jjohnson28
Sunday, March 26, 2006 1:38:00 PM
Don't know why but I find myself in the market for a New Home Defense type shotguns lately. Oh I know why, it's because I was in a gun shop the other day and they had the Mossberg 500 28" and 18" combo's (5+1 capacity) on sale for $239.00 and I suddenly felt $300 or so burning a nice hole in my pocket...LOL

Since then I have found the Mossberg 500 security 20" bbl (7+1 cap.) and the Remington 870 security 18" bbl (6+1 cap.) on sale for $239 and $271 respectively.

Now I already own a couple of shotguns but they are both nice field grade units. A Winchester 1400 semi auto w/28" bbl and variable screw in choke tubes plus a very nice Browning Auto5 w/30" full choke bbl.

The combo would make a nice 2nd gun to use for quail hunting with the boy, we could also use it to shoot trap and skeet together plus the 18 bbl would fit the HD requirement somewhat. But I really like these 20" bbl home defense guns for some reason, most notably the increased capacity over what I already have.

I've done quite a bit of research online and both brands seem to be fairly equal in quality and what seems to be somewhat fierce brand loyalty...LOL

Which you buy and why?

Thanks, JJ

Big 5 sporting goods current sales:

Mossberg 500 Security slide-action, 12ga/3"/8-shot/blue/synthetic, $239.99

Remington 870 Security slide-action, 12ga/3"/Parkerized/synthetic, 7-shot ("6 + 1 capacity"), 18" Cylinder/bead, $299.99

BTW the clerk said I could still get the Mossberg 500 combo deal for the same $239 if I wanted to wait until they got more in stock.

Tuckersdad
Sunday, March 26, 2006 2:02:00 PM
jjohnson -

Either of them would make a very good home defense weapon. It's sorta like Ford/Chevy, both are well proven designs. It pretty much comes down to what you prefer. You can't go wrong with either.

I do reccommend an 18 or 20 inch barrel for home defense. Normal field gun barrels are too long and give an intruder a much better chance of wresting it away.

Most experts reccommend using 00/1/2 buckshot. Slugs will over penetrate and put others in danger. I like a full extended magazine (6-8 rounds) and I use a stock sleeve that holds five. I don't like the "Sidesaddle" that holds extra rounds on the left side of the receiver (gets in the way of fast handling).

Whatever you decide, be sure to go to the range and pattern it. It'll surprise you how tight the pattern is at close range. You really do have to aim. At 5-10 feet the shot spread will only be about the size of a silver dollar.

Have fun and pick the package you like.

Tuck

jetblasted
Sunday, March 26, 2006 2:06:00 PM
Pump action sawed off works for me . . .
Clintock
Sunday, March 26, 2006 2:09:00 PM
jjohnson28!

Brand is strictly a matter of preferenjce. If it is for home defence, choose a wide open choke or cylinder bore.

use light loads of #8 or #9 shot! The reason for the light loads and smaller shot sizes is to not create a situation where you may put your family in danger.

ie. blowing a hole through one of the children's bedroom walls or someone else in the family.

You will still have plenty of killing power and the wide open choke will lesen the need for aiming! just point and shoot!

Shotgun's with the shortest legal barrel 18" in Pa. are the ones i would choose for home defence.

clintock

andytv
Sunday, March 26, 2006 2:13:00 PM
what clintock said.

Tuckersdad
Sunday, March 26, 2006 2:16:00 PM
I really have to disagree here, no disrespect intended.

7 0r 8 shot will not do the job through heavy clothing.

And you definitely have to aim. Many people thing you can just point down a hallway and take out anything, when in fact the shot spread at ten feet will be no larger than a silver dollar.

These are not my thoughts or experience, but the result of much reading of the experts and professionals.

Here's just one site of many that speaks to these issues relating to all areas of home defense:

http://www.backwoodshome.com/ayoob_index.html 

Tuck

Clintock
Sunday, March 26, 2006 2:27:00 PM
Tuck!

we are talking home protection! shots more than likely less than 10 yds!!! I assure you that a light load of #8 or #9 will more than penetrate at these distances!

Buck shot of any size will go through dry wall line darts hitting a baloon! at these ranges. They are totally out of the question if you are a family man!

clintock

andytv
Sunday, March 26, 2006 2:35:00 PM
typically birdshot loads will penetrate 4-5" of ballistic gel.

with a very short barrel, you spread pattern will be greater than a 1/2 dollar. My "shorty" has a pattern of about 16" at 20 feet.

First shot will probably be fatal........if not, it will knock back/blind/incapacitate.

I use birdshot because of concerns with my family (a compromise).......if I lived alone....#1 buckshot.

grinder
Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:24:00 PM
as far as which barrel length, 18" is ideal. As far as capacity in most cases you would not have to fire, the sound of the racking action will get their attention. A wounded intruder will end up sueing you, a dead one cant.
xibbumbero
Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:32:00 PM
JJ,get an alley sweeper semi-auto w/the 12 shot canister clip. That'll put the fear of God in any hamburglar. X
StogeeBoy
Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:34:00 PM
don't know much about shotguns but I do know that it really hurts when you try to shoot with one arm.
jjohnson28
Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:37:00 PM
X I already have a Ruger 10/22 for the heavy stuff...LOL
Mattie B
Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:37:00 PM
Personally, I have a pump action shotgun for security. I have a good bud that is a detective for the local police dept. He swears that the action of a pump shotgun is the most recognizable sound to an intruder.

