ianmac864
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 11:07:00 PM
Please answer me this...I am constantly reading cigar reviews of people's experiences with their cigars. Many of them insist they taste things such as chocolately, leathery, woody, earthy, creamy, cocoa, wheat, sugar, honey, on and on...the cigar starts out tasting like this, then it changes to that, and ends tasting like something else. I have been a cigar smoker for about 2 1/2 years now; all I have tasted is: sweet/bitter/grass/spicy/salty.

Do these folks just have too much time on their hands? Or, has my tongue and palate failed me?

Just curious.

pacman357
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 12:28:00 AM
Run a search. Subject has been addressed here before. One suggestion Steve had was occasionally exhale through your nose. May help you get a taste.

Everyone has different tastes. Just as some folks have better eyesight, hearing, etc., than others, some folks have a keener sense of taste. I find the reviews helpful, but don't always taste what another person tastes. If your sense of taste isn't as sharp, it's not the end of the world. Bottom line is smoke what you like.

johnfs
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 4:44:00 AM
I still haven't found the taste of cucumber or clam chowder in any smoke yet.
Homebrew
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 6:09:00 AM
When I set out to do a review, the conditions must be right. My sinuses must be clear. I must have the time, free from distractions, so that I can fully concentrate on the cigar. It does take full concentration, to do a good review. Yes exhaling nasally will help you discern certain flavors, such as cedar, and citrus. But all this said, I have been a chef for 22 years and a sensitive palate is a job requirement. Though your palate may not be as sensitive, I believe that if you slow down, and concentrate totally on the cigar, you will notice more of the flavors in the cigar.

Have a great day.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

ianmac864
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 8:11:00 AM
Thanks for everyone's insight...sorry for not having searched for previous answers. I'm just now getting my feet wet in the forum area.

I will try your suggestions, and see what happens.

Clam chowder and cucumbers, eh? I was really hoping to find one that smokes like wings and fries myself...and ice cold beer, of course!

sw48362
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 8:35:00 AM

Depends on many factors: Location you are smoking the cigar(inside or outside), the temp and humidity reading of the air while you are smoking the cigar, what you are doing (golfing or reading), what you are drinking, sinus issues, etc....

Several years ago, I was vacationing in the Dominican Republic very near the ocean. I lit up a H.Upmann that I bought in the States. I detected several flavors, molasses, leather, etc... That I've never detected before from previously smoked cigars out of the same box. I was sad (boo hoo) when that smoke came to an end.

Now H. Upmann Java wrapper is one of my favorite summertime smokes, especially if I lite it up just after a light rain, or on a mildly humid day/evening.

I like fuller bodied, stronger smokes, as the weather cools and the humidity drops. JMO.

pacman357
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 9:59:00 AM
ianmac, I wasn't chastising you for not searching on the topic, my intent was that you look for the other thread(s) to get more information. Just trying to help you get the answers more quickly.
pgje51
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 11:52:00 AM

What Dave said in #4 mirrors my experience. When the setting supports

maximum concentration, my smoking experience is very different and

I am able to discern what the stick has to offer much better and in more

detail.

Let us know how it goes for you.

sw48362
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 12:04:00 PM
Johnfs,

Progresso chunky soup. LOL!

andytv
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 1:01:00 PM
I taste these sorts of things.......I don't make them up.

I think it is a matter of:

1) Having the sensitivity of palatte (physically born with it) to detect flavor notes.

2) Having the mental ability to associate these subtle notes with other things you have tasted or smelled.

3) Being able to concentrate on the flavor.....this means having a clean palatte, being distraction free, being out of the wind, etc.

I have had this conversation with an esteemed member of these boards who is of the opinion that one must be specifically trained to recognize subtle flavors in wine, in food, in cigars, etc.

I disagree.......it is simply a comparative process......I have eaten raisins, I have smelled graphite pencil lead, I have tasted toffee............I have no problem identifying flavor notes in cigars based on these sensory records in my memory bank.

Now......if I smoke a cigar while mowing the grass or sitting in a bar, they typically fall into "good" or "bad".

The best cigars are those I smoke all alone in the dark on my back porch.........concentrating on the cigar.

Ram27
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 1:56:00 PM
^ The best cigars are those I smoke all alone in the dark on my back porch.........concentrating on the cigar.

