A coupla things:
First to les017 - the Toscana is a 'flat-top' right? Do you really think you can go up an inch and a half for effective storage? I doubt the lid in total is anymore than an inch and a half deep and there is the humidifier right in the center.
To me, that's one of the advantages of 'dome' tops - you can go up.
Depending on how many cigars you own or plan on owning, I also recommend a larger unit. Do you shop CBid because you want to get a good deal on one or two bundles? I doubt it.
100 count boxes are 100 count if you smoke nothing but robustos or coronas. The most mixed cigars I have in any 100 count flat top is around 70 and that box is 'chock full' of cigars.
The Toscana is a good size; I have alleged 100s that are smaller.
No handle on the lid doesn't seem much of an issue to me - I only grasp the lid at the corners to open it, so fingermarks are not a real problem. I find the lack of carrying handles to be more problematic.
I have to say that I like a display humidor, IOW, glass tops. If you will allow me, I will suggest a humidor to look at as an alternative (probably because I really want this style) for $140.
I own 23 humidors, from 5-10 cigar 'Executive' desktops thru 1,000 plus cabinets. Why so many? I didn't know where I was going with cigars and I ended up continuing to buy middling storage for each successive increase in my stock.
That's what you need to determine first - how many cigars are you going to be holding. If you end up buying as a collector...
Personal stock of cigars can build incredibly fast - four bundles would overfill a Toscana. Most humidors do not fit full boxes either well or at all.
My final suggestion - if you enjoy not only smoking but acquiring and owning cigars, if potentially you are going to own 500 or more smokes, go big right from the beginning - buy a cabinet.
If you end up with 500 smokes, you will need 5 (likely 6) Toscanas at $100@. Take that $600 and buy a 3000 count cabinet.
** edited by SteveR@CigarBid due to competitor references