Cycleman
Monday, August 28, 2006 12:09:00 PM
Stan and I were talking about the "Sick Cigars" time frame.

How long are they sick? I would guess it depends on the stick of course, but we were really talking about Cuban's (that we heard about).

I thought the sickness was from the first roll..... to about a year, but Stan has heard that they are good at first..... then they hit a "Sick" period..... and then they are good again......

RED SAID:

From my readings over the years, not many "domestic" cigars get sick once you buy them. The reason being that quality control had been better, and that there's a bit less demand for them, so the manufacturers have the time to ferment the tobacco sometimes twice or three times. They often, then, age the tobacco as well before making cigars.

They then, seem to be able to keep the cigars in the factory long enough to age them on site, sometimes for the better part of a year or longer.

In the late 1990s and even into today, this had not been true for Habanos. While all indications are the quality control is better now that Altadis owns nearly half of Habanos S. A., they still seem to be only fermenting tobacco however long it needs it up to three fermentations. But they are then not aging most of the leaf, instead sending it right into the galeras. The finished cigars are getting some aging, but nowhere near the full year or more like the domestically available brands.

Therefore many still believe that if you like them young let them rest a week or so and try them, then put them away at the six month mark or just before and don't touch them until the year mark has passed.

I haven't experimented with all of this, but I've read about it and discussed with enough friends of mine who have.

Any other thoughts..........

rbmbb
Monday, August 28, 2006 12:23:00 PM
I dont understand why anyone ages Cuban cigars, the moment i get one i smoke it (ok, i wait a few weeks but then...) I think they are great right off the truck( or plane....or is it boat? I don't know)

If they taste any better with age than they already do, I would probably pass out.

R

Smoke the dang things, that's what they are there for.

edwarderc2
Monday, August 28, 2006 3:10:00 PM
Thank you, Randy, my sentiments exactly.

BTW, is your Cuban humi still stuffed?

Slimboli
Monday, August 28, 2006 5:00:00 PM
Cigars need to age at least a year.

Cigars are best smoked during the first three months after they are rolled ... or a year after they are rolled.

During that nine-month period, known to aficionados as "the sick period," cigars are relatively tasteless compared to the brash young cigars, and the much more refined cigars that have been aged a year or more.

During the 'sick period' the cigars create ammonia as one of the by-products of normal plant decompostion ... which you will surely taste in a cigar that is going through that period of time. If you enjoy that taste ... smoke 'em up.

Slimboli
Monday, August 28, 2006 5:01:00 PM
Oh ... and I should point out, practically every single cigar available on the shelves of tobacconists in the US has been properly aged, and "the sick period" is something that only people who smoke Cuban cigars should worry about.

jpotts
Tuesday, August 29, 2006 4:42:00 AM
This is just a guess, but I think the reason why Cubans are rushed out the door faster isn't because of tradition, technique, or whatever. I think it might be that Cuba needs the money.

Like I said, it's just a guess.

Slimboli
Tuesday, August 29, 2006 5:13:00 AM
Very good guess ...
Bluedevil
Tuesday, August 29, 2006 5:26:00 AM
Very helpful thread!

Thanks

Cycleman
Tuesday, August 29, 2006 7:20:00 AM
My dear friend Heavy Metal rote this yesterday. IT IS OUTSTANDING INFO:

Answer is: Depends. Depends on 1) who you're talking to and 2) the cigar.

I'll side with Min Ron Nee on this as my experience parallels his. In his book "An Illustrated Encyclopaedia of Post-Revolution Havana Cigars", Nee says cigars undergo several maturations. He categorizes them as:

Sick Period - one month after production to around 2 years.

First Maturation - around 5 years

Second Maturation - 15 - 25 years

Third Maturation - 50 years up

He notes that there are "sick periods" were the cigars can go flat in between maturations. He speculates that this is caused by the complex oils in cigars breaking down into more simple compounds and the migration of those compounds thru the tobacco. This breakdown and migration is what causes "plume".

I personally don't like the term "sick period" so I don't use it. Since it's a matter of taste, I use the term "flat". That's how they taste to me. The cigar's flavors become muted and flat. There's still some flavor there, but it's off, muted, flat.

Some smokers seem not to mind this or can't really tell, so for them there is no sick period. Some appear to be less sensitive to it, so for them the period is shorter.

From my experience, habanos go flat around 1 - 3 months after rolling. THIS DOES NOT MEAN 1 -3 MONTHS AFTER THE BOX DATE. The box date is the date the cigars are packaged, not the date they were rolled. The dates usually are close but the box date can be a few months after the rolling date. The only way to tell is to smoke one. As long as the cigars don't have an ammonia smell to them, I'll try one. If they have that fresh "chincales" taste (a slightly bitey, fresh tobacco taste), I might smoke a couple. The rest will get aged for at least 9 months after the box date. Depending on the cigar, I'll try them then and maybe smoke them (like Party Shorts or Choix Supreme). Others I'll let sit for longer - sometimes up to 5 years depending upon my patience and stock.

Within the past few years I haven't received cigars with the ammonia smell. This was due to incomplete fermentation and post-fermentation processing. With new methods and some quality controls instituted by Altadis this seems to be a past issue.

As far as long term again (5+ years), I'll again side with Nee. A 5 year old cigar tastes significantly different than a 2 year old smoke. Ditto at 10, 15, etc. I've smoked a few 10 - 25 year old habanos and they do change significantly. I've also had some flat ones, let them rest for a while and they aren't flat. So I'll also buy his argument that there are additional flat periods between the maturations. Never had a 25+ cigar, but I hear they're amazing.

As far as N/C, yes they go thru a similar maturation. It's a bit different since most N/C is pre-aged before boxing (apparently to avoid the first flat period). A good example is Opus. Opus are reportedly aged 2 years before boxing, yet I still don't like them "fresh". I think they have an excessively hot-spicy flavor that overwhelms the other flavors (essentially they're flat to me - a one dimensional flavor). After about another year they begin to loose the excessively spiciness and start developing additional flavors. At 2 - 3 years they've hit a peak. And I've had orginal-release Opus that were amazing. These ages would closely correspond to Nee's First and Second Maturations.

These days I generally smoke "young" cigars only to try them and tell how they will age. If I like them I lay down an aging stock.

todd38sd
Wednesday, August 30, 2006 1:55:00 PM
i have heard from a very "reliable source that the time frame for optimum aging is six months......if you don't age them for at least six months you simply cannot expect them to be any good!

especially if your mommy buys them for you!

02
  • 02
  • Aficionado
Wednesday, August 30, 2006 6:15:00 PM
Good stuff...

The only way to know for sure is to try one every 3 months or so until they taste "awesome" to you. I had a few smokes in Mexico. They were probably all very young. Most were very good but a couple were a bit average. (yes they were real)

So six months is a good timeframe after you receive them to start the trial period. If they taste good but not "awesome" after six months give them a few more months before trying again.

I have heard this from several guys many times.... Next post...

02
  • 02
  • Aficionado
Wednesday, August 30, 2006 6:18:00 PM
I have heard this several times ^^ continued...

Someone buys a box of Cubans and lets them rest for a month or two before he smokes them. He smokes a few, hands out a few and they seem pretty good. He then forgets about them when he's down to just 5 left (or he doesn't want to smoke them because he's running low).

After a year or so he decides to smoke another and DAMN!! It's REAL GOOD!!!

Now he's made because he smoked and gave away the other 20 not realizing how great they would be after a long rest period...

Just what I hear over and over and over again in these posts!!