tailgater
Friday, June 23, 2006 6:46:00 PM
I just received the newest CI catalog, and it reminded me of something that I wanted to post after reading the previous one:

Who actually writes these?

Years ago, I used to receieve a competative catalog from the "T" company. It seems to me that a lot of the CI cigar descriptions sounded like the same author as the other guys.

The same words were over used, and the phrasing was earily similiar.

I'm sure it's difficult to make 200 different cigars sound enticing without excessive hyperbole, but I just have to wonder if they're using the same marketing group or something.

Please note, I have not read this newest issue yet, and I no longer receive that other rag. I'm just going off of memory.

Sboecker1
Friday, June 23, 2006 7:43:00 PM
Hmmmm. There is some similarity there. At least CI doesn't have gross overpricing of average cigars in their catalog.
pacman357
Saturday, June 24, 2006 3:21:00 AM
I think they're written by the same guy who appears in all those informercials, each time with a different sweater on.
Slow burning
Saturday, June 24, 2006 4:50:00 AM
Let me see if I can clarify this.

I used to work in the news business, specifically, writing and editing news for newspaper and radio. Our international and national news sources are from AP and Reuters, local news from reporters.

We routinely edit news due to space/time constraint, rarely use the entire piece word for word, but the essential information will be there.

If you read several newspapers, listen to radio or watch TV that cover the same story, you will notice slight variation how each describes it, but the what, when, where, who, and how will always be the same.

Cigar catalogs are essentially the same, they receive promotional materials from same manufacturers/marketing companies regarding the same products, they will edit the promotional materials and use them in their catalogs.

Sometimes, when the catalog is about to go to press, and the marketing staff (like SteveR at CI/CBid) is (in lack of a better word) lazy (just kidding), overwork and can't come up with something, they may use the entire piece from the promotional materials, or just use someone else description, thinking and hoping that all die-hard, loyal customers would not notice it.

Since everyone is using the same source, it is hard not to notice the similarities.

How did I do?

Steve, are we still cool. My orders will not "mysteriouly disappear," would they? (j/k)

johnfs
Saturday, June 24, 2006 7:38:00 AM
Slow pretty much sumed it up, companies make promo packs w/ the description, and the distributers pretty much press their release.

J

pabloescabar
Saturday, June 24, 2006 9:47:00 AM
your crazy
TrishS@CigarBid
Monday, June 26, 2006 7:36:00 AM
Sorry guys, but you're way off. Our catalogs are taste tested and written by our own CI Staff. Not all of us, but a couple of guys who are holed up in a closed room all day and smell like old cigars.
Steve*R
Monday, June 26, 2006 7:59:00 AM
TrishS@CigarBid wrote:"Sorry guys, but you're way off. Our catalogs are taste tested and written by our own CI Staff. Not all of us, but a couple of guys who are holed up in a closed room all day and smell like old cigars."

What a crock! Every resource, whether manufacturer or distributor, provides some semblance of ad copy. It can be cut sheets, camera ready photographs of product, or basic suggestions for in-house copy. Were you to go to the major manufacturer's websites, there is ad copy for each product. Virtually all of it may be reprinted with slight modification by retailers.

TrishS, I can assure you that your CI staff writers, without resource provided copy guidelines and source provided information would probably be reduced to writing; "A wonderful brown cigar," unless it's green. Of course there's going to be similarities in copy from retailer to retailer. Everyone gets the same cut sheets and descriptions from the resource.

I'd wager that blindfolded, without resource information, 99% of the copywriters wouldn't know what they're smoking.

Jon@CAO
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:06:00 AM
!
Charlie
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:07:00 AM
My hat is off to any writer who can try and make some of the crap in the catalog sound half way good......

Victor Sinclairs, Drew Estates, Puros Indios, Free Cubas, etc.....LOL

Charlie

SteveR@CigarBid
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:08:00 AM
Steve - You obviously don't know how we go about writing our descriptions. My apologies, but what Trish says is far from a 'crock', sir.
Steve*R
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:24:00 AM
SteveR@CBid: Thanks for the chuckle.