=======================================================

Or taking a " P" behind someone's garage ! ! ROFL

Sorry Andy, couldn't resit ! !

I just enjoy the cigar & flavor , what ever it may be.

Sardious
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 2:33:00 PM
I agree with what andy said accept on his first point about being born with it. When I first started in cigars I did not know how to seperate the flavors, over time I just was able to do it more and more. Sometimes when new it is all a rush of flavors that you like or not, but as you go you start to notice why you like it then you start ti get specifics as your palette gets more experience with it. I drink lots of teas I have taste little nuances in green teas from various farms. Even on Computer games it started with "like or do not like" then now I can say what I like and talk about visual and gameply styles required and things like that.
ianmac864
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 3:06:00 PM
I know you were helping me, pac...I simply didn't want you to think I was a total idiot. On the contrary...I appreciate your help, as well as everyone else. Thank you again.

I do think that it could certainly be an individual ability, as well as a learned talent, or, as andy said, sometimes you just have the knack for that kind of thing. In any case, I do know what I like and dislike in cigars, and that is the whole reason for our discussions here, yes?

Once again, I enjoyed everyone's responses! Thank you for the help, all of you.

fishinguitarman
Wednesday, September 27, 2006 5:29:00 PM
I agree with Sardious. Not too long ago, I didn't know cigars even had different flavors. But the more I smoke, the more I begin to recognize the difference in wrappers, spices etc. I already have several favorites as well as some I probably won't try again. Still learning, but it's a fun process!
Slimboli
Thursday, September 28, 2006 5:05:00 AM
ianmac864 --- professional taste testers have to be trained. I once worked for the National Food Processor's Association, and they had a Sensory Department that had trained taste testers on staff to paying people 'off the street' to come in and taste the 'new' products that companies wanted to start marketing ... but the folks that weren't regular employees had to first agree to a training session.

They were given 'control samples' to train their tastebuds to recognize the different subtile flavors in food products. They had to taste everything from cardboard samples, to leather, metal, grass, rancid etc. Some of these were extracts in liquid form ... to actually chewing on a piece of cardboard (for example) to see what it tasted like.

The big joke around there at the time was ... if someone said the product they were testing tasted like sh*t ...

... we would ask them how they knew that ... LOL!

Why are cigars described with adjectives like "pepper", "citrus", "earth", etc.

The reason is simple,­ people use food terms and aromas to describe cigars because that is how we have learned to express the sensations on our palates. It is the flavors that we have had in our mouths in the past that serve as our frame of reference and provide the best way for an individual to verbally express the sensation they are experiencing from a cigar.

Does that mean everyone eats dirt, flint, or leather? No, but most of us have had those flavors in our mouths or have smelled them in our lifetimes. Remember that scent and flavor are two intertwined by our sense. These non-tobacco terms are use to provide a common reference for all of us.

As for your not tasting any of these notes is not surprising, because many people do not. Remember that your sense of taste and smell may not be the same as the next persons.

Some people simply have more acute palates than others and can identify individual flavors better than their peers. People's sense of smell and taste vary just as greatly as do people's eyesight, threshold for pain, or ability to hear.

Most of us are within the same relative range palate-wise, but there are some with a very acute sense of taste and smell while there are others that have very dull palates. All that is important is for you to determine if you enjoy the flavor of what you are smoking regardless of what it may taste like to others.

andytv
Thursday, September 28, 2006 12:02:00 PM
troo dat, boo^
cigar breath
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:13:00 PM
i am new to habanos but the two different ones i have smoked had a distinct zing or twang like it had a bit of a spark to it. its not a flavor but more a sensation.???
Sardious
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:22:00 PM
Cigar breath you think those gave a zing of feeling go for some good sun grown nicaraguan love, that'll zinga lifta ya and plant you on your butt and taste great while doing so
cigar breath
Thursday, September 28, 2006 2:25:00 PM
sard. name names.
ianmac864
Thursday, September 28, 2006 8:46:00 PM
Slimboli,

A very nice response. Thank you for the information; I concur with your assessment of people being able to recognize traits, smells, sensations, etc. from past exposures. I know that I have experienced certain situations where something similar has occured. So far for me, with the cigars, no dice. However, it is like you and everyone has said, what really matters is that you take a simple and pure enjoyment from what you like to smoke. That is just part of what makes our little hobby so much fun!

Thank you again for your great response. I enjoyed it!