Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 4:12:00 AM
USA! USA! USA!678724.jpg
victor808
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 8:38:00 AM
I'm sorry Drathaar, I'm going to have to jump in on this. Please keep in mind that I'm not only commenting on this photo, but a number of other instances where we have either pictures or comments about disliking the French, or bullying other countries (as you depict in this picture). I just have to say, WHY?

I don't particularly like the french, but why should we dislike them? Why should we lampoon abusing them? What have they done to us? The current (21st century) wave of anti-french propaganda seems to be directed towards them because of their disagreement over our invasion of Iraq. But is that a problem? So they don't think we should have invaded Iraq, aren't they entitled to that? They have not tried to stop us, they are not arming the Iraqi citizens against us. They have simply stated that "this is a bad idea". Hell, our citizens are allowed to say this (or at least we currently are), so why shouldn't a soveriegn country. To lampoon them as a weak little poodle (or any other of the cartoons) because of their desire to not get involved in a war they don't believe in makes us look more like bullys than ever.

Which brings us to the other problem. Why do you identify so strongly with our country as a powerful entity abusing a smaller one? Many of the cartoons here show us threatening a smaller country, beating them or otherwise bullying them. This is not a good image, especially when the target is another democratic country merely expressing its free opinion.

I don't mean to attack you, Drathaar, I just have been having a problem with seeing these images and hearing people talk about the situation in this manner and I want people to start wondering whether we have crossed the line from a country defending the concepts of democracy to a country trying to bully the world into doing what we want.

jetblasted
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 9:31:00 AM
Thank You, Drathaar . . .
Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 12:30:00 PM
Victor, its a French Poodle. Not just any "weak poodle", but a symbol of France.

Now, France may not have armed Iraqi civilians (or maybe they did) but they did help arm Iraq. Despite sanctions they sold military arms and equipment to Iraq. Those military items were used to kill American soldiers. Strike one & two against them.

Also, France had a very sweet oil deal with Iraq (secretly, and again against sanctions). But the deal would only take affect if the sanctions were lifted from Iraq. Do you think that might have played a hand in France trying to stop us from taking Saddam out? France did try to stop us, twice. Strike three.

They treatened other countries who wanted to vote with us in the UN. Those countries wanted to be part of the EU (God knows why) and France told them if they voted with us, they would not be accepted into the EU. Any leagues have four strikes? France's does.

As for the question "Why do you identify so strongly with our country as a powerful entity abusing a smaller one?" Because they deserve it. They earned it. I don't see us as a bully against France. We don't have sanctions against them (but a bunch of us are boycotting them - and it is hurting them). But they should have been officially punished for ignoring the sanctions (Russia and Germany as well). But they weren't, so its up to Joe Citizen to pay France back for helping kill American soldiers. That is why I do this.

P.S.

I didn't create this cartoon, I'm just passing it along.

victor808
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 1:09:00 PM
Drathaar, I figured you were just passing it along. But there are still some problems:

1) The french poodle is not a symbol of france any more than french fries are. Obviously the dog was chosen because of the name, but do you really think it would have been chosen if french poodles were known for their visciousness?

2) Yes, france was a supplier of arms to Iraq prior to our invasion. However, I did a quick check and we were the 11th largest supplier of arms between 1981 and 2001 (according to a SIPRI database or something). So, yes, they supplied arms which killed american troops (note, still before our invasion) but so did we.

3) France tried for a sweet oil deal w/ Iraq that would only be worthwhile when sanctions were lifted? Lets look at this logically, Iraq has a natural resource everyone wants to get their hands on. One country, with the military power to take it by force threatens invasion. Another country, without the military power to take it by force, strikes a different deal by trying to ply their political clout for access to the same resource.

Lets look at the outcomes of the two strategies. We already know what happened when the force method worked. What would have happened if France succeeded in convincing us to not invade Iraq? There would be no war in Iraq and France would have a deal to purchase their oil. That sounds pretty free market to me. It isn't like this was any sort of "secret" deal.

So France wont support a country's entrance to the EU based on their support of the US. The EU, in order to function well, needs to be a tight collective of countries with a large portion of their politics and economies aligned. Imagine how the war would work if only a few states agreed to send their reserves to Iraq.

I'm not stating that the war is right or wrong (for the record, I think it is wrong) but another country considering it wrong and positioning their politics to prevent it is not really deserving of the "we are beating your $ss" theme of the cartoons.

To oppose this diametrically, do you think there is anything profoundly "right" or "mighty" about those countries that supported Bushes war and offered troops? (Poland, Australia etc). Do you think these countries are doing this for any reason other than an opportunity to gain some political clout (and their hands on the oil)? If the cartoon were modified to show all those countries (including the US) depicted as large dogs beating the french poodle, would you find it as pleasing?

jetblasted
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 1:38:00 PM
Thank You, Drathaar . . .
Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 1:50:00 PM
1. When you see a poodle, what country do YOU think of? I'm gonna go out on a limb and say most people think of France, making a symbol of France.

