advanracing62
Friday, July 7, 2006 6:19:00 AM
Inspired by my other thread on how to taste- Thought it might be fun to have a taste off. Noobs and vets alike- We can select a stick, smoke it, note the flavours we taste and then compare notes. The noobs will get to see what others taste, and the vets will get to be king of the hill on this one (so to speak.)

I think this would allow some of us that don't quite get the flavour thing just yet, to see how we compare to others in the tasting realm. Maybe we'll learn a thing or two.... Anyone think this is:

a. a good idea?

b. going to work?

nine999
Friday, July 7, 2006 6:55:00 AM
sounds good to me, but then again, i'm married, which means i don't hav a life...

so yeah, this sounds GREAT!-lol

here's an idea, pick a common stogie, one that a lot of us may have sitting in the humi- like say, isom monte #2.

ok, just kidding. never even seen one before- but you get the idea. perhaps a cammie. i've seen a lot of type about cammies lately.

hmmmm... any one else have any ideas? ....that don't include pulling fingers?

nine

SteveR@CigarBid
Friday, July 7, 2006 6:56:00 AM
In order to work, each participant must submit their notes without seeing what others have to say. Often times, reading or hearing what others have to say about a cigar will influence their opinions on flavor, strength, etc.
dadz
Friday, July 7, 2006 6:58:00 AM
how about a $3 stick we can get at our local?
SteveR@CigarBid
Friday, July 7, 2006 7:20:00 AM
A box should be split to ensure that each cigar is from the same crop, year, production period, etc. Otherwise, one person may be tasting a cigar with an additional month or year of age on it.
Homebrew
Friday, July 7, 2006 7:35:00 AM
Yep, Steve has a point.

It would be best, more accurate, if they all came from the same box.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

nine999
Friday, July 7, 2006 7:41:00 AM
wow- never even considered that. guess thats why i'm sittin' behind this computer and not strolling around a walkin humi, deciding what to smoke....damn...

a good idea would be to bid on a box of 20/25, have all participants split the cost, send in all reviews to one, unlucky, yet very good ttyyypist aand he kannn intrre all thu reevyoos.

nnnniias/aljds

advanracing62
Friday, July 7, 2006 7:48:00 AM
Agreed- A box would be the best way to go. I guess if we did it that way- we could all put in x amount and buy a box of an agreed upon stick, providing we have enough people to merit that quantity.

I guess at this point it's kind of a rough idea- but definately something that would be fun, interesting, and a good learning experience.

I was thinking that we could take notes when smoking- then come on here and just hit reply- post our notes- then go back and see how we compare. Kind of the honour system.

andytv
Friday, July 7, 2006 8:06:00 AM
I liked the "blind taste test" format that Drnos ran a few times.

It went something, but not quite, like this....

The applicants are sent a fiver of the same sticks without bands, but each numbered.

They then smoke them in order and take notes. Once both have completed their tasting session (or all of the tasting sessions), the notes are revealed......as is the name of the stick.

I had a LOT of fun when I particpated.

advanracing62
Friday, July 7, 2006 8:08:00 AM
^ that sounds like a good idea. We'd have to nominate someone to be the one to send everything out and to. Yeah, that does sound like it would be the best route to go. That way we'd end up with one master thread with comments and what not.
nine999
Friday, July 7, 2006 8:35:00 AM
advancracing- good of you to volunteer to do everything. how noble of you. i thank you in advance; er...advanc.

i'm in, let me know all the details.

(lol)

nine

andytv
Friday, July 7, 2006 8:47:00 AM
OK..........I'll put something together........see trades board.

advanracing62
Friday, July 7, 2006 8:56:00 AM
Meh- I'll do it... I don't mind. So far it looks like there are four of us, I have a local guy that wants in. We could get away with fivers at this point....

How long should we wait before we start? a week? a month? I'll buy the sticks and then will send an invoice out for the cost? emails will need to be had- umm... what else?

nine999
Friday, July 7, 2006 9:16:00 AM
why not "BID" on the a box?

that way it can be kinda random?

nine

advanracing62
Friday, July 7, 2006 10:57:00 AM
yeah, I suppose we could bid on a box- though people would know who it was and then know the sticks they were going to get- in theory...
infiniterapture
Friday, July 7, 2006 3:08:00 PM
Sounds like a great opportunity of a cigar club on cbid. Put em on special, after you smoke one and submit a review to cbid you get a half a cent credit on your next auction win 😛
dadz
Friday, July 7, 2006 10:23:00 PM
advanracing62 and andytv

you guys have some good ideas.

There's no question taste is developed, and we need the opportunity to train ourselves for fuller enjoyment. I wish I could get into the Andytv tasteoff. My taste runs to 3$ sticks. Shipping always increasing costs, but approx $40 for a 5er is too much.

infiniterapture - good idea for cigar club. Review and discount could work with some creative plan.

advanracing62
Saturday, July 8, 2006 5:27:00 AM
IF CBid recognized a cigar club- you'd have to have dues paying members, other wise everyone would be able to sign up and get a discout or rebate. You'd probably have to limit number of people that are involved in the club too. Not saying it's not a good idea- just not sure how to really work it and make it seem fair.

As far as the fivers go- those are just the tasters that are sent out- I'd think, depending on participants, we could just say for the five boxes it was x amount- we sent x sticks from each box and have x left over- and then split them among ourselves... maybe even make it kind of part of a trade- you know throw in a couple of our favourite sticks... You wouldn't have to send to everyone- your sticks I mean, we'd set up a trade pair and the two would just send sticks to each other... I would send out the remaining sticks in the boxes- That's pretty much the only way I could see that working... thoughts?

rbmbb
Saturday, July 8, 2006 5:49:00 AM
The best way to go about it seems to be the Andytv method, where someone picks up sticks and sends them out to several people who will review each stick blindly.

Then you send your review of the sticks to the person who sent you the gars(via email so as not to taint the remaining testers...) and voila...the trick she is done!

R

JMO

advanracing62
Sunday, July 9, 2006 1:19:00 PM
I'll see what I can do then- I'll post a new thread when I get everything together, so people can sign up...