I guarantee that without a cut sheet or other descriptive material, describing the composition of each cigar, you and the other copywriters wouldn't know where to begin. Take, for example, the older P.I. and Cuba Aliados lines. Rolando Sr. took great pride in the fact that Colorado, Colorado Claro, Claro, and Maduro all had identical coloration. Only the doble maduro was distinguishable by color, and it was rosado. Unless you'd smoked boxes of each, you'd be hard pressed to distinguish one from the other in print.

So where do you start?

You grab the cut sheet with the descriptions and compositions.

Of course, the embellishment copy will vary from retailer to retailer. We all know about the lawsuits filed over copywrite infringement and cigar catalogs.

SteveR@CigarBid
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:29:00 AM
Steve - How about I send you an application...you can do the writing for us?
puskarich
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:34:00 AM
"I'd wager that blindfolded, without resource information, 99% of the copywriters wouldn't know what they're smoking."

Heck, I'd wager that blindfolded, 99.999999999% of ALL CIGAR SMOKERS, wouldn't know what they were smoking. The remainder would get lucky.

Steve*R
Monday, June 26, 2006 8:36:00 AM
SteveR wrote: "Steve - How about I send you an application...you can do the writing for us?"

Steve*R replied, laughing: "That's the third offer I've received to write cigar catalog copy in the past few months. Thankfully, I've been retired for six years, and have no plan to become employed again.

Hopefully, you're jesting.

Steve*R
Monday, June 26, 2006 9:37:00 AM
puskarich wrote:"I'd wager that blindfolded, 99.999999999% of ALL CIGAR SMOKERS, wouldn't know what they were smoking. The remainder would get lucky."

I think many experienced cigar smokers could distinguish between puros, cigars rolled from tobacco exclusively from one country. Such as: "This tastes like a Nicaraguan cigar."

In that most cigars, other than habanos are multi-nation blends, I think blindfolds would make many primos into pooch projectiles.

I've been to many blind tastings and people rarely have a clue what they're smoking. They either like a stick or don't.

dup
  • dup
  • Herf-A-Holic
Monday, June 26, 2006 9:50:00 AM
tailgater sorry for this threadjack , but it's almost along the same lines.

i've noticed in the auctions that when i go from one cigar to the next that it's the same pic and the same description to a tee.

all A.F's don't look the same or taste the same...this isn't every auction description but i'm sure if you go through them right now and look at the pic and description and click "next" auction that if it's close it will have the same description and pic.

can't there be a little more accuracy in the description?

I know you all work hard. but a pic and description of a certain cigar could be on file for future use instead of copying another cigar's layout. then if you run across one you don't have a description for you can sample it and write up a new description.

like these two below....

both are A.F. Rothschild but one is Maduro.

same pic and same description.....

But they don't taste the same.

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/lot.cfm?lotID=360886 

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/lot.cfm?lotID=360887 

that's just two....there's other's listed that copy everything in the auction although it's two seperate and different tasting cigar's ?????

(figured i'd toss it out there while the staff's here!)

hehehe

Rocky@Indian
Monday, June 26, 2006 11:47:00 AM
CI does a fantastic job with their catalog copy. In my opinion, they're tops in the industry.
SteveR@CigarBid
Monday, June 26, 2006 11:49:00 AM
Steve - No worries, I am totally joking. We have a great crew with a ton of knowledge...together our taste buds do a damn fine job at describing cigars and different tobaccos. Although you might not want to believe it, we're actually quite experienced over here...after all, it's our job.
pacman357
Monday, June 26, 2006 12:00:00 PM
"Our catalogs are taste tested and written by our own CI Staff."

______________________

So, how do your catalogs taste? I'm smoking one right now, and frankly, I find them a bit harsh and one-dimensional. Maybe some time in the humi will help...

______________________

BTW, Steve@Cbid, I'll take an application. I have a BA in English from the U of Washington, and A JD (law degree) from U of Puget Sound. After nearly 20 years in criminal defense, and a brief career in sales (18 months or so) I can put a spin anything! Just send me some samples, tell me where to write the ad copy, and boom, we're in bidness.