It depends on how much crap you want to carry around in your pockets. A punch does a nice job, but is worthless on a torpedo or figurado.
I haven't used a punch in ages.
The option I like best now is a swiss army knife cigar cutter. I am resigned to carry a pocket knife anyways, so it is an excellent cutter which takes no additional pocket space.
For a while, I just used the sharp blade of a pocketknife to score a circular cut in the cap.
I also like the idea of learning how to remove the cap with your teeth or fingernail; I think that will be my winter project