Here's my Top Five in each price range-
Top sub $2:
Black Pearl Rojo Supertoro
Licenciados Wavell
Onyx Reserve Toro
Puros Indios Magnum Maduro
Top Sub $4:
Arturo Fuente 858 SG
CAO Black Frontier
Gurkha Master's Select Toro H2000
Joya de Nicaragua Celebracion Churchill
Top Sub $8:
Arturo Fuente Anejo No. 50
Graycliff Espresso Robusto
Gurkha Legend Aniversario
Padron 1964 Anniversary Corona Maduro
I only listed 4 in each case cas I can't make up my mind 🙂
I think $2 is around the minimum you have to pay to get high quality smokes. $4 for me it's the "sweet spot", price/ quality wise. At around $8 you can get some of the best cigars ever made, anything above that IMHO you're only paying for the rarity- it won't further improve smoking experience.
I therefore didn't list anything above $8, and for me to pay more than that it has to be really really special- either limited edition or Cuban, since you can't easily get them here I think is pointless to list.
Of course I would like to expand my list to put more variety into my humidors, so please post comments.