I guess we'd need to know how long you've had some of these sticks in this environment. Were the dry ones dry before you got them? Have you verified that the humidity is fairly even throughout the humi?
I know you salt tested (twice) but if you had the baggie in the sun, as an extreme example, the readings would be quite high...meaning the actual humidty is lower.
I used to keep everything at less-than 65% and nothing ever got brittle in that "dry" environment. THAT is why I bring up your salt test conditions. Under 65% should take quite a while for things to get truly dry...if ever.