While it is highly likely that cultural and political issues have played a role in the differences between Haiti and the Dominican Republic (which are both located on the Caribbean Island of Hispaniola) this issue of tobacco is primarily related to geography and ecology, primarily mountain ranges which influence precipitation. Also, Haiti over-exploited and degraded it's environmental resources during early European colonization to the point where the land was not able to recover. Below is an excerpt from Jared Diamond's book "Collapse":
"Why did the political, economic and ecological histories of these two countries the Dominican Republic and Haiti sharing the same island unfold so differently? Part of the answer involves environmental differences. Hispaniola’s rains come mainly from the east. Hence the Dominican (eastern) part of the island receives more rain and thus supports higher rates of plant growth.
Hispaniola’s highest mountains (over 10,000 feet high) are on the Dominican side and the rivers from those high mountains mainly flow eastwards into the Dominican side. The Dominican side has broad valleys, plains and plateaus and much thicker soils. In particular, the Cibao Valley in the north is one of the richest agricultural areas in the world. In contrast, the Haitian side is drier because of that barrier of high mountains blocking rains from the east.
Compared to the Dominican Republic - a higher percentage of Haitis area is mountainous. The area of flat land good for intensive agriculture is much smaller. There is more limestone terrain and the soils are thinner and less fertile and have a lower capacity for recovery.
Note the paradox. The Haitian side of the island was less well endowed environmentally but developed a rich agricultural economy before the Dominican side. The explanation of this paradox is that Haiti’s burst of agricultural wealth came at the expense of its environmental capital of forests and soils. This lesson in effect, that an impressive-looking bank account may conceal a negative cash flow. While those environmental differences did contribute to the different economic trajectories of the two countries a larger part of the explanation involved social and political differences — of which there were many that eventually penalized the Haitian economy relative to the Dominican economy. "