This is a very good question... which, if I even try to answer fully will never please everyone...
So, I'll say this just to offer one man's opinion, a premium smoke is one you would be PROUD to share with a close friend, on a special night out.
Some examples would be (and I know this will get me grief) AF, CAO, RPs, Gurhkas, Camamcho, Parti, Hoyo, JdN, LaAurora, LaGC, LJs, Montes, Padron, Torano... and MANY OTHERS.
Guys... this is all about having fun, being fair, and behaving like gentlemen (and ladies).
Lets keep this a place where we can enjoy each others company, stories, and share some good cigars.
I hope that helps.
Cheers,
PT 🙂