Also, this way I can have a loaded gun without it being hot. I can chamber one in less than a second if needed. I also will add that I too have a little one in the house. I have bird shot in my gun also. One shot in the chest and one in the face...if he's not dead, he'll want to be.

MACS
Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:39:00 PM
The military uses both models.
grinder
Sunday, March 26, 2006 4:44:00 PM
a clip loads a magazine, a magazine feed the action.
Tuckersdad
Sunday, March 26, 2006 5:54:00 PM
Clintock & Andy -

The pros disagree with your beliefs/statements. I once believed as you do, until I got more training.

I'm speaking of ranges of 5-10 feet, and with cyllinder bore (the largest). Read the link I gave above and you'll see. These facts are well known and proven by pros.

Tuck

Mr. Jones
Sunday, March 26, 2006 6:54:00 PM
Go with the Mossberg 500 Security.

7 + 1 = 1 more shot than the Remington.

$239 is less than the Remington.

The Mossberg is available in 20 guage also if you want your wife to learn how to use it.

Mossbergs are the AK-47(dependable in all weather conditions and reliable) of the home defense shotguns.

Most Police use Mossbergs.

CWFoster
Monday, March 27, 2006 2:40:00 AM
WHAT ANDYTV SAID!

as to the brand, I would go with the Remington! Many of the 'civilian models of the Mossberg 500 have a plastic safety switch that tends to break across the screw hole, and I can assure you that this happens at the worst possible times. Other than this one design flaw (manufacturing cheapness) thay are both pretty dependable, but when I was a professional gunsmith, I had alot more M-500's in my shop than M-870's. My final word on the subject is material, the M-500 is usually found with an aluminium reciever, where the M-870, (not the 870LT) has a steel reciever. I prefer steel myself, but lockup is accomplished between the barrel and the bolt, so this is not a slam dunk litmus test.

Gunflintwoodshop
Monday, March 27, 2006 3:24:00 AM
I think a couple of things have to be cleared up. I go thru sometimes 1000 rounds a week at the range I have what you call a expensive hobby to say the least. I have a Mossberg 590 special purpose that I keep handy and I had to use it once while living in Virginia while I was in the service. Long story short I was lucky enough to hear the crackhead coming up the stairs thanks to my now 15 year old black lab and I was able to get my wife, dog and myself in the masterbath. Once he got in the bedroom he was looking for something that we must not have had because he kept screaming about how Tyrone must have sold it. I still to this day have no damn clue what he was talking about. Then it happened he was at the bathroom door pounding and my wife was crying and the was dog barking. I started yelling at him telling him "I have a gun and if you enter this room I will shoot". This went on for what might have been 30 seconds but it seemed like an hour. Then all of a sudden the door flew up and I squeezed the trigger - and what was chaos just a second before was over in a split second. As he lay dieing on my bedroom floor I grabbed my wife and dog and got them out of the house. I ran back upstairs and he was dead by the time I got to him which was only a minute or two after I shot him. All in all everything feel into our corner that night so to speak. I was at a range of 6 feet and the 00 buck had zero spread once it hit his chest in fact it went thru him and penetrated 1/2 drywall over 12 feet away. So if you ask me about what brand to buy I'd tell you who cares as long as when you pull the trigger you feel confident it will go bang. As far as which one holds the most rounds who really cares you need one maybe two shots at the most. The ranges for home defense are between 5-12 feet and it's at night most of the time. If you shoot someone at 10 yards you better pray he has a gun and it's pointed at you. It's going to be hard to explain why you shot a unarmed man at 30 feet when the cops get there. As far as the load goes I think #7, #8 or 00 Buck will all work just fine. What you have to remember is it's not only the load size but it's the amount of foot pounds behind the load size. The most important thing to remember is this isn't a combat zone or a riot zone this is your house and your family, and the winner on that night if that night ever comes will be the person who wants your family the most. All I can say is prepare, prepare, prepare I had a plan and we executed it without any flaws and criminal came to us and that is what you want. You want to have the control in a situation like I had - you want to make him have to come thru a 28" door to get you. While all the while you are waiting to meet his advancing attack on the other side. I never hesitated that night and I looked directly into his eyes as he stood in that door way and I squeezed that trigger. I have never had nightmares nor even felt bad about what happened that night, and I think it's because I know what would have happened to my wife if I hadn't been there. Just my two cents -- Gunflint
EI
  • EI
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, March 27, 2006 3:35:00 AM
12 ga pistol grip 18in barrel (easier to get thru a doorway with the gun at the ready)

Extended mag tubes are just fluff for a home defense shotgun. 4 rounds is plenty if you need more than that learn to combat reload and have a bandolier sling or belt with more shells. If you fire 4 shots and still need more you should be finding cover anyway.

First round #4 buck second thru forth rounds #00 buck.

Have a few rifled slugs on hand just in case you want to fire thru some walls,

A mounted light may be helpful but can also make you a target. It is better to have a light switch near your defensive position that will back light the advisary and not give your postion away