ddsmokin
Monday, October 9, 2006 6:18:00 AM
The Duke is right857343.jpg
rod_townsend
Monday, October 9, 2006 8:13:00 AM
Si ! Muy mucho!!!!!
Dr Pepperhill
Monday, October 9, 2006 9:01:00 AM
It's simple. If you own a business in an area with a big hispanic or asian population, and you want their business, you're going to need to be able to communicate with them. If, on the other hand, you don't care about their business, then you don't provide any translation services, and give your competitor the green light for that segment of the local population's business.
pacman357
Monday, October 9, 2006 9:31:00 AM
I heard that if you press the button for Spanish, Immigration comes looking for you.
Dr Pepperhill
Monday, October 9, 2006 9:40:00 AM
And another thing, I like the Duke ... grew up with him. But that flag behind him means something. It stands for FREEDOM. As long as I follow the laws of the land, it's really none of anyone's business how I dress, what language I speak, what god I worship, what newspaper I read, or what political party I'm registered with.

What's with all this "speak THIS language!", "marry THAT person," crap lately. This is America, land of the free. The Duke respected freedom, his wife was from Peru & spoke Spanish, and someone is defiling his memory by using his image for low-level propaganda. If others don't break the law, and you don't like what they do, tough! This is America (code for MYOB). Any questions? Now go enjoy your blow up Mattie B doll in private, just don't tell me anything about it.

Bluedevil
Monday, October 9, 2006 9:59:00 AM
agree
Gene363
Monday, October 9, 2006 5:10:00 PM
It is easy to do both, our local utility defaults to English, after a greeting in English, there is a short sentence in Spanish asking you to press 1 for Spanish.
mattmelcher
Monday, October 9, 2006 5:37:00 PM
hmm...

Considering all 3 of his wives we're hispanic I think he wouldn't have any problem with it...I think he must have had a thing for those brown skinned women.

Sardious
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 6:47:00 AM
"As long as I follow the laws of the land, it's really none of anyone's business how I dress, what language I speak, what god I worship, what newspaper I read, or what political party I'm registered with."

On free commercial business it is the business of the owner, when we do not have enough teachers to tech right cause so many are forced to teach seperate classes in seperate langues and cut teaching time in half when your "law" calls English the national language. Also if you live in parts of like arizona, Utah, southern california and you can not work with an english company cause so many of the base employees refuse to speack the official languages that the law states is the countries language.....that is where the problem is. So putting the Flag of a country who law states that it's official language is English and then having to ask why they have to press buttons to get the language of the land seems a little wierd.

I never called my friend in Lancaster and had to choose 1 for english or else they'd default to Pensalvania dutch.

Charlie
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 7:02:00 AM
I agree

Charlie

vfrtwice
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 9:11:00 AM
agreed!

"land of the free" does not mean "land of the lets try to accomodate everyone"

there had to be standards???

america can be an umbrella of freedom but it cannot be MEXICO, JAPAN, CHINA.BRAZIL..ECT. Isnt that what the south tried to do a few hundred years back???

America is america..yes..the land of the free..but not without standards!!!

ok..feel free to ramble on !

v

Dr Pepperhill
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 10:08:00 AM
Kinda hard to debate the topic when it's unclear what the topic is. If it's about only speaking English in the US, well that's a crock. America is a country of immigrants and has never, nor will it ever be "English" only. If the topic is about immigration, maybe we should change immigration law to keep up with changing demographics; DIFFERENT TOPIC. If the topic is about school literacy, my kid goes to a public school with kids from other countries, and I see no problem with their English curriculum. In fact, public school students are required by law in my state to take a foreign language, such as spanish, French, Chinese, etc., in order to graduate; DIFFERENT TOPIC.

But if the topic is about what language one's answering machine message has to be in, private or commercial, that's a violation of the 1st amendment. This is America damnit, and I can speak whatever language I'm capable of.

Post #9: "Also if you live in parts of like arizona, Utah, southern california and you can not work with an english company cause so many of the base employees refuse to speack the official languages." The way this is written, it sounds as if companies from the United Kingdom have all these factories in the southwest. I thought we ran those pasty bastards out back in 1783. America is not an English colony by god, it's sovereign America, land of the free!!

Post #11: "america can be an umbrella of freedom but it cannot be MEXICO, JAPAN, CHINA.BRAZIL..ECT. Isnt that what the south tried to do a few hundred years back???" This passage is even more ambiguous. America tried to be Mexico, Japan, China & Brazil back in 1806? You referring to when European immigrants from Germany & Ireland who pushed west of the Appalachias to settle the areas around the Ohio & Mississippi rivers? Well there was a lot of anti-German & anti-Irish sentiment back in those days too from the English majority. I happen to come from German/Irish European stock, and I say if you don't like it, go back to England.

BigStoney
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 3:21:00 PM
Speak whatever language you want, but you should be prepared to speak english to accomplish anythhing!!!!!!
Dr Pepperhill
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 3:37:00 PM
Hell yea, one should speak whatever language is spoken where they live, that's just common sense. I can see passing some common sense laws, like not driving drunk, not having sex with minors, etc. But others, like "Thous Shalt: only speak language X, only worship god X!" etc., translates into too much government control in areas that are simply none of their concern.

I have more than a few acquaintances whose grandparents spoke very little to no English. It was fine back then. To all of a sudden make that somehow illegal is just unAmerican IMO.

In Europe, where so many nations are jammed packed next to one another, people are necessarily poly-lingual. More & more people here in the SF Bay Area are meet poly-lingual, which seems to require an intense intelligence to pull off. Demanding one language only is a cry for dumbing-down, not to mention unconstititional. It's another one of those symbolic laws, like flag protection laws, or the Cuban embargo, that accomplish nothing other than allowing a few self-inflated ignoramouses to feel superior, and at the expense of common sense. Personal preference and behavior is one thing, but to codify it into law should be a red flag to thinking people.

elp007
Tuesday, October 17, 2006 3:29:00 PM
I agree.