Pacman,
I'll take a shot at it. Although I am completely biased in my opinion.
The Civil War was the culmination of our founding fathers not having the guts to take make tough decisions on where America was going to go.
Both sides had honorable reasons for fighting. For the North, the majority of people fighting to keep a fledgling democracy together. The South fought for States rights.
Sure there were dirtbags and dubious characters and evil motivations on both sides. Some of the Northerners were dispicable carpetbaggers. The some in the South were blind racists and wanted to keep "the Darkies" in line.
But it came down to Brother verses Brother. Father versus Son. They fought like mad for 4 years because both sides believed in their cause.
Shelby Foote's "The Civil War" is in the neighborhood of 2,600 pages of history and characters you couldn't make up. I'm better than two/thirds of the way through it. Some of it is dry, but many of these soldiers and how their mids worked, their passions, their ideology was something some of us can barely comprehend.
People fought with honor. They followed orders and tactics that were outdated compared to the weaponry they were up against.
Robert E. Lee could have gone with a guerilla campaign in Virginia instead of handing over his sword. It would have taken generations (if ever) to squash all rebels in South. If Lee doesn't surrender with honor, the USA would cease to exist. We'd probably be under the hand of the British again, or we'd be fractured into a handful of ragged country states that would have the combined power of today's Albania, Serbia, Croatia etc.
A friend of mine just came back from Gettysburg last week. He walked in the same footsteps where his great (or great great) grandfather walked in July of 1863. He said it was the most powerful emotional thing he has ever been through.
It does have a lot to do with where you are. Myash in Virginia. Jet in Georgia. No fighting happended in Wisconsin, but the Iron Brigade came from here and were one fiercest group of fighters on either side of the Mason/Dixon line.
I've went to more than a handful of reinactments. Seeing two or three hundred people marching across an open field, walking into cannon fire is a sight to behold. Some battles had tens of thousands of people involved. Its almost inconceivable.
The American Revolution was a big deal, but the Civil War tore America down, so it could rise back up together as one strong nation.
(stepping off my soapbox).
That's why guys like me are into it.