jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:10:00 AM
Seeing that I can't get these from my local smoke shops, I'm looking for feedback about the following:

* El Mejor Espresso

* 1876 Reserve

* Pirate's Gold Maduro

* Morro Castle

My big concern is construction, consistency, and flavor - the last being the most important of the three. So, if you would, highlight these in your comments. If you think they're a pooch projectile, please explain the reason why.

johnfs
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:14:00 AM
"If you can say anything good then don't say anything at all", my mom.

No comment.

J

steeliefly
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:17:00 AM
Check out the CI Staff Reviews on the sister site. Brando seems to like the El Major Espresso.
bassdude
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:19:00 AM
what John said.
golden13
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:25:00 AM
jpotts, I did not personally care for the Pirates Gold. I have a few left. If you want them to try, they are yours. Just drop me an e-mail.

[email protected]

J.Redleg
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:28:00 AM
From your list, I'd pick the El Mejor Espresso. Good flavor for a bundled cigar and it gets better with age.
jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:28:00 AM
steeliefly:

Not to sound like a paranoid jerk, but the CI staffers are rarely going to say anything really bad about the stock they sell. Usually when they say, "good value" it may mean "these are really good, and low priced," or "these suck, but they're inexpensive, so that makes them suck less." That's why I'm looking for actual purchaser reviews. If I get enough people saying, "these are really great tasting, but they canoe about half-way," then I might consider trying them.

In all actuality, the only reason why I'm looking at these sticks is based on the comments at CI. But I really don't like buying something that I'm definately not going to like.

SteveR@CigarBid
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:34:00 AM
jpotts - Take a look at my reviews. You'll notice a bunch of negative write-ups. Honesty builds customer loyalty. If I think a cigar is crap, I'm going to tell you I think it is crap, rather than have you find out for yourself and, in turn, go elsewhere.
JPR
  • JPR
  • Herf-A-Holic
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 11:45:00 AM
jpotts - "these are really great tasting, but they canoe about half-way" - kidding

The El Mejor are pretty good they compare to the Nestor Reserve (recommended).

The other three, for the price you get sometimes on CBid, I would give a fiver a shot if they interest you at all. Smoke two of each - everyone's tastes are different.

If you like them - you found a winner at a bargain, if you don't, you didn't really lose much.

golden13
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 1:45:00 PM
jpotts, I just checked and I have 3 of these left. I do not want them, so they are your if you want. Just send me your info and they are all yours.

[email protected]

cooksta2
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 6:02:00 PM
The only one I would ever consider again is the El Mejor
jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 8:19:00 PM
SteveR:

I looked at *all* of the CI reviews (at least as far as I could tell). While I did see some you-can-buy-better-for-the-price comments, and the occasional let-these-sit-for-a-while, I noticed the flee-from-this-stick-like-a-screaming-drooling-madman remarks were wholly absent. You know was well as I do that there are some wholesale purchases that end up being urea-laced turds with pretty bands on them (the typical "oh my God, what the he** was I thinking when I bought these" lament). This is the stuff that I want to avoid invading my humidor. I had a bad Belinda Black experience not long ago, and I'm looking to not repeat that mistake...

(The very mention of Belinda so-and-so nearly brings me to retching.)

I did my homework on some of these, and the reation was mixed, which is the reason why I'm doing more research. On others (like Morro Castle), I can find virtually nothing outside of the CI product description. Ergo, this post.

By the way, does SteveR chiming in on this post mean that Big Brother is watching? Or is that the paranoia resurfacing. Oh my God...Belinda Black flashback! Save me....SAVE ME...!

jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 8:26:00 PM
SteveR:

And no - I'm not trying to say that CI occasionally sells abject crap. I just wanted to clarify this.

pacman357
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 9:15:00 PM
Bollocks! A pox on you and the horse you rode in on... Oh, wait, just read the title, not the first section. Never mind.
jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, July 5, 2006 9:49:00 PM
pacman357:

Touche'.

Drathaar
Thursday, July 6, 2006 12:04:00 AM
I have found there are 2 Belinda Blacks. The ones cbid sells, and the other kind. The other kind are good, not great, but a good yard gar. The ones on cbid are crap. You can tell the difference by the wrapper. The "other kind" actually have a black (or dark brown) wrapper. Cbid's have a pale wrapper.

As for the others you mentioned, I've only tried 1 of the 4. And they are a steal! Pretty damn good with some age on them.

jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, July 6, 2006 6:13:00 AM
I had the Cubano oscuro, which was akin to smoking a maduro wrapper over maduro filler, and maduro binder - waaaaayyyyy too sweet for my tastes. It was one of the only cigars that I had that nearly made me puke - and that's saying a lot. In my opinion, there either wasn't enough filler to balance the wrapper, or there wasn't enough strength of flavor. I almost had the same problem with a Sanch Panza Double Maduro, though I felt it was blended far better.

Granted, some may like this type of stick - I don't. I also noticed that some of it mingled with my other cigars, so now I've got a rather unpleasent reminder of this bad experience every time I light up. Ergo, my hesitation.

causeofhim
Monday, July 17, 2006 7:35:00 PM
Dont waste your money on the 1876s.
BigAlnAZ
Monday, July 17, 2006 8:03:00 PM
I haven't tried any of the sticks you mentioned, but I have smoked a lot of "bundle" cigars. Super Primo seconds, Punch seconds, Over Production, mistakes, etc etc etc. In my humble opinion, you can't really go wrong with the Nestor Reserves or the RP Seconds from CBid. You can usually score a bundle for a decent price. They smoke well right out of the mail and they age well in the humi.

For what it's worth..

pacman357
Monday, July 17, 2006 8:51:00 PM
I like the EMs, especially after having them unwrapped and sitting next to spanish cedar in my humi for a few months. The pirates are a decent yard gar, same for the MCs. Haven't tried the 1876 fiver, something tells me I'll wait until I have a cold and can't taste them much. Saving those types for colds and flus, just to get a fix.