315press
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 6:57:00 PM
I used to never use anything but a cutter. I thought the puch would restrice too much of the smoke. Tried a punch a year or so ago, never went back to the cutter. Except obviously when i have a torp or beli.
GU
  • GU
  • Connoisseur
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 7:06:00 PM
I couldn't understand how the little punch hole could do the job of the cutter.

Since I won a Xicar punch cutter here, I'm a convert.

Like they say, "Once you try black, you never go back."

pacman357
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 7:09:00 PM
Except where the shape makes the cutter the only sensible option, I prefer a punch. That is, when a punch will do the job (some larger cigars I will make 2 or 3 holes). The punch is just a neater way to cut, and if the cigar isn't packed too tightly, it's less likely to come apart at the head. For those cigars where I can't get a good draw from a punched hole or three (I test draw before lighting), I'll then switch to a cutter and clip it.
les017
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 7:54:00 PM
ditto pacman - plus the punch hangs from my keychain so i never have to worry about making sure I have it
bsevern
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 8:17:00 PM
Been using a punch for ten years, I like them, but their not for all smokes.

I think Pacmans post is right on. Although I've never had to punch three holes in one smoke, what the heck are ya smoking up there Pacman?

nine999
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 9:34:00 PM
punch...even on torps.

nine

bsevern
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 9:51:00 PM
^^^ now that might get tricky - lol
pacman357
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 11:05:00 PM
I think most cigars with a normal shape and a ring of 60 or better can withstand three punches. Inmensos, for sure, can take multiples punches. You just offset them a bit, not hitting the center. Helps if the cap cooperates. Usually I'll try one, test draw, punch again if I can/need to, etc. I've also found that in a pinch, although I usually have plenty of punches and cutters around, the bottom half of a metal ballpoint pen can work as a punch if needed.
happy1
Thursday, November 30, 2006 3:03:00 AM
i prefer to punch, less lose tobacco to get in your mouth,less likely to unravel your cap,just hope you get good sticks without plugs or are wrapped to tight
PDQ
  • PDQ
  • Connoisseur
Thursday, November 30, 2006 3:23:00 AM
Like Pacman 357 said, I use a punch except on Torpedos, which I cut. My Colibri Oscar has 2 punch sizes.

My personal experience is that it is difficult to make a clean cut on the end of a round-headed cigar, without tearing the wrapper. Torpedos clip cleanly, though.

andytv
Thursday, November 30, 2006 3:29:00 AM
It depends on how much crap you want to carry around in your pockets. A punch does a nice job, but is worthless on a torpedo or figurado.

I haven't used a punch in ages.

The option I like best now is a swiss army knife cigar cutter. I am resigned to carry a pocket knife anyways, so it is an excellent cutter which takes no additional pocket space.

For a while, I just used the sharp blade of a pocketknife to score a circular cut in the cap.

I also like the idea of learning how to remove the cap with your teeth or fingernail; I think that will be my winter project

louiec
Thursday, November 30, 2006 3:56:00 AM
I prefer the punch. The best cutter though that gives you the best of both worlds is the V-Cut. I prefer this even to the punch. It cuts more of an area like the cutter for a good draw and also gives you the smooth edge that you get from the punch. Winner in my book.
andytv
Thursday, November 30, 2006 4:01:00 AM
^ I concur.........the v-cut works great, even on torpedos.

I guess my problem is that I don't like carrying stuff in my pockets.

mtstanger
Thursday, November 30, 2006 4:13:00 AM
Hey Lou! I'm with you on the v-cut. I tried some of the cheap plastic v-cutters and at first was disappointed in them. After getting some tips from some of the fine gents on this board, I learned that they actually do a nice job as long as the cigar is moistened and you "set" the blade into the cigar first, then quickly snap through - just like a guillotine cutter.
nine999
Thursday, November 30, 2006 6:06:00 AM

...hmmmm. not sold on this v cutter. i even tried using one to cut an "X" on a larger torp. whatever.

i'll stick to a punch. i got one for $2 here. a blue keychain. also have three or four more expensive ones. the cheap blue is my favorite. go figure.

but on torpedos, all you have to do is punch it on the side, about 1/2 inch from the tip of the head. then smoke it like a flute.

nine

Charlie
Thursday, November 30, 2006 6:37:00 AM
I own just about every cutter made, thanks to Slimboli for the Zino and the pailo, also I have two Xikars and an otter....and several non discript things.

Have tried punches and do not care for them at all, but if that floats your boat.."go with my blessing"..LOL

Charlie

rkdub
Thursday, November 30, 2006 7:06:00 AM
Utility knife blade!
teedubbya
Thursday, November 30, 2006 7:21:00 AM
Whaaaa I want a SAK but haven't found the right price

I used to punch, but went back to my Xikar. Punches seem to restrict and gather Vitamin N or tar I dunno.....

I'm trying to speak intelligently when I really shoulda just said I like the cutter better

MACS
Thursday, November 30, 2006 8:06:00 AM
I've used a punch. Liked it, used it once in awhile.

I've used a V-cutter (nice one, too... not a crappy plastic one). Liked it, used it a lot.

I've currently got a couple double bladed guillotine cutters (both thanks to slimboli) and I just pretty much stick to them now. A Palio and a Xikar Xi3.

I think I sent my V-cutter to tailgater?

Simbrock
Thursday, November 30, 2006 8:41:00 AM
Definitely prefer the punch. I like the concentration of the smoke. Some punches are too small however and require multiple punches - can result in messy cap if not sharp. Have only tried the Cat's Eye clip a couple of times at the store, but have enjoyed that also.