At one time, Peterson was a very bad cigar. One that nobody would smoke twice. This old blend can easily tarnish any new attempts at a winner. People remember...
Also, Peterson does not have the Ashton name anywhere on it. While those in the know realize who makes this cigar and where it comes from, first-timers do not. So, why wouldn't they spend $1-$2 more for an Ashton, falling victim to the brand name once again?
Lastly, Peterson is associated with pipes. Think about Pepsi, when they came out with Aquafina, you could not find the name Pepsi anywhere on the bottle. Cross-marketing is tricky.