2. You seem to be missing the point about the ams & equipment. France was selling them ILLEGALY to a country with UN sanctions against it. Its interesting, they didn't want us to take out Saddam without UN approval but they were going against the UN themselves. Hypocrites.

3. Again, you are missing the point. Iraq had UN sanctions against it. France didn't care. They bullied other countries into voting their way so they could have their illegal oil deal. I thought you didn't like bullies? The only reason France thought the war was wrong is because they wanted the oil. I guess those signs were right, just in the wrong country "NO WAR, for oil". No war, sanctions lifted, France gets oil.

Its interesting you call the EU a "collective". That fits. Of course, we wont be assimilated.

I'd love that cartoon!

Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 1:53:00 PM
You're welcome Jet 🙂
bloody spaniard
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 2:11:00 PM
Up until the last 15 years or so, I have gone from being an admirer of French haute couture, wines, cuisine, and their nazi resistance movement to disdain for their duplicity & cowardice in dealing with our common enemies.

IMO, they have proven themselves unreliable liars and faux allies in the mold of the Saudis.

Good for you, Draathar(sp?)!!

victor808
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 2:32:00 PM
Okay...

1) I think we are actually on the same page here, yes, if I had to identify a country with a FRENCH poodle, I'd think of france. Obviously this is the artists symbolism and I agree. My statement was that this is not a symbol FRANCE would endorse, making it insulting.

2) Okay, I'll cede this point. During the time when the UN had sanctions against Iraq there were a number of countries illegally supplying them with goods. This consisted of both weapons and consumer goods. France was included in this list (and one of the more prominent ones). It was also at this time that a number of nations (including France) were suggesting that the sanctions against Iraq were having a severe humanitarian impact on the people and should be lifted. (not significant right now, but keep it in mind)

Note, that France trades despite UN sanctions and you vilify them. The US invades a country against UN approval and you honor it. Both of the countries are acting against the UN... The only real difference between the two actions is that one caused a great deal of loss of life.

3) The oil deal France was shooting for would take place AFTER the sanctions were lifted, making it perfectly legal. They were trying to negotiate a deal, "we get you out of trouble with the UN, you give us a bit of the oil trade" sort of thing. Not too dissimilar to "we'll give you a no-bid contract on the rebuilding of Iraq" kind of deal.

4) Of course we wont be assimilated. We are already a collective of states... who cares?

jetblasted
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 2:35:00 PM
Thank You, Drathaar . . .
wrm72
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 2:49:00 PM
Love the cartoon for what its worth.... I'd buy a shirt with it on the front..

Who put the quarter in Victor

adroomi
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 3:38:00 PM
the sad thing is...we're the one's getting spanked these days.

It's a shame.

andytv
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 3:50:00 PM
Ernesto wrote some of his best stuff while he was in France.....I love to read about France.

I can't say that I agree with their politics, but I would love to chill there.

Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 4:54:00 PM
Ahhh....

What would a patriotic thread be without "Gloom & Doom" Droomi (See where doomi fits now?) ;~)

Now on to victor, I'm on the phone now, so this is going to take a while...

jetblasted
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 4:56:00 PM
andy, I went there several years ago, and I will say that Paris is the most beautiful city I've seen . . . Now, if I could only get to Rome . . .
Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 5:12:00 PM
Victor,

The oil deal was illegal, we didn't find out about it until after the invasion - the Iraqi's didn't destroy the evidence, honor among thieves! They were using this deal to keep Saddam in power, a man who murdered, raped, tortured, and maimed his own people. A very selfish act if you ask me.

Also, was France really thinking of the Iraqi peoples health and welfare or were they trying to get sanctions lifted for oil? If they really cared about the Iraqi people they could've talked to their buddy Saddam and asked him to feed his people and get them proper medical attention. But alas, Sadaam was too busy building palaces for himself.

We didn't act against the UN, there were 2 votes and both were approved. It took some doing and a lot of time, but the precious approval was given. Now, I could give a rip about the socialistic anti-American UN, but that's another topic. France was touting the importance of the UN and going on and on about approval. All the while defying it.

Your welcome jetblasted 🙂

Oh and droomi, we are not getting spanked. Try not to put all your faith in the liberal press.

Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 5:18:00 PM
Andy, it is their government and politics I disagree with. Besides everything mentioned above, they are pandering to the muslims and are fast becoming as anti-semetic as the muslims are. Another white flag for France.
jetblasted
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 5:19:00 PM
It was funny how France was holding out admitance into the EU based on the war . . . They were trying to be the big dogs on the block with a EU that matched anything that we had. It was all for show and fluff . . . and, when the votes came down to it a few months ago, it fell thru . . .

The vote could dealt a fatal blow to the EU constitution, which needed to be ratified by all 25 member states.

President Jacques Chirac accepted the voters' "sovereign decision", but said it created "a difficult context for the defence of our interests in Europe".

The French leader had campaigned hard for a "Yes" vote.

I don't know who's the bigger wimp, Chirac or De Villepin . . .

Drathaar
Tuesday, March 14, 2006 10:10:00 PM
I'll pick The Worm.