deadeyedick
Monday, October 30, 2006 8:32:00 AM

I just tried my 1st Partagas SD #3 EL from the ‘06 release. This one had a good, rich and spicy flavor profile which was surprising for such a young EL. Very enjoyable even though this cigar was only boxed in August.

This got me thinking about my experiences with other EL releases in general.

I have had the opportunity to try a few of almost every EL ever produced since their inseption back in 2000. While I know that most EL are made for the longer-term, I have not enjoyed many of these nearly as much as the premium prices should suggest. I still have boxes of the original releases of the Partagas Piramides and Monte Robusto, as an example, that after over 5 years are still far too harsh and tannic to be ready for full enjoyment. These may take another 5 years or longer to show their best attributes. Others I have tried just do not show the potential to ever develope into a superior cigar.

With a few notable exceptions, such as, Partagas SD #3 ‘02, RyJ Hermosos #1 ‘03, Cohiba DC ‘03 and Monte D ‘05, (and a few others) many have not lived up to the hype and the additional cost.

For pure enjoyment I find that the natural wrapper on the regular lines have much more to offer OTT and age into wonderful smokes in just a few years and at sometimes 1/2 the cost of similar EL versions. Anybody else care to add their experiences?

DED

Buckwheat
Monday, October 30, 2006 8:59:00 AM
Dead you're not the only one who has this opinion. Some of the hype on most of these is just that, hype.
RocketBoy
Monday, October 30, 2006 10:16:00 AM
Although I am fairly new to cigars and cuban cigars in particular, I share your opinion on the Monte "D". I find them very enjoyable right now, and feel that they will only get better with time. I do have a couple of boxes of Cohiba Sublimes that I only intend to smoke twice a year - one on the anniversary of my engagement, and the other on my wedding anniversary. I think it will be fun to see how they are aging from year to year. I smoked the first two earlier this month on my honeymoon, and although they were enjoyable, I know that they will need more time to reach their peak. In the meantime I find a PSP2 or and Edmundo much more budget friendly, not to mention smokeable. I have some PLPC's that are not living up to their rep, but I think mine are a little too new. I'm going to let them nap for a few more months to see if they can redeem themselves.

Now that you have me thinking about it, I am running low on the "D"'s .....

deadeyedick
Tuesday, October 31, 2006 6:43:00 AM
Any other views?

DED

johnfs
Tuesday, October 31, 2006 6:57:00 AM
El are good, but I'd rather buy aged cigars, than new ELs made with aged leaf.

J

bassdude
Tuesday, October 31, 2006 7:06:00 AM
I have yet to try the 06s or 05s.

I agree with you on the Cohiba DC - excellent. Another fave was the HdM pyramide and the first release PSDs.

The RyJs were just OK.

xibbumbero
Tuesday, October 31, 2006 7:20:00 AM
DED,I think that you are prolly right.

IMO,I think it still may be too early to tell. If after, say 10 years, they still aren't anything special then we got took. X

MACS
Tuesday, October 31, 2006 11:25:00 AM
Well, none of them have really hopped out and kicked me in the jimmy...

But I DAMN sure like the Montecristo C's from '03.

Still have a box of Monte D's from '05 resting quietly. I torched/gifted all the smokes from the other box.

I really liked the Party SD #2 as well.

sli38
Friday, November 3, 2006 8:27:00 PM
Been there, done that, and don't think I'll take the plunge anymore. Too many excellent smokes out there for a lot less. The older I get the less I care about novelties like EL's and regional releases.
sli38
Saturday, November 4, 2006 10:50:00 AM
I posted that reply last night and what did

I find my self doing this morning? I was seriously contemplating pulling the trigger on a box of the PL lonsdale ER's......

deadeyedick
Saturday, November 4, 2006 2:35:00 PM
The PL Lonsdales (regional release) have some of that classic PLPC profile but way too soon to enjoy yet IMO.

DED