8trackdisco
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 5:52:00 PM
Tuck,

I was goin gto send this via email, but maybe I could get more out of this if I opened it up to others as well.

Although I consider myself a moderate conservative, I do listen to National Public Radio, whick is far to the left of center.

They had a guy on today what was a Christian, floated away, became Born Again, and now considers himself an agnostic (for a minute I thought it was Billyjackson).

This guy talks about the apostles and their different writings about the same events and how they conflict. It would take a long time to explain, so I'll just post a link with some excerps from it.

Dr. Pepperhill, Billy Jackson, adroomi, Rug Runner et. al, I'm realy interest in the view from you guys on this nearly as much as I am interested in Tuckers view.

If everyone could keep this respectful, I would appreciate it. As a reward, I promise to fight with all of you at a later date about something else. I really want to try to learn something from this.

Here's the link.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5052156 

Discuss.

8

pabloescabar
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 5:56:00 PM
Merry Christmas youyoungpeachfuzzbuckyou
Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 7:10:00 PM
I'm not a biblical scholar, but have dealt with similar kinds of philological considerations in general studies of many early European and Middle Eastern literary and linguistc sources.

Your man Ehrman's observation that "the modern Bible was shaped by mistakes and intentional alterations that were made by early scribes who copied the texts" is also true for most ancient texts, as in Homer, Plato, Aristotle, etc.

For example ancient Hebrew, the original language of the old testaments, is extinct with no real record left of the original meanings, so our knowledge of it, coming primarily through Greek, Arabic, and Roman translations, and then to our English, contain many unintentional mistranslations and other unintended changes. For example, I have heard that 'virgin' is the Hebrew word for young woman, so the idea that Jesus was born to a 'young woman' vs. a 'virgin' in the way we define virgins, has widely distinct meanings.

When I was studying Aristotle, many warnings were placed throughout the texts that such and such a passage might have been added later on by Greek, Arab or Roman translators or editors looking to make a name for themselves in posterity.

Language, both semantically and phonetically is not static and changes over time. Also, select passages of texts are added or deleted, as when Constantine called together a meeting of religious and secular leaders at Nicea in 325 AD regarding the newish cult of Christianity that was then on the rise. "It was felt best to tack new policies on the end of this religion ... one of the principal tasks was to decide which books should constitute the 'Holy Book' of the new religion, which would become the Bible."

Tuckersdad
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 7:30:00 PM
Eight - I read the material in the link, but am not sure what your question is, or what part you want to discuss. I firmly believe the following, among much more. The following are not in any particular order.

1. The bible proclaims that all scripture (the books contained in the Old and New Testament) was inspired by the Holy Spirit of God, and is infallible in it's entirety.

2. While many different "writers" wrote the various books, under the direction of God, there are no contradictions or errors in any one of them.

3. There were many other books written by spiritual and scholarly men of God. While these books are good, they are not on a level of the inspired books.

4. Everything required for salvation and knowledge of God is contained within the bible.

5. The New Testament in no way replaces the Old Testament, nor does the NT conflict with the teachings and truth contained in the OT. The NT is the "new covenant" and builds upon and fulfills the OT. Christ said that He came not to destroy the law (the OT), but to fulfill the law.

6. The bible, containing the OT and the NT, is the only scriptures to be used for faith and instruction.

7. God, through the inspired scriptures, proclaims that there is one God, and there are no other.

8. The scriptures plainly state that there is one way to redemption, one way to be forgiven, one way to God's Heaven, and that's through His Son.

9. The bible is impossible to understand except the Holy Spirit of God reveal it to you. No man, however educated and scholarly, will ever be able to understand the truth and message of the bible unless God reveals it to him.

10. Many people say that getting to Heaven is like going to St. Louis . . . some take the train, others a plane, and still others an automobile . . . but they all get to St. Louis. By this they try to explain that some may worship Buddah, others Allah, and others find their way through many other "religions". The bible plainly states this is just not so. In many many places the scriptures plainly state there is one God, and no other. And there is one way to reach God's Heaven, and that is through the Son of God, the Lord Jesus Christ and His sacrificial death.

As I said, I don't know your question, if you were asking one, but hope this information is helpful.

Other interesting facts:

Although the bible contains much scientific facts and information, not one error has been found in four thousand years.

Although many other "prophets" proclaim themselves to be God, no other prophet or God or messenger of God has died, been ressurrected from the dead, and ascended back to heaven, all before many witnesses. All the rest are in their graves.

