Czechmate0
Thursday, November 16, 2006 2:36:00 PM
Recently I posted regarding large lots for Specials and indicating there was a glitch in the system because bids placed after mine and many others were less than ours. Apparently according to SteveR there is no glitch in the system it is just how it works if you use the autobid feature. I was not aware of this and I don't believe many of you are either. I personally do not agree with such a policy but this is their site and have the right to administer how they see fit. Below is SteveR's response and explanation so you may be aware of how the autobid feature works on this site.

Hello Kevin,

There is no glitch; this is the same system that has been in place for the past 6 years. Date/time doesn't necessarily take priority. Autobidders take priority at winning the lot. Those without autobid are taking a higher risk of losing the lot.

When the first bid comes in at the higher price (in this case $42.99) to knock out the lowest non-autobid bid, the minimum bid increases to the next increment (in this case to $42.99). As a result all autobidders get moved in unison up to the minimum bid to ensure they will not lose the lot. If you're willing to take the "risk" of placing a non-autobid bid, you too could have a chance of getting it at a lower price, (in this case $39.99).

Autobid is a surefire way to ensure that you win the auction, as long as the winning bid price does not go above your set maximum bid. The autobid feature prioritizes your bid in this fashion. This is a service provided to you to ensure that you win the product without having to baby-sit your bid.

Those taking the higher risk (of not using autobid) get a potentially higher reward if they hang on to win.

I apologize for the confusion.

Best Regards,

Steve

CigarBid

Steve,

I appreciate your response. However, I don't necessarily agree with how you administer the bidding and I am not the only one confused. Any other type of auction site using a similar feature as your autobid gives priority to the time and amount bid. I have bid on quite a number of lots over the years and have never noticed such a policy before on CBid until just recently with your large lot Specials. I have been told by your own Customer Service Staff this was a glitch in the system and it has been corrected in the past manually.

I have reviewed your policies about bidding and nowhere did I find it indicated that using the autobid feature comes with a cost attached to it (losing to a lower bid placed after your initial bid as a convenience of using autobid). You should make this policy of CBid much clearer to the individuals bidding, because as it stands it is very deceptive the way CBid administers the bidding in relation to the autobid feature. Nobody else I am aware of on the boards is aware of this policy, and apparently neither was your CS Staff.

Cbid has the right to administer their business as they see fit, however I do not agree with this policy. Again I believe you (CBid) should communicate this policy to your members because as it stands it is in my opinion very deceptive. It is just the right thing to do in making it clear to individuals using the autobid feature they may be charged more to do so.

Best Regards,

Kevin

andytv
Thursday, November 16, 2006 2:38:00 PM
dude
edsbar60
Thursday, November 16, 2006 2:54:00 PM
Uhhh...this shouldn't be here. This is between you and SteveR.

I and most everyone here fully understand the policy. And furthermore, we fully appreciate that CI/CBID offers an auction site to allow some of us average Joes the ability to buy cigars we normally couldn't afford every week.

Their auction site rules are set to their perogative(sp) and I will comply even if they say only Arizonans win on Tuesdays. Cmon, Steve...PLEEEZE!

Thanks SteveR for this great site and forum.

jackconrad
Thursday, November 16, 2006 3:18:00 PM
I have boughtat least 500 lots here and never had a problem except for my own mistakes. Even then i called right away and they were corrected.
SteveR@CigarBid
Thursday, November 16, 2006 3:37:00 PM
I guess this keeps me from having to reply to the other thread for now. Thanks.

The autobid function works perfectly, as does the system. It is the same system we've been using for the past 6 years. I am sorry that you'd don't agree with it. Certainly we will do our best to assist you and anybody else that has a question or is confused.

Hopefully all the other guys won't start posting the emails that I've sent to them. Especially you Andy. Now that, could be bad!

johniniowa
Thursday, November 16, 2006 3:38:00 PM
I appreciate you sharing the email. I did notice a difference on my last specials bid. Without the blatant boot licking, I think we all appreciate the deals we get here, but its always nice to know the rules, since they are different from other "dutch" auctions.
andytv
Thursday, November 16, 2006 4:29:00 PM
From: SteveR@Cbid

To: [email protected]

Hey andytv,

You are right about my momma.....when she lays around the house, she lays "AROUND" the house.

(sorry for publishing that private email Steve)

edsbar60
Thursday, November 16, 2006 5:31:00 PM
Somebody help me get that boot off my tongue....

whatever.

Czechmate0
Thursday, November 16, 2006 5:49:00 PM
SteveR,

Did not realize it was meant to be a private email, but more an informational email. Just posted it for informational purposes for other bidders who may not have been aware. Appears this may have been done in error, therefore I apoligize. Furthermore, I did not mean to get others on the board upset, and if I did, Sorry.

I surrender, even though I don't agree I will not say another word about the issue, as it is CBid policy. And yes I enjoy also bidding the last few years, so just pass the KoolAid.

andytv
Thursday, November 16, 2006 5:56:00 PM
dude
Slowburning
Thursday, November 16, 2006 6:59:00 PM
Steve,

I got your email.

I need cigars.

Let's talk.

nine999
Thursday, November 16, 2006 8:59:00 PM
i feel i need to add my opinion. the BIGGEST glitch with the system here at cbid is when i place a bid no matter how low i bid, a lot of people still have the ability to outbid me.

i would really appreciate if stever could do something about that.

a good example:

i placed a bid once for a 5er of gurkha gran envoy's for 3$, beating the previous 1$. shortly after, someone came by and outbid me.

this needs to be fixed right away!

nine

BikerBob1961
Thursday, November 16, 2006 9:19:00 PM
Thanks for the info was not aware of that and have not noticed it myself. I have bidded on muti-items and unless my bids is the same amount as the ones using auto-bid I,before,have not noticed thier amouth going up.
BikerBob1961
Thursday, November 16, 2006 9:29:00 PM
Sorry but had to point out an example of why I am confused on this auction 397904 a bid was placed for $3 and took one away from an non-auto-bidder but the auto-bidder did not change in the amount.
phurley66
Friday, November 17, 2006 2:54:00 AM
I like the peace of mind of autobid and don't care if it could potentially cost me an extra $2 in the end. Call it cigar purchase insurance. I love this place and I'm much more concerned with how to sell the wife on yet another coolerdor.
IUROX
Friday, November 17, 2006 3:34:00 AM
Go buy to your local and spend MSRP! This subject has grown quite tiresome.If 40-70% off retail is not good enough,GO LOCAL!
engletl
Friday, November 17, 2006 3:36:00 AM
and like I have said continually, some people prefer to not use the autobid and just bid higher than the minimum on the special lots. And now you know why.
tank71663
Friday, November 17, 2006 7:50:00 AM
Not that I think this makes it MUCH clearer, but this seems to semi-explain the Glitch everyone is talking about....I think...

This comes directly off C-Bids site..

"Rules for Winning Bid Determination"

1.An auto-bidder with a higher maximum bid takes top priority over other bidders at the same bid price.

2.An earlier bid will beat a later bid of the same price only if Rule 1 does not apply.

I admit I've had a hard time following this one, mainly because I dont think I've ever had ANY problems with the site or C-Bid/CI...

Tank

porschesales225
Friday, November 17, 2006 7:53:00 AM
i dont get it if im willing to pay UPto a certain amount for something then i was willing to pay up to that amount. the day autobid goes over my preset amount me and a nice customer service rep will be on the phone talking it out until then....