wer
  • wer
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 11, 2006 10:07:00 AM
The central dogma is that just about everything gets better with a little age on it. One debated exception is the RASS, some folks prefer 'em fresh. I've found another that I really like better OTT - Ashton VSG.

I've got a couple fistfuls of these that I wish I had fired up immediately. After a year or more, they really seem to have lost the peppery kick that I most like in this cigar. The mellowed, aged versions just aren't as good imho.

Any others that you prefer fresh vs. aged?

andytv
Thursday, May 11, 2006 10:14:00 AM
I bought a box of Mag46s that smoked better fresh than aged.

One thing to consider though........when many of us refer to "aged" we are referring to the cigars as they emerge from their sick period, which is really not "aged", but rather just smokeable. I have yet to try a Mag46 with more than 2 years on it.

bassdude
Thursday, May 11, 2006 10:20:00 AM
I don't think aged should have anything to do with the sick period. I have noticed that not all habanos experience this either. There are several habanos that are good fresh and aged - the flavor profile just really changes with the age. To me aged has to be 2 years or longer for Habanos. Doms really depned on how long the manufacturer aged them prior to marketing.

RASS - needs at least 3 years to be smokeable.

Fresh

Partagas black

Ashton VSG

DC Max

Both

PSD #4

Party short

Aged

Boli

RA

Punch

AF Hemis

DC Maddie

Just a few.

smelly4tay
Thursday, May 11, 2006 12:34:00 PM
I choose aged

Better Fresh:

-Oliva O Bold

-Bucanero Don Douglas

-CoRo

-Party Shorts

Both:

-CAO Black & Brazilia

-Torano Sig & Tribute

-Opus X

-Oliva Master Blends1

-Psd4

-Mag 46

Better aged:

-ALL Padron

-Excalibur Prensado Oscuro

-Bucanero Z

-AF Royal Salute SG & Maduro

-Partagas Lusitania

-La Punta

All IMO, and experience recently with comparisons to some of my favorite cigars fresh and aged 2+yrs. I could list a bunch more that are better with a few years.

deadeyedick
Thursday, May 11, 2006 4:41:00 PM
What is this "aged" you speak of?

DED