Tuck

billyjackson
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 7:39:00 PM
8

not agnostic...very convinced there is a God who works in the lives of humans...just not happy about how God has worked in my life some ways

i looked at the link. I recognize the author from a textbook or two from seminary days. He is a competent and moderately respected scholar.

as far as what i think...i have too much hostility invested in the issue to be able to participate in a righteous manner.

all i will say is that whether you consider the scholarly arguments or not, what you think of the bible comes down to your faith. that's it...end of story. you can take what scholars/scientists/whatever say and let it strengthen what you think scripture says...you can let it undermine it...or you can let it make you reconsider things

to say more is just going to end up with me in a knock down drag out...sorry for not being of better help

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 7:39:00 PM
Tuckers, regarding your point #2, I beseech you oh Arkansas man, read Spinoza's Theologic-political Treatise, you can buy it used for $2-$4. He is an uber-wise biblical scholar and covers the empirical contradictions of the bible in painstaking detail. He'll have you doing donuts in your Pride Jazzy 1170XL.
Tuckersdad
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 7:50:00 PM
I don't think so. No, I know so. He is not the first to write such critiques, won't be the last. I haven't read this particular fellows stuff, but have read others. Each one has been debunked by scholars far brighter and better equipped than I. Anybody can write a book, but that means little, when the whole of true scholars tear them apart and show the fallacy of their thesis.

I've read my last, because I'm getting tired, and they're pretty much all the same. I spend my time attempting to get greater revelation and understanding of the scriptures, and the wonderful God who loves me.

But there are some things that will never be known by mortal man . . . the bible is all about faith, not proof one way or another, and I have placed my complete faith in the God of the bible, and in His Son Jesus Christ my Lord. If we could understand it all, we'd be God.

Here is a fact . . . If I'm wrong, it's no big deal, I've lived a good life, and if there is no Hell, in contrast to what the bible proclaims, I'm ok.

But if you're wrong, you're in deep trouble.

Thanks,

Tuck

Tuckersdad
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 7:55:00 PM
Billy, I commend you (not that you need my commendation). A very honest post. And absolutely right concerning faith. God loves us more than we can comprehend, and understands your position where you are now. Stay open to truth, He'll be there. And He'll come more than halfway to meet you.
18delta
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:03:00 PM
i firmly agree with tucker on his stand regarding the scriptures and his belief of and faith in them.

chris

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:04:00 PM
Spinoza isn't the first Tuckers, but he is the best. He was also a very pious man of God.

You do not like Spinoza.

Try him and you may!

Try him and you may, I say.

Seriously, if you like the bible, and I know you do, you'd love the Theologico-political Treatise by Spinoza. It's all bible all the time. Think of it, you, a cigar, Spinoza, and your Pride Jazzy 1170XL.

Here it is for $5.18

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/offer-listing/0486437221/ref=buy_pb_n_//002-5078747-5187263?condition=new 

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:12:00 PM
Not to belabor the point, but here's a brief review of the Theologico-political Treatise from the Amazon site I posted:

"An eloquent plea for religious liberty, demonstrating that true religion consists of the practice of simple piety, independent of philosophical speculation. He [Spinoza] examines the Bible at length to show that freedom of thought and speech are consistent with the religious life."

Guys like Tuckers & 18delta will love it.

Tuckersdad
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:13:00 PM
I appreciate the suggestion. But Spinoza is the best only in some people's estimations. Many others would fervently disagree. I've spent a lifetime (well not completely yet) reading material such as you suggest. Now I'm tired. Approaching 60, and in questionable health, I'm finding I have pretty much settled all my doubts, and enjoy spending the huge majority of my available time in the Word. I haven't closed my mind, but it's been a long search, and I'm satisfied.

By the way I'm not criticizing this author, I'm not qualified. I just have others I know and trust, and they are in the great majority of scholarly thought.

I do thank you for your suggestion though.

Tuck

GDColson
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:13:00 PM
Pep,

If you want him to read it...maybe it would make a nice Christmas present to Tuck?

Tuckersdad
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:18:00 PM
I don't mean to duck out, but Tucker (our Boxer) is having major oral surgery tomorrow and we have to arise around 4:00 a.m. to get him there by 6:30. I have to get some rest to make it. His condition, after the recent strokes makes the surgery dangerous. Thanks for the interchange.

Tuck

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:21:00 PM
Colson, I'm not even giving my mom a gift, 2005 was a lean year. However, for those who like, scratch that, love, consumer level biblical exegesis, this book is a gift (you can score it at the local used book store for a couple of bucks, because no one cares to read such stuff now days).
TBWCW
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 8:34:00 PM
Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 9:03:00 PM
Wow Wjm. Great free book site on Spinoza. If even a few read it it will have been worth it. Spinoza brings the bible out into the world in a way few of us can on our own. He's critical and respectful at the same time. Hope this will answer some of 8track's questions.
stickme
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 10:09:00 PM

imho

..seek what is good in man, and find "your" god there

..unending

Dr Pepperhill
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 10:15:00 PM
Defining what is good in man/woman is really a task for the ages.
TBWCW
Wednesday, December 14, 2005 10:31:00 PM
I'm not surprised that you would appreciate Spinoza. You seem to share many of his presuppositions - ones I obviously oppose.

For some info on Spinoza from others who disagree with him:

http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14217a.htm