Well lets think on this. I see people here bidding 5 to 10 dollars for an empty box, so I'd say the looks matter but fictionality is important too. The function is simple, #1 protection, #2 the taste that the cedar supposedly imparts, #3 the solid look that sells your brand as "not being crappy"
The looks do matter for sales. For me a plywood box like many fuente or such is fine... a thin cedar sheet for the scent and all is well. A wood box always seems more quality upon looking but a great design on the cardboard/plywood box will achieve good things as well.
To me I struggle with the new bundle craze where $20 dollar a stick is in your local B&M in a budle. I grew up on the "bundle = crap" times. Bundles were for don nobodies and people who claimed their stuff was seconds of someone famous but were straight out lying. I see a box like the Gurkha titan or beast or like diamond crown and I get the impression of "quality" before I even smell or feel the stick.
When I see a diamond crown or a montecristo platinum or an Opus X box I feel more ok spending $16 to try it.
That is where the box ends. If the product does not equal the price then the box will win only so many people but not too many keepers.
Still some habe $6 cigar that is worth it plus tax and then I like to collect the box if I can