theo
  • theo
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Thursday, December 14, 2006 1:06:00 PM
My wife wants to know what her mom can get me for Christmas. Anyone have the Toscana Humidor? If so, is it good. Satisfied?

I think its popped up for bid on occassion. Its $100 on CI. Worth it?

les017
Thursday, December 14, 2006 2:03:00 PM
That is the one I have and it is quite nice. My wife bought me this and it is my first real humidor.

My observations - other than "damn it looks nice"

1) I doubt I would get one with a drawer again (amazing how much space you lose for the size of the humi)

2) No handle on the lid so the high gloss (and it IS high gloss) finish shows a lot of fingerprints.

3) The upper tray really only securely holds 1 layer of sticks and then you can't really grab the tray to remove it. I am modifying by adding 1 1/2" high cedar all around which will add about 50 to capacity.

4) Holds humidity great! I filled the rectangular humidifier with 65% beads and it sits at 63-66% no matter what is going on outside, and we have swung from 15% to 90% humidity in the last couple weeks.

5) Damn it looks nice!!

6) Get a bigger one

good luck

Evan

engletl
Thursday, December 14, 2006 3:20:00 PM
gotta agree with item 6 above...get something bigger.

Better yet get beads and a 120 quart cooler

Todd

les017
Thursday, December 14, 2006 3:35:00 PM
or do like I did.

Beads, 120 qt Tupper, 60 qt Tupper AND something to show off.

I use the Tuppers for "aging" and the 100 or so in the fancy unit are on deck for flame

FNA
  • FNA
  • Enthusiast
Saturday, December 16, 2006 5:51:00 AM
A coupla things:

First to les017 - the Toscana is a 'flat-top' right? Do you really think you can go up an inch and a half for effective storage? I doubt the lid in total is anymore than an inch and a half deep and there is the humidifier right in the center.

To me, that's one of the advantages of 'dome' tops - you can go up.

Depending on how many cigars you own or plan on owning, I also recommend a larger unit. Do you shop CBid because you want to get a good deal on one or two bundles? I doubt it.

100 count boxes are 100 count if you smoke nothing but robustos or coronas. The most mixed cigars I have in any 100 count flat top is around 70 and that box is 'chock full' of cigars.

The Toscana is a good size; I have alleged 100s that are smaller.

No handle on the lid doesn't seem much of an issue to me - I only grasp the lid at the corners to open it, so fingermarks are not a real problem. I find the lack of carrying handles to be more problematic.

I have to say that I like a display humidor, IOW, glass tops. If you will allow me, I will suggest a humidor to look at as an alternative (probably because I really want this style) for $140.

I own 23 humidors, from 5-10 cigar 'Executive' desktops thru 1,000 plus cabinets. Why so many? I didn't know where I was going with cigars and I ended up continuing to buy middling storage for each successive increase in my stock.

That's what you need to determine first - how many cigars are you going to be holding. If you end up buying as a collector...

Personal stock of cigars can build incredibly fast - four bundles would overfill a Toscana. Most humidors do not fit full boxes either well or at all.

My final suggestion - if you enjoy not only smoking but acquiring and owning cigars, if potentially you are going to own 500 or more smokes, go big right from the beginning - buy a cabinet.

If you end up with 500 smokes, you will need 5 (likely 6) Toscanas at $100@. Take that $600 and buy a 3000 count cabinet.

** edited by SteveR@CigarBid due to competitor references

Ram27
Saturday, December 16, 2006 6:37:00 AM
FNA, DO YOU PLAN TO living to 100 ????????

To smoke them all !!!!!!!!!!

Have fun !!!!!!!!

" OVER KILL "

theo
  • theo
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Monday, December 18, 2006 5:57:00 AM
Thanks guys! Good advice. I ended up telling her to get me a 150-stick box. It was on sale at another site. It looks exactly like the Toscana, but its bigger. Good call to go bigger. I am already closing in on capacity between what I have and a couple boxes I got for Hanukkah (Astral Talanga Valley robustos, which are surprisingly good). The humi looks so good, my wife is actually letting me keep in on the bar in the family room. Mighty nice of her.

Good point on the buy to smoke or buy to keep. I like to age 'em, so I will probably get a bigger cheaper humi to keep some boxes in.

This habit...uh, hobby, really eats the wallet, but its worth it!

Thanks again for the advice!

theo
  • theo
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Monday, December 18, 2006 6:38:00 AM
Oh, let me get an opinion here. Instructions that came with this humi said in all caps "NEVER WIPE THE INTERIOR OF THE HUMIDOR WITH WATER".

Hmmm...don't know the problem would be, except maybe damaging the joints or seals of the box. As long as you let it settle, shouldn't the wipe down end up in the same place as letting a glass of distilled water sit in there for a few days?

Anybody seen this warning before?

les017
Monday, December 18, 2006 9:10:00 PM
TO FNA - I hear ya, I haven't really measured it yet. And now that I think if it I would probably be "adding" about an inch over and above the existing tray. But still that would effectively "almost" triple the tray capacity. The humidifier in the lid has already been removed. Using beads in toothbrush travel tubes (2 of them at 65% works great).

But it seems the point is totally moot for me anyway. Just got an email from Watkins shipping stating that my "shipment will arrive 12/19/06 from xxxx". Well 12/19 is my birthday, and I called xxxx after not being able to get anything out of wifey. Turns out I have a Montegue Humi landing tomorrow!!!! Woo Hoo!!!

The wife's been trying to figure out what furniture to put in this one spot AND she always makes fun of me rooting thru my Tupperdors. So I guess she sloved both problems.

les017
Monday, December 18, 2006 9:11:00 PM
anyway, I guess the Toscana is gonna pro'ly turn into a lower moisture smoke-prep humi, or something.