So many things can influence your perception of an individual cigar. Some variables include how the cigar was kept, where it was kept, with what was it kept and for how long.
IMHO, the most significant variable is what you had to drink or eat just before smoking the cigar. The 1916 has always been a consistent cigar for me. But I can tell a significant difference in this and many other cigars based on drinking / eating something before or during the smoke.
I would recommend having another 1916 after a glass of ice water. Maybe even while sipping some good strong coffee.
Then again, it just might not be your flavor profile and that's ok too.