I have a box of cuban Bolivar Churchill tubos from 2000. I am about to sample one. I will let you know how they have not dropped in flavor. LOL
While I enjoy Nicks products, I have not noticed a drop in flavor in them, when even aged 3-4 years. Myself, I find that they become much better when aged up to 10 years. I recently smoked a 98 Punch Punch, which was like having a religous experience.
I guess that flavor is in the palate of the individual smoker.
Have a great day.
Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)
P.S. This Perdomo Signature Maddie, old blend, that I am smoking right now, is smoking great at 4+ years of age.