Warning… boring scientific information below. It’s interesting to me though… but hey, I’m a scientist. 🙂
Ok, I was once skeptical about whether moisture can get through cellophane, so I looked up some technical info. This is under the assumption that cigars are wrapped in cellophane, I have no idea what happens for other plastics (shrink wrap, etc.).
Anyway, cellophane has a moisture (water vapor) permeability of over 0.000152 sq. cm. per second, whereas the permeabilities for nitrogen and oxygen are (both) 0.0000000000507 sq. cm. per second.
It seems then that cellophane is 3 MILLION times more permeable to water vapor than the two largest components of air (nitrogen and oxygen).
The data I found agrees well with other info I've found about cellophane being extremely non-permeable to air and yet permeable to water vapor.
So, now that I agree that cellophane permits moisture transfer I am still at odds about whether to keep it on or off for long term aging based on the fact that oxygen doesn't pass through the cellophane.
I have smoked a pipe for a while, so I know a bit about aging pipe tobacco. From what I’ve read, pipe tobacco ages by various bacteria consuming the sugars in the tobacco. Some of the bacteria are aerobic (need oxygen to live) and others are anaerobic (able to live without oxygen), so to properly age pipe tobacco the container needs to be air-tight so that the aerobic bacteria can die off and let the anaerobic bacteria keep up the aging process. Somehow that’s the ideal way to age pipe tobacco (so the oxygen gets consumed).
It seems to me that if the cellophane is kept on, the cigar will be limited to a very little amount of oxygen, so that sounds like a similar case as aging pipe tobacco. But I'd like to know whether oxygen is good for cigar tobacco since the sugar content is likely a lot less than pipe tobacco.
In any event, I'll likely keep the cellophane off simply because I don't like the idea of a synthetic material hugging my tobacco.
Regards,
-JT