tdepeter
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 8:48:00 AM
Got out Foxed!899813.jpg
MACS
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 12:44:00 PM
Holy Crap!

Is this a real shot? That would appear to be a golden eagle. Are they actualy big and bad enough to grab onto a fox, or is this some kinda photoshop deal?

MACS
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 12:51:00 PM
Upon further review... look at the front paws. Definitely photoshopped.

And this is an excerpt, cut and pasted from Snopes:

How a bald eagle could manage to take off carrying a 13-pound animal defies what is known about eagles; they don't have that kind of lift power. That the fierce predator couldn't successfully carry its load away fits what we know of these birds: they're not built to make off with small dogs even if one of them is ambitious enough to try it. (The dog's owner credits his pet's escape to the dachshund's having bitten the eagle, but considering that the talon wounds were in the abducted pooch's hindquarters, the dog wouldn't have had a chance to turn on its captor. It fell because the eagle dropped it, not because it attacked its attacker.)

So where are we with this tale? We have an eagle that grabbed a small dog and apparently got it up into the air to about the height of a tree before losing it. That the bird tried and succeeded even this much is phenomenal, but it's still nowhere close to being the effortless "flight into the sunset bearing its prey in its claws" of legend.

We're right back to where we started: Eagles do not swoop down and carry off small dogs as an ordinary matter of course. Some may attack a dog on the ground, and some may even get it temporarily airborne, but they do not ultimately succeed in making off with it.

errasa
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 1:04:00 PM
Weeellllllll, hang on a minute. I am an eye witness to a scene, or moreover, the aftermath of a scene just like this. I was 14 or 15, up north by Ft. Bragg (California), soaking my feet in the Noyo River and chasing mud puppies when I came across an eagle with a small fox in a short redwood chompin' away and havin' a great old time. It was the first time I can remember feeling a true sense of awe about anything.
pacman357
Tuesday, November 21, 2006 1:13:00 PM
I wouldn't give eagles a chance. Lovely birds, and we have some near our home, which I appreciate. However, even though my wife's rabbits are quite large, when I built a pen for them to run in the yard a little bit, I put a roof on it, and the missus covers it when they are in it, too. I have no trouble believing an eagle could pick up a small dog or a fat rabbit. I also know that before the neighbor's dog (a little guy)died, they kept a close eye on the skies when taking him outside.
vasmooth
Wednesday, November 22, 2006 10:07:00 AM
Golden Eagles often have a division of labour while hunting: one partner drives the prey to its waiting partner. They have very good eyesight and can spot prey from a long distance. The talons are used for killing and carrying the prey, the beak is used only for eating. The talons of a Golden Eagle are thought to be more powerful than the hand and arm strength of any human being. Their prey includes marmots, hares and mice, and sometimes birds, martens, foxes and young deer. Large mammals like chamois or adult deer can only be taken if they are wounded or sick.

this is most like rill if not it could be

Nutttttttttty
Wednesday, November 22, 2006 11:22:00 AM
They certainly can kill larger animals such as dogs. I have seen them kill lambs and go down and grab pretty damn big fish and carry them out of the water.

But I don't think the eagle was trying to carry the fox away or even eat the fox. I'm pretty sure he just wanted to scare the crap out of it and get it away from that carcass.

Very Cool Pic not sure why you think it is photoshopped.

MACS
Wednesday, November 22, 2006 12:51:00 PM
First of all, look at the front paws on the fox. They're not there.

Second, research on eagles shows that about 15 pounds is all the weight they can fly with.

My cat weighs 12 pounds. That fox is over 30 pounds and it is physiologically impossible for that bird to FLY with 30 pounds in it's talons.

That's why.

03screw
Thursday, November 23, 2006 1:52:00 PM
Here's my theory..

The fox's paws are in the snow so you can't see all of them. I think the eagle just wanted to strike the fox and not carry it away. It seems like the strike already took place and the fox is responding to the strike and the eagle is flying away. The fluff of the snow is probally from the eagle taking off and it's wings making contact with the ground.

dapperdan
Thursday, November 23, 2006 2:15:00 PM
Cool picture but my bet it's not real.
jbu
  • jbu
  • Herf-A-Holic
Thursday, November 23, 2006 2:19:00 PM
macs,

The justification is sillier than the pic.

There is a good meal there in the snow for all three of them. Why would they risk life and limb trying to eat other?

Unless it’s analogous to an adroomi story, where the girls have to resort to eating each other, disregarding the corpse in the room.

dapperdan
Thursday, November 23, 2006 2:36:00 PM
Exactly jbu. Animals first and foremost is self preservation. A fox could easily injure the eagle so he could no longer hunt or even fly. If the eagle was to swoop down it would be from a height to be safe and to scare off the fox so he could eat the carcass himself. Fake,but cool picture.