Let me see if I can clarify this.
I used to work in the news business, specifically, writing and editing news for newspaper and radio. Our international and national news sources are from AP and Reuters, local news from reporters.
We routinely edit news due to space/time constraint, rarely use the entire piece word for word, but the essential information will be there.
If you read several newspapers, listen to radio or watch TV that cover the same story, you will notice slight variation how each describes it, but the what, when, where, who, and how will always be the same.
Cigar catalogs are essentially the same, they receive promotional materials from same manufacturers/marketing companies regarding the same products, they will edit the promotional materials and use them in their catalogs.
Sometimes, when the catalog is about to go to press, and the marketing staff (like SteveR at CI/CBid) is (in lack of a better word) lazy (just kidding), overwork and can't come up with something, they may use the entire piece from the promotional materials, or just use someone else description, thinking and hoping that all die-hard, loyal customers would not notice it.
Since everyone is using the same source, it is hard not to notice the similarities.
How did I do?
Steve, are we still cool. My orders will not "mysteriouly disappear," would they? (j/k)