. do you own an shpo? sorry ,that's the left over Victory Hop Wollops from Christmas (14% abv) talkin ,LOL. Just keep bidding and you'll catch on fast, welcome.
BikerBob1961
Saturday, October 15, 2005 11:48:00 PM
you know I would like to know why some items the bid increases by $1 and others $2 or $3?
Slimboli
Sunday, October 16, 2005 4:45:00 AM
It's just the way cigarBid sets up the bid increments ... depending on what the lot is worth. More expensive lots have higher bid increments, less expensive lots have lower bid increments.
burgess_b
Monday, October 17, 2005 4:26:00 AM
Mr. Jones. i do not know "an shpo", but i think you mean "a shop", as in a cigar shop.

no. live in japan, and i can only get ahold of Cubans and bad other world smokes. and they are all over-priced. you gotta blow a 20 to get a decent size. sure you can get some good coronas for a 10, but they i am not a 44 kinda guy.

jcwbnimble
Monday, October 17, 2005 3:41:00 PM
It really pays to be the first bidder on an auction. If you bid reasonably (like you $15 bid) chances are you will win the auction.
jdobson
Wednesday, October 19, 2005 11:30:00 AM
Eventually, you will realize that $15-$17 is the going rate for these sticks around here. It is only a "deal" when you can get it for less than that! I have been watching and waiting patiently for some Gurkha Master Selects to fall below the $15 mark, but all you guys are just too diligent around here! I can't even seem to pull this one of when the holidays keep most folks offline 🙂
TBWCW
Wednesday, October 19, 2005 11:34:00 AM
Where in Japan do you live?
elrico
Wednesday, October 19, 2005 1:58:00 PM
I may have mis-interpreted his comment, but I think Burgess is implying that it seems CBID may be artificially ensuring that some auction items never close below a minimum amount.

On occasion, I've wondered the same thing, but then there is the occasion when you win a lot or two at a price that just has to be at or below wholesale price, or at least extremely far below retail.

I think CBID is above board, based on my experience, but sometimes the bidding can be a bit frustrating when you think you're on the verge of a great deal and a last-minute bid from someone else fouls things up.

Elrico

Slimboli
Wednesday, October 19, 2005 2:02:00 PM
... that's why they call it an auction ... 😉
jcwbnimble
Wednesday, October 19, 2005 3:20:00 PM
I'm curious as to how Cbid could be ensuring a minimum bid for an auction that starts at $1?

The pure fact of the matter is, it's market pressure. Absolute supply and demand. If you watch closely, the same item can be up at the same time in two different auctions, one having a qty of 1 and the other 7. Inevitably the auction with a qty of 1 will go for a higher amount.

People don't do searches too often. They see something they like, and instead of checking to see if it's on another auction with a higher qty (and more likely a lower final bid) or even to see if CI's retail price is cheaper.

If someone is finding that they gars they really like (CAO's, IT's, Gurkha's, etc) are never getting below $15-$17, chances are its because it's the favorite gar of alot of other people.

Take for example CAO Brazilias. It has a very large fan base, and you are lucky to find a fiver of ANY size for under $20. On the opposite side, there is Reserva Maximas. This gar has a much smaller fan base and you can usually get very good deals on fivers or boxes.

Supply and demand, puer and simple. The only way Cbid can ensure a minimum bid is to start the bidding at the lowest amount they are willing to take, which is what the other maJoR online vendor has done at their new auction site. Most auctions start at their cost or higher.

No worries here. I would guess that 99% of the auctions here start at $1.

elrico
Wednesday, October 19, 2005 8:23:00 PM
jcw,

I think the implication was that regardless of the starting auction price, an unscrupulous auction site could enter dummy bids or something of that sort to bump the auction up to their floor price for a given item. If an actual customer really wants it, he/she may chase the auction and re-bid at the higher price. If not, the auction site ends up with the product and re-lists it again.

I'm not saying that I believe this happens on this site, but the potential for abuse is there.

Elrico

burgess_b
Thursday, October 20, 2005 5:05:00 AM
wjmiskelly --

i live just outside of kobe, on the other side of osaka.