Sardious
Tuesday, September 19, 2006 2:09:00 PM
What is the deal with these? I have been watching bidding for a while but these always sell really low, lower than pirates gold. What is up with that? Makes me afraid to try them
bsevern
Tuesday, September 19, 2006 2:21:00 PM
Bought two 5'er's of torps (natural and maddies) but haven't tried 'em yet. They look pretty nice, box pressed, nice oily maddies. It seems like being from Perdomo they should at least be OK.

If you do a search on here there's others that seemt to enjoy them, but top25review.com is pretty mixed (they do seem to like the torps!).

Cal

Boxtakilla
Tuesday, September 19, 2006 6:48:00 PM
I took the chance and bought a 5-pack of naturals and maddys. They are well worth the $7.00 I paid for 5 of them.

The maduros are mild and tasty.

I'll buy more when I clear these out of the humi!

Sardious
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 7:47:00 AM
cool I should have about $50 to spend on sticks in a week comming up here I was thinking of not going for the big name ones getting some more bulk for the buck so I may try to win a 5er or 2 of these.
engletl
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 8:12:00 AM
These are one Perdomo product that I do not care for at all. No flavor and bad burn.

Todd

bsevern
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 8:16:00 AM
Todd do you think some aging would help these along? They actually look very nice, but haven't fired one up yet (got a couple of 5'ers on here for cheap).

Cal

richokeeffe
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 8:17:00 AM
well, here's my 2 cents

The TDS are a lower end stick that, if you have developed a taste for the higher end ones will probably not do the job for you. If you are the sort of smoker that can debate whether you like the 97 or 99 crop of the Anejo better, these are probably not the stick for you. In the price range that they live in, they are a great value. Heck, for less than 2 bucks a stick at CI prices, they are an excellent value smoke.

For me, I have four grades of smoke that seem to correspond to pricing at CI. This is a guide and not an absolute. The other requirement to go on a list is that I have to like them. There are some popular sticks that I just don't like, so they go in the last category

1) Oh My God - special occasion sticks

2) Really good - $2 to $6 a stick when buying a box/bundle at CI

3) Everyday value smoke - usually less than $2.50 a stick when buying a box/bundle at CI

4) Won't smoke it - even if you try to pay me to

the TDS are a staple in my "Everyday value smoke" category.

Hope this all helps

BuckyB93
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 8:25:00 AM
At the risk of post padding, I'd have to agree with Rich.

Regarding the del Sol in particular, I like the maddies over the nats.

bassdude
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 9:02:00 AM
the TDS fits #4 for me. and aging does not help them.
sw48362
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 11:48:00 AM
Smoked one from a 5pk, put the other four away somewhere to sleep. I'll find them again someday when I am reshuffling my gars, ain't goin to look for them though. Don't remember finishing the cigar, do remember thinking maybe age will help.
Sardious
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 1:18:00 PM
yeah may just go for one 5 pack to see how it goes. many of the $2 and under CI retail I have not liked so well, but only having 5 lets me have 2 or 3 over a month before I decide.

I am still waiting for those LVH fumas to get out of backorder. I loved those things and they were great cost. In my inder $2 a stick buys at CI retail only LVH and the V centennials have tasted good to me. V centennial has bad burn issues almost every time though and the LVH fumas in the Connecticut shade is not my deal. I still need to try Sherpa.

Anyway the tierra del sol being nicaraguan and perdomo (love their stuff usually) and the picture made it look good, just the bidding on them scared me off. I will try for a fiver though. You guy rule with the advice

bsevern
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 2:26:00 PM
Let me just do a sanity check then.... would you guys then classify (using richokeeffe's grading system) that Nestor Reserve Maduro's are #3 or possible #2 smoke on the list?

Thanks,

Cal

Helio
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 2:59:00 PM
I put the Nestor Reserve Maddies at a definite #2. The Nestor Reserve connies, well.....right now, yard gar. Hopefully in a few months, better yard gar. But, at 31 for a bundle of 50, who cares. I do have some TDS churchill naturals. Not the best cigar, but far and away from the worst.
burgess_b
Wednesday, September 20, 2006 11:26:00 PM
i agree with rich, as well...i like them...and i hand them out to mooches, who also "say" they like them.

never had the nats...maddies are good...only had 1 bad one.

Altutor
Thursday, September 21, 2006 1:34:00 PM
For the money, they are great smokes. Perdomo usually doesn't disappoint. They are smooth, medium bodied smoke. Slightly nutty and flavorful.

The great attribute of this smoke is the price. If you don't like them, at least you didn't pay $10 a stick.

FuzzNJ
Thursday, September 21, 2006 6:31:00 PM
I like the maddies for a yard cigar, didn't like the naturals at all.