The cosmic joke is as follows: one is born, spends a lifetime gaining wisdom, them at the last moment, when you’ve figured out the whole game, are then snuffed out like a candle; as if you never did nor never had existed at all; forgotten entirely soon after the moment of your expiration. Some find the cosmic joke funny. Others don’t find it funny in the least, whereas substance dualists, who believe their spirit lives on after corporeal death, remain nonplused.
I happen to fall into the first category, that the cosmic joke is a humorous state of affairs, although I do not feel I hold any different ground than the latter two participants. Those who find the cosmic joke consternating just take life too seriously in my opinion; they expect some reward for having been born, and though I can understand the economic expectations they’ve worked so hard for etc., I cannot understand exactly the dividend they hope to be paid in the end. The lattermost, nonplused participants, represent to me a non-tragic comic figure, sincerely believing they’ll continue to live after death (a logical absurdity), yet even so, are above it all, happy in their delusion.
I’d like to talk about the three categories in a bit more detail, beginning with my own favorite, those who find the cosmic joke funny, and why. I find it funny because of the liberation such a view confers. The nihilism bequeathed by life’s lot is immensely entertaining. If nothing really matters in the end, as with a Sartrian existentialist, we are then set free; the dogs have been let out to play. Sartre himself saw this existential freedom as a sort of responsibility, but we hedonists see it as more of a get out of jail free card; we are free to enjoy life, with all its thrills and sick old ending, as one would viewing a movie from a theatre balcony: the seats are un-crowded and comfortable. Admitted, this all may not make much sense, but that’s part of the benefit of being amused over it all; sense can be so stressful and life diminishing. We cosmic joke appreciators are rational people: we accept the world on its own terms, allowing us to enjoy the hedonistic pleasures available and not sweat the inimportant stuff.
The middle category, those who do not see the cosmic joke as humorous, but rather as an insulting slap in the face, I do not look down on; as their justification is warranted by logic. After all, a person comes into life with trusting intentions, works hard, only to find their efforts dashed upon the cliffs of time like so many flecks of sea foam, and who is to say such a soul hasn’t a right to some disappointment, some anger at the powers that be? Only I differ from such complainers because there are no identifiable powers that be. To be mad about circumstances requires someone to blame, and perhaps such strivers should blame the most guilty party, their own selves. Is not their expectation of some reward for being born and for all their hard work a bit egoistic? Like ascetic Protestants who delay their gratifications for some ultimate reward, only to find, when the cerebral calculator tallies up the final bill, their revered meanings are just so much nihilistic desire; and they are therefore disappointed, nay, pissed-off at the possibility the hedonists are enjoying themselves. But just as not all people have a functioning liver, or good eyesight, so some do not have an easily activated sense of humor, and like natural animals, expect some amount of security and recompense for their plottings and hoardings.
The last category is the substance dualists. It is important to distinguish between the substance and property dualists. Substance dualists think that there are two essential substances that exist: body substances like meat and nerves, etc., and soul substances that are capable of living on beyond bodily expiration, possibly for eternity. Property dualists are a more pragmatic lot, seeing body & soul, as it were, as merely two properties of corporeal meat and nerves, and not separately each other. Thus the substance dualist sees body and mind as separate, mutually exclusive substances, whereas the property dualist sees mind as an emergent property of the animal body, and on par with it. In many ways I see substance dualists as the most fortunate of the bunch, as their egoism carries them soundly through this corporeal world, and moreover, provides them with an impetus sufficient to provide predicative motivations for an afterlife, which, whether they are ever realized or not, serve as additional fuel sources for the here and now. Unlike the embittered cosmic joke perceivers, substance dualists are left unburdened by negative predispositions about existence, and are free to proceed plotting their afterlife tactics, however preposterous and unfeasible such efforts might ultimately be in any real world.
This brings us back to my preferred category, those who accept the cosmic joke, but find it funny. Why would such a raw deal be funny, one might ask? Because it exists. Contemplating the futility of existence surely will rouse consternation in a thinking person, but this is unacceptable for many reasons. Because over contemplation about the ultimate futility of life causes unhealthy bodily reactions, like stress, anger, and a host of other outlooks that have been empirically shown to result in negative mental and physical outcomes. Because life is without reason and morally nihilistic, worrying about it in juxtapose to laughing along with it, presents a superior alternative on many fronts. Better health, more enjoyment, greater freedoms, deeper wisdom, and relative guiltlessness.
The substance dualist lives in a different psychological universe we don’t need to analyze too deeply; they expect to be paid richly for their larcenies of the present, and therefore have a lot at stake; which is to rationally be respected on its own logical merit.