Arcanedice
Friday, February 9, 2007 1:16:00 AM
I didn’t do a search on this but I have a question. Has anyone ever noticed a correlation between ash color and density, and its effect on the flavor and harshness of the cigar they are smoking?

Just yesterday I was smoking a Sancho Panza Extra Fuerte Pamplona, and the ash about a third of the way in was almost pure white and extremely dense. Almost like a caked powered chemical compound. The taste was extremely bitter and harsh. Normally the ash is a blank and white pepper look to it.

I was looking at the ash of another cigar I was smoking today and noticed at times the ash took on a more yellow hue in places, though I could not tell a difference in flavor.

Grampa
Friday, February 9, 2007 5:07:00 AM
For the most part I believe that nice white ash is a sign of a good cigar. The darkness in the ash is said to be unburnt things in the cigar. I think that the whiter the ash the more pure the cigar has burned. For instance a Davidoff usually has a very white ash and is a for the most part a very smooth even burning smoke. Someone please correct me if I am wrong.

Gramps

thirdeagle
Friday, February 9, 2007 7:04:00 AM
Sounds like you need to read some Sherlock Holmes. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle made reference to the differences in cigar ash among types of tobacco in one of his short stories. Makes for interesting reading. . .not very applicable to your current dillema.

SteveR@CigarBid
Friday, February 9, 2007 8:03:00 AM
The color of the ash does not denote whether or not a cigar is good or of high quality. The color of the ash simple represents the amount of magnesium present in the soils of which the tobaccos were grown. Nicaraguan soils are high in magnesium. Therefore, Nicaraguan tobaccos create a bright white as when they born. Honduran and Cuban soils are very low in magnesium. Tobaccos grown in these soils create a dark grey or even black ash as they burn.
drnos
Friday, February 9, 2007 8:35:00 AM
Mmmmmm, magnesium
jpotts
Friday, February 9, 2007 1:03:00 PM
Ok, interesting. The ash on the Cuba Libre maduros (honduran) have a reddish ash on the wrapper, and a silvery ash for the filler. Does this mean that the maduro has more iron in the wrapper leaf, or is it purposely colored?

I asked this once, but I never really got a satisfatory answer.

Arcanedice
Friday, February 9, 2007 9:57:00 PM
I have always heard that Steve, but I was wondering if it can affect flavor when you see large variation in the ash color

Interesting jpotts, I am going to continue to watch as any information about cigars is fun. Though I really doubt that this will produce anything meaningful.

APhiO_Igor
Saturday, February 10, 2007 9:51:00 AM
First, I like the Cuba libre... that said, I have heard from several different persons that their maddies' wrappers are colored. Yes, they're legit maduro wrappers, but they color/dye them to make them even darker in color. Again, I don't know for sure, but have heard it from several different vendors... If it's true, though, the red ash from the wrapper may be from residual dyes. Just my 2cents...
Thunder.Gerbil
Saturday, February 10, 2007 10:23:00 AM
Wouldn't the dye come off and stain your fingers and lips?

Anyone happen to remember offhand what kind of ash HT leaves behind?

(actually, you could bust open the nub on an old one and see if there's an HT binder in there - the "tobacco masking tape" is pretty unmistakable)

jpotts
Saturday, February 10, 2007 2:46:00 PM
APhiO_Igor:

I "suspect" they're colored, but can't pin that down as all of the information I find comes in second-hand.

Remembering back to my high-school/college chemistry days, iron leaves a red deposit behind when burned. This would be an excellent Dr. Pepperhill question.

jpotts
Saturday, February 10, 2007 2:49:00 PM
Thunder.Gerbil:

The Cuba Libres I've got are robustos, and I don't leave them in my mouth long enough to produce a bleeding effect. Secondly, I've noticed that even conneticut shade wrappers and genuine maduros will stain fingers if the cigar is wet or moist.

I've heard the Fidalgo Negros have this effect, and they probably are dyed.

02
  • 02
  • Aficionado
Saturday, February 10, 2007 4:25:00 PM
I never let the ash detirmine whether I am enjoying a particular cigar. 🙂