Opux x never got anything crazy like a 96 rating from cigar aficianado, and for $10 a stick they are good. People overbid cause they are rare. I do not know if that = overhype. I think they smoke and taste like a good 10-12 dollar stick and earn the 89-91 rating.
For me the most over rated were punch cubans. I hear so many things about how GREAT they were and then 5-6 later even one being aged a few years in the humi, yuck. I have only had 4 cohiba cubans while they did not live up to the hype they were pretty good they were overhyped but not by too much.
Some Gurkha and Greycliff were way overpriced but while I can find a $10 at a B&M that is better or as good as some of their $24 to $30 dollar sticks still people were not telling me they were the greatest cigars ever.
What about puros indios. I'll admit I like them but a 91-92 rating....probably not that good in my opinion but worth the cheap price at any B&M