As a newbie there are several advantages to getting a coolerdor instead of a humidor. First and foremost, cigar smoking can be a particularly expensive habit to pick up. boxes of cigars generally run about fifty bucks a piece. Then you have to get cutters, lighters, and all of the other accessories. A humidor is the most necessary but one of the most expensive accessories there is. I bought a desktop that held forty cigars originally. It cost me about thirty bucks. Two boxes later and it was comepletely full. Then I had a dilemma....should I buy another Humidor? I began considering my options. How long was I going to continue in this hobby? How many cigars would I be storing in the future? Would I ever get above 150? 200? 1000? If I was going to buy another one I wanted to make sure it was big enough to last. The other problem was that as a newbie, I was having a hard time keeping the humidity stable in my humi. I was checking it every hour, playing with water and prop glycol forever. The fact that I had a fairly cheap humi that didn't hold its humidity well didn't help.
Instead of throwing out another few hundred bucks on another humidor....I found coolerdors. It cost me twenty dollars to buy and assemble. I bought some cheap Oasis foam, a tupperware container, and Igloo chest, and (later on) some spanish cedar to line the walls (although this is not necessarily needed if you are storing your cigars in boxes.
After assembling it I noticed a few things right away...first, I had money left over to buy cigars to fill up my new coolerdor, second, it held the humidity amazingly well, and third, it was easy to control the humidity (in the summer it usually creeps up, so I unplug the drain, and in the winter I plug it back in) I built mine almost two years ago and it has been great. I enjoy it thoroughly, my father-in-law made himself one as well, and it's starting to get a little full as I have a couple hundred cigars in there. If I had bought a second humidor, I would probably be looking for an upgrade by now. Instead, I will probably just by a bigger cooler, and use my old one as an ice-chest. Maybe in a few years, if I am still smoking, if I figure out how many cigars I will generally have at one time, and if I find the right one for the right money at the right price, I will buy something to put in the living room, but for now, I'm happy.