What cigar(s) and what quantity did you purchase and later tossed because they were so bad? I am talking you couldn't give them away because you would have felt too guilty.
Mine: 4 cigars of 5 pack: Maya Reserve Torpedo and Te-Amo Which are now serving as fertilizer for my plants in the back yard

mine are a box of thomas hinds something. i would try one every few months for a while. i never made it past about 10 puffs. the box has been sitting on a shelf in my garage for about a year. maybe someday they will have aged enough.

DARK SHARKS

A bundle of Tamborils = last years compost.

Montague natural something or other. Bid on them to justify shipping costs on a small lot that I really wanted way back when. They have absolutely no flavor whatsoever. I understood quickly why I won at such a low bid. I keep them to give out to mooching friends.

DARK SHARKS

DARK SHARKS....PU. X

Got some Island Collection flavored cigars and some Bucaneer Rum Runners or something like that (not to be confused with Bucaneros). Blech!

Thomas Hines were horrible and were given to one of my smarta-- neighbors who thinks himself a great cigar expert and loved the damn things!!!

Charlie

Charlie ... that makes me wonder if my neighbor and your neighbor are related ... by any chance, does your neighbor also like wine that comes in a box ???

Hoya duh Nicaragua Consuls...
Some 3 or 4 5-packs of little short shoddly constructed, no label mini-dog rockets
...maybe more, but I've undergone extensive memory blocking techniques to remove those experiences...

I bought a five-pack of Reyes & Benicio a while back, and after trying one and then another, just to make sure, I jettisoned the other three. Not bad flavor, just absolutely no flavor whatsoever. Mild would be garish overstatement. It was actually hard to tell if the cigar was lit, despite blowing out lots of smoke (kind of like the lights were on but no one was home 🙂 ).

I got a dark shark in a sampler. Tossed it after 5 or 6 puffs. Threw most of a box of thomas hinds 'cause they were Full Of Beetles! Never again.

Riatta's.......it was like smoking burnt leather and horse.....how shall I say it?.....butt. I couldn't even bring myself to give them away. It's difficult to even think about the experience. I have to go brush my teeth.

Bad Frogs--haven't tossed 'em yet. You pay for shipping...and they're on the way

Two bundles of Rosa Cubas. Didn't get a chance to see if they tasted good, everyone of them was plugged!

Fuego Del Rey.....one puff...tossed

Lots, most purchased right here. Dark Sharks, Diesels, Havana Sunrise Maria Mancini EMS. All part of the cost of learning what cigars I like.

Jazzman,To get rid of em you're going to have to pay shipping and bribe the guy to take em off your hands,LOL. X

Domestic Sancho Panza Valiente.The most vile cigar I have ever smoked,Mettalic,putrid almost indescribable flavor.I kept trying hoping it would turn around and smoked about an inch of it.Fuggit fine for throwing a burning object out of my truck or no fine I pitched the thing to the curb as I didn't even want it stinking up my trucks ashtray.Too bad too as I had heard nothing but good things about this brand and I really wanted to like them because of the price,but I got to tell ya it was more than a week before I got even partial function of my taste buds back.I still pick them up every now and again as bonus sticks in trades and such but I just can't bring myself to smoke one.