teedubbya
Monday, May 22, 2006 8:04:00 AM
I have yet to find one I like, and have tried almost all of them.

The only one I had not tried was the Edicion De Silvo. And I was really looking forward to trying one wich was graciously gifted to me by a fine botl with some other exceptional cigars.

I have heard these are the best thing since sliced bread, but I have to say I was disappointed. It was pretty uneventful, and reminded me of the other Perdomos I've had.

I really expected this one to stand out, but it didn't. So so while smoking it, less than desireable aftertaste. I followed it up with a R&J ISOM from the same botl which was excellent (compared to it)

Am I a heritic? Who likes these and what makes them so good. It did burn well, but so does a fireworks punk, a sparkler and a chunk of coal lol.

Just kidding. I know these are well regarded. Thoughts?

gunbuyer76
Monday, May 22, 2006 8:47:00 AM
same thing here brother tried most of thier stuff,,, the only 3 I like are the cantero maduro, and the perdomo2 maduro, and the la tradicion cammies
BeatDragon
Monday, May 22, 2006 8:53:00 AM
I must say that they are some of the prettiest looking cigars around. The construction and burn are wonderful, but the taste..well..

Thats why I call them PerDONTmo.

SteveS gave me one once that wasnt bad. I think it was whatever it is they call the Red labled Maduro ...I wouldn't go buy any but at leat I finished it.

jackconrad
Monday, May 22, 2006 9:15:00 AM
I can't imagine not liking the Champagne.
burgess_b
Monday, May 22, 2006 9:22:00 AM
what jack said.

i had a robusto of the ed de silvio, and i am telling you, BAM! hope the double corona is the same, but size matters alot in cigars, i am learning.

Charlie
Monday, May 22, 2006 9:23:00 AM
The estate series are all great cigars...Champaign is one of the very best mild cigars made...

Charlie

bloody spaniard
Monday, May 22, 2006 9:33:00 AM
What Jack, Burgie, and Charlie said.

Also, some pretty good, lower costing cigars, such as the Milenario Mistakes and the Fresh-rolled Wheels.

JHC
  • JHC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, May 22, 2006 9:46:00 AM
I enjoyed a Golf on Saturday. Taste was great. Could have used a little more humidor time. Had trouble with the burn.
Whistlebritches
Monday, May 22, 2006 9:54:00 AM
I have yet to find a Perdomo I don't like.I must admit I haven't tried them all.

Just won a couple 5'rs of the Cantero maduros.Can't wait to try em.

Any Perdomo's y'all don't want here is my addy

[email protected]

Ron

BeatDragon
Monday, May 22, 2006 10:09:00 AM
I didn't like the Champaign...Didn't finish it

Im not much for mild smokes, what I consider mild most would say is medium, but I do smoke them on rare occasisions, (Leon Jimenez is my go to mild) but I didn't care for the Champaign. I just dont care for the flavor profiles of the Perdomo lines.

teedubbya
Monday, May 22, 2006 10:56:00 AM
gotta go with Beat Dragon on this. To each there own, but there is something about the entire line I just don't care for.

Dgar
Monday, May 22, 2006 11:16:00 AM
I really like most of the perdomo cigars, the Champaign, Cuban Cafe, La tradicion Cameroon, 91 ESV aristocrata, lots of good smokes in my opion

Dgar (david)

Slimboli
Monday, May 22, 2006 11:27:00 AM
... ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh ...

... I'm not alone. Very few have been to my liking ...

... I've tried many times, but they just don't seem to do much for me.

ChrisND
Monday, May 22, 2006 11:39:00 AM
Soo much Perdomo bashing Im suprised. I have a question, for all that dislike Perdomo cigars, are you all Arturo Fuente fans?

Everybody I know who dislikes Perdomo love Arturo Fuente's. Im on the other hand the opposite, HUGE perdomo fan, dislike Fuentes!

Charlie
Monday, May 22, 2006 11:52:00 AM
My go to mild smokes are:

Perdomo Champaign

Cuseta Rey

Diamond Crown

Not in any order, but those are the mild cigars I smoke....

Charlie

BeatDragon
Monday, May 22, 2006 12:15:00 PM
Not much of a Fuente fan. I like SOME Fuentes, Hemmingways for example. I just think they are way to proud of their "ordinary" cigars that I wont buy them. Opus and DC's are IMHO the biggest ripp-offs in the indusrty. As are Anejos. Ordianry cigars pimped up as something else.

I do like the Fuente Cuban Belis however.

teedubbya
Monday, May 22, 2006 12:54:00 PM
I am more of a Padron fan. Regular line is an every day smoke for me. Anni are great but kind of pricy for my blood. Lately I'm mostly ISOM.... they are cheaper.

I do like the holiday fuentes etc, and the Don Carlos line is good, but I don't smoke many fuentes other than the holidays.

I don't really appreciate Opus like some do. My mild smokes are ashton maddies and AVO #2.

I'm not really a fan of Patel either. I like the vintage but none of the IT. Sungrowns are ok. But in general I put the IT and Perdomo in the same boat.

CAO - Brazilia, Italia and Criollo. The rest I can take or leave. MX2s are good with age but I've burnt myself out on them. My wife likes the gold labled camaroon belicoso.

I've struggled trying to like Gurkha as well. Some are pretty good others are not. None are great to me. I'd like to try their maddies.

La Aurora - regular line are great inexpensive mild cigars. Pref - red tube is my favorite the others I can take or leave. jimmenez is good for a mild smoke.

Lets see.... what line haven't I bashed lol

Oh yea. Litto Gomez just hurts me like tequila and I don't want to talk about the Macanoodles I started on. I'd rather smoke La Unica (actually the cammys are ok)

Punch and La Glorias are good lawn smokes.... but I always go back to Padron.

One of my favorites that dont really fit my profile are La Hoya Dark Sumatra Media Noche. Every time I have bought them, I've forgetten about them and ended up smoking them after the lables and the cedar are falling off. With age they are awsome.

Ok more than you asked for but I like to ramble.

Normous Fulani
Monday, May 22, 2006 1:10:00 PM
No, no, please don't stop. Tell us more.

What do you prefer for your early morning weekend smoke?

Also, if you had to choose breakfast from the following with said cigar, which one to pick- oatmeals or cream of wheats?

Then, please to explain if you use cow's milk, goat's milk, or water on selected breakfast.

Then, do you smoke while you move your bowels?

Does that interfere with smoke aroma or enhance it?

Do you have a Mr. Blunt costume?

Would you like one?

I anxiously await dignified anwers. Thank you.

teedubbya
Monday, May 22, 2006 1:18:00 PM
SCDH El Principe

Cream of Wheat - Chocolate

Cows milk in the cerial, goats milk on my person

Perdomo for the BM, birds of a feather seem to stimulate each other

It makes the Perdomo smell better

What I do and what I wear in the bedroom is my business....I am neither confirming or denying the costume

Maybe I'd like one when mine wears out.

Also I forgot Torano

I do like some of these and dislike some of these. But for the $$$ usually ok

Normous Fulani
Monday, May 22, 2006 1:28:00 PM
Thank you, Mr. TP.

I am mortified and otherwise exhililarated by your answers.

Do not hesitate to exonerate an otherwise exhume further brilliant cigar insights.

I am compilating a major cigar encyclopedia in Oorbanistani.

Bopa!