my favorite go to has been the same for about 6 months now...Joya de nicaragua 1970, Still too much niccotine kick but still just great even burn and awesome flavors. For a lighter flavored one I loved the La Veiha habana The fumas with the Corojo wrapper by Drew estate. Was given my first was AMAZED and it was so cheap. Of course Drew discontinues all LVH lines is what my local shop owner said. Punch has some flavor and is good and consistent, H. Uppman is lighter but good, great construction, I like puros indios too. Also good when you just want something. Too many, tha tis why I keep variety around, but to namejust my top 2 go to I'll stick with Hoya de nicaragua, and....ummm....puros indios.
For reals though, the key to finding your favorite go to cigar is to bid on samplers start getting just 2 ro 5 of just lots of quality random stuff, macanudo, perdomo, CAO, 5 vegs, Gurka, hoyo de monterey, just whatever. start going through and after a while you will start tending to go to one style or even one certain cigar. It may not be your favorite but it seems like a good anytime stick for you every time you go to the humidor.